The Kumagai Method Utilizing the Pigeon Bottle Feeder with a Long Nipple: A Descriptive Study for the Development of Feeding Techniques for Children with Cleft Lip and/or Palate

Shingo Ueki, Yukari Kumagai, Yumi Hirai, Eri Nagatomo, S. Miyauchi, Takuro Inoue, Qi An, Junko MiyataChildren 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper describes the "Kumagai Method," a specialized feeding technique for infants with cleft lip and/or palate (CLP) using a long-nipple bottle. The study details the method's steps, focusing on optimizing milk intake and infant comfort, and suggests its potential to improve feeding practices for this vulnerable population.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Infants born with cleft lip and/or palate (CLP) often face significant feeding challenges. The anatomical differences in their oral structures impede their ability to create the necessary negative pressure to effectively suck milk from a standard bottle. This can lead to poor weight gain, increased risk of aspiration, and delayed surgical interventions. While various feeding techniques and specialized bottles exist, there's a need for detailed, expert-driven methods that optimize feeding for specific tools like the Pigeon long-nipple bottle, which is less commonly used but offers unique advantages. This paper aims to elucidate such a method, the Kumagai Method, developed by experienced nurses.

Methods

The study employed a descriptive research design, utilizing qualitative data collection and analysis. Five specialist nurses with extensive experience in using the Pigeon long-nipple bottle for CLP infants were recruited. Data was gathered through structured interviews where nurses described their techniques and then demonstrated them using a baby doll. The sessions were video-recorded and analyzed using content analysis. The process involved transcribing audio, documenting movements, coding and categorizing techniques into correct and incorrect movements, and organizing them chronologically. The findings were then validated by the participants to ensure accuracy and adherence to the Kumagai method. Rigor was enhanced through principles of trustworthiness, including verbatim transcripts, researcher neutrality, and consensus-based data interpretation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on expert interviews and demonstrations rather than a formal dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Chokubo-zui" as the Goal: The core objective of the Kumagai method is to encourage "chokubo-zui," a simulated natural breastfeeding tongue movement, which helps infants create negative pressure and achieve efficient milk intake.
  • Long Nipple Specificity: The unique shape and softness of the long nipple require distinct handling compared to standard bottles, necessitating a specialized technique to prevent milk spillage and ensure proper nipple insertion.
  • Holistic Approach: The method encompasses a comprehensive set of techniques, from infant posture and bottle holding to precise nipple insertion and feeding maintenance, all aimed at optimizing the feeding experience.
  • Importance of "Just Point": A specific depth of nipple insertion, termed "just point" (2-3 mm beyond the thicker part of the nipple), is crucial for triggering sucking reflex without causing gagging or discomfort.
  • Timing is Critical: The "tap, swim, push" sequence for milk delivery, lasting approximately 2 seconds, is vital to synchronize with the infant's sucking reflex and prevent missed feeding opportunities.

Key Results

The study successfully detailed the Kumagai method, breaking it down into key stages:

  • Basic Posture: Cuddling the infant close and holding them slightly upright to restrict movement and prevent aspiration.
  • Bottle Holding: Using three fingers to hold the bottle and specifically pinching the nipple between the index and middle fingers at its thicker center to control milk flow.
  • Nipple Insertion: A precise sequence involving horizontal movement, gentle lip contact, and insertion into the mouth to adhere to the lower lip and tongue, aiming for a "just point" depth.
  • Maintaining Feeding: Pinching the nipple in time with the infant's sucking, adjusting pressure to control milk flow, and observing breathing patterns to prevent choking.
  • End of Feeding: A careful, straight pull-out of the nipple to minimize infant discomfort.

The method aims to improve feeding efficiency, increase milk intake, and reduce feeding time for infants with CLP.

Limitations and Future Work

The study acknowledges its limitations:

  • Small Sample Size: Only five specialist nurses participated, which might limit the generalizability of findings.
  • Focus on Nurses: The study exclusively included nurses, potentially overlooking techniques used by other professionals.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Randomized Controlled Trials (RCTs): To quantitatively assess the efficacy of the Kumagai method compared to standard care, measuring outcomes like improved sucking ability, reduced spillage, and better weight gain.
  • Observational Studies: Observing experts instructing parents to identify any unconscious or implicit techniques not captured in interviews.
  • Addressing Infant Resistance: Investigating strategies to overcome resistance or refusal from actual infants to the long-nipple technique.
  • Virtual Reality (VR) Training: Developing VR tools to provide systematic and streamlined educational approaches for parents and healthcare providers to master the Kumagai method, given its current limited use in clinical practice.

Summary updated

Abstract

We aimed to identify the steps involved in the Kumagai method-an experimental nursing procedure to feed children with cleft lip and/or palate, using a feeder with a long nipple. We conducted a descriptive study, enrolling five specialist nurses who have mastered the Kumagai method. Their approaches were examined using structured interviews. Moreover, the participants were asked to perform the sequence of actions involved in this method while describing each step. Therefore, we were able to explore the Kumagai method in depth and step-by-step, including the following aspects: correct infant posture; correct feeding bottle holding position; nipple insertion into the child's mouth; and feeding process initiation, maintenance, and termination. Each step comprises several clinically relevant aspects aimed at encouraging the infant to suck with a closed mouth and stimulating chokubo-zui, i.e., simulation of the natural tongue movement during breastfeeding in children without a cleft palate. In conclusion, when performed correctly, the Kumagai method improves feeding efficiency in children with cleft lip and/or palate. Feeders with long nipples are rarely used in clinical practice; the Kumagai method might popularize their use, thereby improving the management of feeding practices for children with cleft lip and/or palate.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ueki2024kumagai,
  author = {Shingo Ueki and Yukari Kumagai and Yumi Hirai and Eri Nagatomo and S. Miyauchi and Takuro Inoue and Qi An and Junko Miyata},
  title = {{The Kumagai Method Utilizing the Pigeon Bottle Feeder with a Long Nipple: A Descriptive Study for the Development of Feeding Techniques for Children with Cleft Lip and/or Palate}},
  booktitle = {Children},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/children11030365},
}
Figure