The key role of production efficiency changes in livestock methane emission mitigation

Jinfeng Chang, Shushi Peng, Yi Yin, Philippe Ciais, Peter Havlík, Mario Herrero2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals that improving livestock production efficiency, rather than solely focusing on dietary changes, is crucial for mitigating methane emissions. By analyzing historical data and projecting future scenarios, the study highlights that efficiency gains have a significantly greater impact and should be prioritized, especially in developing countries with high mitigation potential.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Livestock production is a major contributor to anthropogenic methane emissions, a potent greenhouse gas. As global demand for meat and dairy products rises, these emissions are projected to increase, posing a significant challenge to climate change mitigation goals. While dietary shifts towards more sustainable options are often discussed, their effectiveness in reducing livestock methane emissions is debated. This paper addresses the critical question of how to best mitigate these emissions by comparing the impact of production efficiency improvements versus demand-side interventions. It aims to quantify the historical trends in livestock methane emissions and emission intensities and project future emissions under various scenarios, specifically investigating the role of production efficiency.

Methods

The authors developed two new global estimates of livestock methane emissions for the period 2000-2018 using updated IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change) guidelines: a "Mixed Tiers" (MT) method combining Tier 1 and Tier 2 approaches, and a Tier 1 method. They then calculated emission intensities, defined as methane emitted per kilogram of protein produced, by integrating these emission estimates with FAOSTAT production data.

A key methodological advancement is the use of the 2019 IPCC refinement, which includes updated emission factors and methodologies for both enteric fermentation (digestion in ruminants) and manure management. The MT method, in particular, incorporates more detailed calculations for enteric fermentation based on gross energy intake and feed digestibility, and for manure management, it considers factors like volatile solids excreted and methane conversion factors.

For future projections, the study employed three socio-economic scenarios (Business As Usual, Stratified Societies, and Toward Sustainability) and two pathways for emission intensity: "constant intensity" and "improving efficiency." The "improving efficiency" pathway was modeled by extrapolating country-specific historical trends of emission intensity changes in relation to GDP per capita growth.

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets:

  • FAOSTAT (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations Statistics Division): Provided data on livestock production quantities (meat, milk) and herd sizes for various animal categories and countries.
  • FAO Global Livestock Environmental Assessment Model (GLEAM) v2.0: Used for protein content of different livestock products.
  • Gridded Livestock of the World v3.0 (GLW3): Provided global spatial distribution data for livestock at a 5 arc-min resolution, used for downscaling national emission estimates to a gridded format.
  • IPCC Guidelines (1997, 2000, 2003, 2006, 2019 Refinement): Served as the basis for emission factors and methodologies for calculating methane emissions.
  • FAO (2018) projections: Used for future projections of livestock production under different socio-economic scenarios.
  • SSP database (Riahi et al., 2017): Used for GDP per capita projections under different socio-economic scenarios.

The study also made their R code and parameter files publicly available on Zenodo for reproducing their estimates and projections.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Efficiency is King: The most striking insight is that improving production efficiency (i.e., producing more protein with less methane) has a far greater potential to mitigate livestock methane emissions than demand-side interventions like dietary changes.
  • Historical Trends Matter: Emission intensity per kg of protein has been decreasing globally for most livestock categories over the past two decades, driven by increasing productivity. This historical trend is a strong indicator of the potential for future mitigation.
  • Methodology Matters: The choice of IPCC methodology (Tier 1 vs. Tier 2, and the 2019 refinement) significantly impacts emission estimates and projections, highlighting the importance of using up-to-date and detailed approaches. The 2019 MT method, which accounts for productivity and liveweight changes, provides a more nuanced understanding of temporal emission trends.
  • Developing Countries Hold the Key: The largest mitigation potential through efficiency improvements lies in developing countries, where current emission intensities are often high and livestock production is projected to increase significantly.
  • Dietary Shifts Alone Are Insufficient: While promoting balanced diets is important for overall sustainability, it will not be enough to meet climate targets without parallel efforts to enhance production efficiency.

Key Results

  • Global Emission Intensity Decrease: Between 2000 and 2018, global livestock methane emission intensity per kg of protein decreased by approximately 9% using the 2019 MT method.
  • Projected Emission Increases: Under a "constant intensity" pathway, global livestock methane emissions are projected to increase by 51%-54% from 2012 to 2050, reaching 186–191 Tg CH4 yr⁻¹.
  • Mitigation Potential of Efficiency: With an "improving efficiency" pathway, global livestock methane emissions are projected to increase by only 15%-21% from 2012 to 2050, reaching 143–150 Tg CH4 yr⁻¹. This represents a substantial mitigation potential.
  • Contribution of Efficiency: The "improving efficiency" pathway can contribute 60%-65% of the global reduction in livestock emissions by 2050, with developing countries accounting for the majority of this potential.
  • Dairy Cows Lead Mitigation: Dairy cows are estimated to contribute the largest share (38%-46%) to emission reductions through efficiency improvements by 2050.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Availability and Regional Differences: The study acknowledges that regional information on production systems and their temporal variations can be limited, leading to assumptions in their modeling. They also note that the FAOSTAT data for some categories (e.g., dairy cows vs. other cattle) were not always separately provided, requiring estimations.
  • Assumptions in Projections: Future projections rely on socio-economic scenarios and assumptions about the continuation of historical trends. The study notes that in some developed countries, there's a possibility of a shift towards more extensive livestock systems, which could lead to an increase in emission intensity, contrary to their "improving efficiency" assumption.
  • Adaptability and Side-Effects: While efficiency improvements offer significant potential, the authors highlight that implementing these strategies requires careful consideration of adaptability issues, potential side-effects (e.g., increased concentrate use, competition with human nutrition), and the need to align with local environmental and social contexts.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that their updated historical emission estimates using the 2019 MT and 2019 T1 methods can serve as valuable references for Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs) in future climate projections. They also emphasize the need to consider country-specific trends and potential deviations from the assumed efficiency improvements. Further research could explore the specific technological and management interventions that drive these efficiency gains in different regions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Earth and Space Science Open Archive This work has been accepted for publication in AGU Advances. Version of RecordESSOAr is a venue for early communication or feedback before peer review. Data may be preliminary. Learn more about preprints. preprintOpen AccessYou are viewing the latest version by default [v1]The key role of production efficiency changes in livestock methane emission mitigationAuthorsJinfengCHANGiDShushiPengiDYiYiniDPhilippeCiaisPetrHavlikMarioHerreroSee all authors Jinfeng CHANGiDCorresponding Author• Submitting AuthorZhejiang UniversityiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-4463-7778view email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressShushi PengiDPeking UniversityiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-5098-726Xview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressYi YiniDCalifornia Institute of TechnologyiDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-4750-4997view email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressPhilippe CiaisUniversité Paris-Saclayview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressPetr HavlikInternational Institute for Applied Systems Analysisview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email addressMario HerreroCommonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organizationview email addressThe email was not providedcopy email address
BibTeX
@misc{chang2021key,
  author = {Jinfeng Chang and Shushi Peng and Yi Yin and Philippe Ciais and Peter Havlík and Mario Herrero},
  title = {{The key role of production efficiency changes in livestock methane emission mitigation}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1002/essoar.10506703.1},
}
Figure