The K-theory type of quantum CW-complexes

Francesco D’Andrea, Piotr M. Hajac, Tomasz Maszczyk, Albert Jeu-Liang Sheu, Bartosz ZielińskiarXiv 2020 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The multipullback quantization of complex projective spaces lacks the naive quantum CW-complex structure because the quantization of an embedding of the $n$-skeleton into the $(n+1)$-skeleton does not exist. To overcome this difficulty, we introduce the framework of cw-Waldhausen categories, which includes the concept of weak equivalences leading to the notion of a finite weak quantum CW-complex in the realm of unital C-algebras. Here weak equivalences are unital $*$-homomorphisms that induce an isomorphism on K-theory. Better still, we construct a noncommutative counterpart of the cup product in K-theory, which is equivalent to its standard version in the classical case. To this end, we define k-topology, a noncommutative version of Grothendieck topology with covering families given by compact principal bundles and bases related by continuous maps, which leads to the much desired idea of multiplicative K-theory for noncommutative C-algebras. Combining this with cw-Waldhausen structure on the category of compact quantum spaces, we arrive at the multiplicative K-theory type of finite weak quantum CW-complexes. We show that non-isomorphic quantizations of the standard CW-complex structure of a complex projective space enjoy the same multiplicative K-theory type admitting a noncommutative generalization of the Atiyah--Todd calculation of the K-theory ring in terms of truncated polynomials.

Introduction

In classical algebraic topology, CW-complexes are the fundamental building blocks of spaces, constructed by inductively "gluing" higher-dimensional disks onto lower-dimensional "skeletons." This structure is essential for calculating K-theory, which describes the topological invariants and "shape" of a space.

However, when moving to the "quantum" or noncommutative realm—where spaces are represented by C-algebras—this construction often breaks down. The algebraic equivalent of an "embedding" of an $n$-skeleton into an $(n+1)$-skeleton often simply does not exist. Furthermore, noncommutative spaces lack a "diagonal map," which is classically required to define the cup product*—the operation that turns K-theory from a simple group into a rich multiplicative ring. This paper introduces a new framework to bridge this gap, allowing researchers to determine if different quantum versions of the same classical space are topologically equivalent.

Methodology: cw-Waldhausen Categories and k-topology

The authors introduce two major theoretical innovations to bypass the hurdles of noncommutative geometry:

  1. cw-Waldhausen Categories: Instead of requiring strict algebraic embeddings between skeletons, the authors use "weak equivalences." These are maps (unital -homomorphisms) that induce an isomorphism on K-theory. By treating these as the "glue," they define weak quantum CW-complexes*, allowing for a "calculus of fractions" that mimics classical homotopy theory even when the underlying algebra is rigid.
  2. k-topology: To recover the multiplicative structure (the cup product), the authors define a noncommutative version of Grothendieck topology. They use compact principal bundles as covering families. In this setting, while one cannot multiply modules over a noncommutative algebra directly, the symmetric bimodules associated with these bundles simulate the tensor product. This allows for the definition of a "multiplicative K-theory type."

Key Insights: Topological Twins and the Atiyah–Todd Picture

A major breakthrough of this work is the proof that diverse quantizations of the same classical space can share a unified identity. The authors demonstrate that the multipullback quantization and the $q$-deformed (Vaksman–Soibelman) quantization of complex projective spaces ($\mathbb{CP}^n$) are K-equivalent. Even though these two algebras are constructed differently and are not isomorphic, they share the exact same multiplicative K-theory type.

Furthermore, the authors successfully generalize the classical Atiyah–Todd calculation. They show that for quantum $\mathbb{CP}^n$, the K-theory ring is isomorphic to a ring of truncated polynomials:

$$K^0(\mathbb{CP}^n) \cong \mathbb{Z}[x]/(x^{n+1})$$

This matches the classical result, proving that the fundamental topological structure is preserved in the quantum setting.

Key Results

  • Unified Framework: Established the definition of a "finite weak quantum CW-complex" in the realm of unital C*-algebras.
  • Multiplicative Recovery: Successfully constructed a noncommutative counterpart to the cup product in K-theory that is equivalent to the standard version in the classical limit.
  • Quantitative Isomorphism: Proved that $K^0(\mathbb{CP}^n) \cong \mathbb{Z}^{n+1}$ and $K^1(\mathbb{CP}^n) \cong 0$, with the ring structure matching the classical truncated polynomial ring.
  • Exotic Examples: Identified "quantum teardrops" (weighted complex projective lines) as examples of quantum CW-complexes that have no direct classical analogue, demonstrating the breadth of the new framework.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research provides a robust foundation for "quantum homotopy theory," bridging the gap between rigid C*-algebras and flexible algebraic topology. While $\mathbb{CP}^n$ is handled thoroughly, applying this to more complex manifolds like general Grassmannians or Flag varieties will require further development of the k-topology machinery. Additionally, extending "Bousfield localization" to the quantum setting remains an open and promising frontier for future investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The multipullback quantization of complex projective spaces lacks the naive quantum CW-complex structure because the quantization of an embedding of the $n$-skeleton into the $(n+1)$-skeleton does not exist. To overcome this difficulty, we introduce the framework of cw-Waldhausen categories, which includes the concept of weak equivalences leading to the notion of a finite weak quantum CW-complex in the realm of unital C*-algebras. Here weak equivalences are unital $*$-homomorphisms that induce an isomorphism on K-theory. Better still, we construct a noncommutative counterpart of the cup product in K-theory, which is equivalent to its standard version in the classical case. To this end, we define k-topology, a noncommutative version of Grothendieck topology with covering families given by compact principal bundles and bases related by continuous maps, which leads to the much desired idea of multiplicative K-theory for noncommutative C*-algebras. Combining this with cw-Waldhausen structure on the category of compact quantum spaces, we arrive at the multiplicative K-theory type of finite weak quantum CW-complexes. We show that non-isomorphic quantizations of the standard CW-complex structure of a complex projective space enjoy the same multiplicative K-theory type admitting a noncommutative generalization of the Atiyah--Todd calculation of the K-theory ring in terms of truncated polynomials.
BibTeX
@misc{dandrea2020k,
  author = {Francesco D’Andrea and Piotr M. Hajac and Tomasz Maszczyk and Albert Jeu-Liang Sheu and Bartosz Zieliński},
  title = {{The K-theory type of quantum CW-complexes}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2002.09015},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2002.09015},
}
Figure