Abstract
As a mixed-methods research in economics and psychology, this study aimed to analyze the influence from the intergenerational succession on the financialization level including asset financialization and revenue financialization, and further test the moderating effect of the heirs' typical growing experience according to The Imprinting Theory, based on the 2009-2020 annual data of listed family enterprises of China. There were two key findings. First, the effect of Chinese family enterprises' intergenerational succession on asset financialization was positively significant while the effect on revenue financialization was not significant, indicating that the financialization behavior has not brought about effective financial profits. Second, among the heirs' typical growing experiences, their parents' entrepreneurial experience during their childhood, oversea study experience, and MBA education experience had the significantly positive moderating effects on the influence from intergeneration succession to asset financialization level of Chinese family enterprises, which was an important internal mechanism for the heirs to promote the financialization process of family enterprises.
Introduction
China’s private economy is currently at a historic crossroads. As the first generation of entrepreneurs who founded businesses in the 1980s reaches retirement age, a massive wave of intergenerational succession is underway. Concurrently, the "New Normal" economy presents challenges such as overcapacity and shrinking profit margins in traditional manufacturing. This environment has led many family-owned firms toward financialization—the reallocation of resources from core business operations to financial channels like stocks, derivatives, and real estate. This study investigates whether the "New Guard" of heirs accelerates this shift and how their personal "imprinted" experiences shape these high-stakes strategic pivots.
Methodology and Data
The researchers employed a mixed-methods approach, blending economics with psychological Imprinting Theory. The study analyzed annual data from 2009 to 2020 for family enterprises listed on China’s A-share market, identifying 158 enterprises that completed a clear succession during this period, resulting in 1,392 specific observation points.
To ensure robust results, the authors utilized:
- Propensity Score Matching (PSM): To create a comparable control group of firms without succession.
- Difference-in-Differences (DID): To isolate the "before and after" effects of succession.
- Moderating Effect Models: To test how specific life experiences amplify or dampen the urge to financialize.
The study distinguishes between two primary metrics: Asset Financialization (FS), which measures the behavior of purchasing financial products, and Revenue Financialization (FR), which measures the actual profit generated from those investments.
Results
The empirical analysis reveals a significant "crowding-out" effect. Following succession, firms see a statistically significant increase in asset financialization (FS). However, this shift does not translate into improved financial performance.
As shown in the descriptive statistics, the mean value for FS is 0.043, while the mean for FR is 0.021. The regression results indicate that while succession leads to a significant jump in financial asset allocation, the effect on revenue (FR) is statistically insignificant. This suggests that while heirs are aggressive in market participation, they are not necessarily achieving superior financial returns—a phenomenon of "effort without reward."
The Power of the "Imprint"
The study identifies three specific life experiences that positively moderate the tendency toward asset financialization:
- Childhood Experience: Heirs who witnessed their parents' early entrepreneurial struggles (the initial stage of the family enterprise) often develop a "rejection" of the labor-intensive real economy, seeking faster profits in finance.
- Overseas Study: Exposure to Western capital markets increases comfort with complex financial instruments but may disconnect heirs from the local "invisible assets" needed for traditional business.
- MBA Education: These programs often instill a mindset viewing the firm as a profit-maximizing machine rather than a long-term legacy, encouraging short-term financial maneuvers.
Discussion and Conclusion
The findings suggest that for many Chinese family firms, financialization may serve as a "legitimacy trap." Heirs may use financial maneuvers to prove their worth quickly, but this often comes at the expense of core business stability and long-term R&D. The "imprints" of Western education and childhood exposure to the hardships of the real economy play a decisive role in steering these enterprises toward speculative financial markets. Ultimately, while heirs are changing corporate strategy, the lack of significant revenue gains from these investments raises questions about the long-term sustainability of this "financialized" succession model.
Summary updated