The Influence of Volunteers’ Psychological Capital: Mediating Role of Organizational Commitment, and Joint Moderating Effect of Role Identification and Perceived Social Support

Li ping Xu, Yu shen Wu, Jing Yu, Jie ZhouFrontiers in Psychology 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that volunteers' psychological capital (their positive mental state) directly boosts their engagement in volunteering and indirectly through organizational commitment. Interestingly, the impact of psychological capital on commitment is significantly influenced by the interplay of role identification and perceived social support, suggesting a nuanced approach is needed to foster volunteer retention.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the critical need to understand and enhance volunteer engagement and sustainability. While volunteerism is vital for societal well-being, factors influencing sustained participation are complex. Previous research has explored motivations, incentives, and values, but the specific role of psychological capital – a concept encompassing self-efficacy, optimism, resilience, and hope – in the context of volunteering remained underexplored. This study aims to bridge this gap by investigating how psychological capital influences volunteering, both directly and indirectly through organizational commitment, and how this relationship is shaped by role identification and perceived social support.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative, cross-sectional survey design. They utilized the PROCESS macro for SPSS (specifically Model 11) to analyze the complex relationships between variables. This statistical approach is well-suited for examining mediation (how one variable influences another through a third variable) and moderated mediation (how the mediating effect is influenced by other variables). They also conducted common method deviation analysis to ensure the reliability of their findings.

Datasets

The study involved a sample of 1165 registered volunteers from China's national volunteer service information system. Participants were recruited from various universities and social worker organizations across multiple provinces. The data was collected via questionnaires.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Psychological Capital is Key: Volunteers' positive psychological outlook isn't just a nice-to-have; it's a significant driver of their commitment and participation in volunteer activities.
  • Organizational Commitment as a Bridge: The link between psychological capital and volunteering isn't always direct. Organizational commitment acts as a crucial mediator, amplifying the positive effects of psychological capital on volunteer engagement.
  • The Nuance of Support and Identity: The impact of psychological capital on commitment isn't uniform. It's significantly moderated by how strongly volunteers identify with their roles and the level of social support they perceive. This suggests that a "one-size-fits-all" approach to volunteer management is unlikely to be effective.
  • The "Overflow" Effect: When volunteers have high levels of both role identification and perceived social support, high psychological capital can paradoxically lead to less organizational commitment. This suggests a potential for resource depletion or an "overflow" effect where too much perceived support might not translate into deeper commitment in these specific contexts.

Key Results

  • Direct Effect: Volunteers' psychological capital had a significant and positive direct effect on their volunteering behavior.
  • Mediating Effect: Organizational commitment significantly mediated the relationship between psychological capital and volunteering, meaning psychological capital influences commitment, which in turn influences volunteering.
  • Moderating Effect: Both role identification and perceived social support individually moderated the relationship between psychological capital and organizational commitment.
  • Joint Moderating Effect: The study found a significant joint moderating effect of role identification and perceived social support on the relationship between psychological capital and organizational commitment.
  • Volunteers with low role identification and low perceived social support, high role identification and low perceived social support, and low role identification and high perceived social support showed stronger organizational commitment when they had high psychological capital.
  • Conversely, volunteers with high role identification and high perceived social support showed stronger organizational commitment when they had low psychological capital.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Cross-sectional Design: The study's cross-sectional nature limits causal inferences. Future research should employ experimental longitudinal designs to establish causality.
  • Age Range: The study included volunteers aged 16-68 but did not account for potential differences between younger and older volunteers (e.g., in life experience, service duration, or attitudes). Comparative studies focusing on these age groups are recommended.
  • Individual Dimensions of Psychological Capital: The study examined psychological capital as a composite construct. Future research could delve into the specific roles of self-efficacy, optimism, resilience, and hope individually.
  • Limited Research on Volunteer Psychological Capital: The relative scarcity of research on psychological capital specifically within volunteer populations means the findings are novel but may lack extensive comparative context. The authors suggest that volunteer psychological capital might possess unique characteristics that warrant further investigation.

The authors encourage future research to explore these areas, particularly focusing on the unique aspects of psychological capital within the volunteer context and employing more robust research designs.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study explores the relationship between volunteers' psychological capital and their commitment to volunteering. We tested whether volunteers' psychological capital had a positive predictive effect on volunteering and whether this effect was mediated by organizational commitment, role identification, or perceived social support. A sample of 1165 volunteers who were registered in the national volunteer service information system of China were recruited in the study. The results showed a significant and positive relationship between volunteers' psychological capital, volunteering, role identification, perceived social support, and organizational commitment. Volunteers' psychological capital not only had a direct effect on volunteering but also affected volunteering through the mediating role of organizational commitment. Additionally, the influence of the volunteers' psychological capital on organizational commitment was affected by the joint moderated effect of role identification and perceived social support. Volunteers with low role identification and low perceived social support, high role identification and low perceived social support, and low role identification and high perceived social support committed to their volunteer organization faster when they had a high level of psychological capital; whereas, volunteers with high role identification and high perceived social support committed to their volunteer organization faster when they had a low level of psychological capital.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2020influence,
  author = {Li ping Xu and Yu shen Wu and Jing Yu and Jie Zhou},
  title = {{The Influence of Volunteers’ Psychological Capital: Mediating Role of Organizational Commitment, and Joint Moderating Effect of Role Identification and Perceived Social Support}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2020.00673},
}
Figure