The Influence of the Built Environment of Neighborhoods on Residents’ Low-Carbon Travel Mode

Caiyun Qian, Yang Zhou, Ze Ji, Qing FengSustainability 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the built environment of neighborhoods influences residents' choices for low-carbon travel modes in Nanjing, China. By analyzing data from 15 neighborhoods, the research identifies key built environment features that promote low-carbon travel and proposes specific recommendations for urban planning to encourage sustainable transportation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Motor vehicle use is a major contributor to CO2 emissions and urban environmental problems. While promoting low-carbon travel is crucial for sustainable urban development, most research on the built environment's influence on travel behavior has focused on the macro-level of entire cities. This paper addresses the gap in understanding how neighborhood-level built environment characteristics specifically impact residents' travel mode choices, particularly in developing countries like China, where rapid urbanization presents unique challenges. The study aims to provide actionable insights for designing neighborhoods that encourage walking, cycling, and public transit use over private car reliance.

Methods

The study employs a three-step methodological approach:

  1. Correlation Analysis: A bivariate Pearson correlation analysis was used to initially identify potential influential variables (both socio-economic attributes and built environment characteristics) that are significantly related to residents' low-carbon travel choices across different travel purposes (commuter, utilitarian, recreational) and overall travel.
  2. Multivariate Logit Regression: A multivariate logit regression model was then applied to further screen and identify the key significant built environment variables. This step accounted for socio-economic attributes as covariates to isolate the independent impact of built environment features.
  3. Unary Linear Regression: Finally, a unary linear regression model was used to establish a quantitative relationship between the identified key built environment variables and residents' low-carbon travel share. This allowed the researchers to propose recommended values for these variables to promote low-carbon travel.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected through:

  • Questionnaire Surveys: A total of 1800 questionnaires were distributed across 15 sample neighborhoods in Nanjing, with 1622 valid responses. These surveys collected data on residents' travel modes (categorized by purpose: commuter, utilitarian, recreational), socio-economic attributes (gender, age, education, income, car ownership), and perceptions of their neighborhood's built environment.
  • Field Surveys: Field observations and measurements were conducted to gather data on built environment attributes.
  • Nanjing Topographic Maps and Land Use Data: These were obtained from the Nanjing Urban Planning Compilation and Research Center to supplement field data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Neighborhood Matters: The study strongly emphasizes that the built environment at the neighborhood level plays a significant role in shaping residents' travel choices, complementing macro-level urban studies.
  • Travel Purpose Specificity: The influence of built environment attributes can vary depending on the purpose of travel (commuting, utilitarian, or recreational). This highlights the need for tailored urban planning strategies.
  • Interplay of Factors: Both socio-economic attributes (like age, education, income, and car ownership) and built environment characteristics are influential. However, the study successfully isolates the impact of the built environment.
  • "3Ds" Extended: The study builds upon the "3Ds" (density, diversity, design) concept by examining specific metrics within land use, road network, and transit facilities.
  • Gated Communities: The inclusion of gated communities in the sample is relevant for developing countries, as this housing type can significantly alter accessibility and travel patterns.

Key Results

  • Land Use: A higher "mixed degree of land use" (combining residential, commercial, and public facilities) was found to be positively and significantly correlated with low-carbon travel for all travel purposes, especially commuting. Building coverage also showed a positive correlation.
  • Road Network: Road network connectivity and road network density were identified as key positive drivers for low-carbon travel. Higher connectivity and density make it easier and more attractive for residents to choose non-motorized or public transport options. Road area ratio was not found to be significant.
  • Transit Facilities: Interestingly, transit station coverage, within the studied radius, did not show a significant correlation with low-carbon travel. The authors suggest this might be due to the generally adequate coverage and distribution of transit stations across the sampled areas, leading to minimal differences.
  • Recommended Values: Based on the findings, the study proposes specific targets for low-carbon travel-oriented neighborhoods:
  • Mixed degree of land use: above 0.736
    • Road network connectivity: above 33.7 points
    • Road network density: above 12.1 km/km²

Limitations and Future Work

  • Origin-Focused: The study primarily focuses on the built environment of the origin neighborhood. The influence of destination environment and actual trip distances, especially for recreational travel, were not fully explored and are suggested for future research.
  • Recreational Travel Nuances: The correlation for recreational travel was less significant, possibly due to the diverse nature of recreational activities and destinations.
  • Generalizability: While the findings are referential, especially for high-density, large-block, and gated communities in developing countries, the authors acknowledge that local conditions and specific characteristics need to be considered for broader application.
  • Other Factors: The study acknowledges that numerous other complex factors influence travel mode choice and suggests further investigation into these.

Summary updated

Abstract

Motor vehicle travel is one of the causes of aggravation of CO2 emission, environmental issues and urban problems. The advocation of low-carbon travel is necessary for the achievement of low-carbon city construction and sustainable development in the future. Many studies have shown that built environment tends to influence residents’ travel behavior, and most studies are demonstrated from the macro level of metropolis. However, from the perspective of neighborhoods, much less attention has been paid, especially in developing countries including China. This study chooses 15 neighborhoods in the main districts of Nanjing in China, taking the location of neighborhoods and residents’ socio-economic attributes into consideration, to examine the effects of residential built environment on residents’ mode choice of different travel types, and to propose the recommended values for the most significant variables. The residential built environment attributes are from three dimensions of land use, road network system and transit facilities. The method of this study is three-step and successive. Primarily, a correlation analysis model is applied to initially examine the role that residents’ socio-economic attributes and residential built environment attributes play on residents’ low-carbon travel of three different travel types respectively. Primary significant attributes from these two aspects are preliminarily screened out for the re-screening in the next step. In addition, the study uses multivariate logit regression modeling approach, with significant socio-economic attributes as concomitant variables, to further re-screen out the key variables of built environment. Furthermore, a unary linear regression model is applied to propose the recommended values for the key built environment variables.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qian2018influence,
  author = {Caiyun Qian and Yang Zhou and Ze Ji and Qing Feng},
  title = {{The Influence of the Built Environment of Neighborhoods on Residents’ Low-Carbon Travel Mode}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/su10030823},
}

Loading related content...

Figure