The influence of power on choice deferral

Xiaoming Li, Song-Yuan JiangAdvances 2019 · DOI

Abstract

<p id="C2">The present study aimed at exploring the role of power in choice deferral (a subcategory of decision avoidance) by studying the moderating role of choice difficulty (Experiment 1) and the mediating role of decision process (Experiment 2). The results showed that choice difficulty can moderate the effect of power on choice deferral, when there is not a dominating option in the choice options, preference for deferral is more pronounced for powerless individuals than for powerful individuals. Additionally, the variance in the proportion of time spent on each attribute mediated the effect of power on choice deferral. The results indicated that lower power can lead to more choice of deferral options (especially in difficult decisions), and decision processing may play an important role in the effect of power on choice deferral.</p>

Introduction

In daily life, individuals frequently encounter "choice deferral"—the decision to postpone a choice or continue searching rather than selecting an available option. While power is known to influence risk-taking and confidence, its impact on decision avoidance has remained less explored. This research utilizes the Approach/Inhibition Theory, which posits that high power activates the behavioral approach system (leading to action), whereas low power activates the behavioral inhibition system (leading to vigilance and avoidance). The study investigates whether power influences the tendency to defer choices and if this relationship is moderated by decision difficulty or mediated by information processing strategies.

Methods

The researchers conducted two laboratory experiments with undergraduate students at Hunan Normal University:

  1. Experiment 1 (Moderation): 120 participants were primed with high or low power via a recall task. They then evaluated an apartment-hunting scenario with two options and a "keep looking" (deferral) option. Difficulty was manipulated by adjusting the attractiveness gap between the primary options.
  2. Experiment 2 (Mediation): 72 participants were assigned roles (Manager vs. Employee) to prime power. They performed a multi-attribute course selection task using MouselabWEB. This tool tracked processing time, depth (percentage of information viewed), pattern (compensatory vs. non-compensatory), and variability (standard deviation of time spent on attributes).

Key Results

The Impact of Power and Difficulty on Deferral

Experiment 1 revealed a significant interaction between power and decision difficulty. When the decision was difficult, 40% of low-power individuals chose to defer, compared to only 10% of high-power individuals. This gap disappeared when the decision was easy, suggesting that power acts as a buffer against the paralysis typically induced by difficult choices.

Deferral rates by power and decision difficulty

Information Processing and Mediation

Experiment 2 demonstrated that low-power individuals adopt more exhaustive and cognitively taxing decision strategies. They spent significantly more time searching (38.8s vs. 26.2s) and viewed a higher percentage of available information (86% vs. 66%) compared to high-power participants. This exhaustive "compensatory" strategy led to higher subjective difficulty indices.

Decision process indicators for high vs. low power groups

Statistical analysis confirmed that processing variability—the degree to which attention is distributed across attributes—mediated the relationship between power and deferral. Low-power individuals distributed their attention more evenly and exhaustively, which predicted their increased tendency to avoid making a final choice.

Discussion and Limitations

The findings suggest that power fundamentally shifts how individuals "crunch the numbers." High-power individuals tend to use simpler, heuristic-based strategies that facilitate faster action. In contrast, low-power individuals engage in "analysis paralysis," where exhaustive processing increases perceived conflict and leads to deferral.

However, the study's reliance on student samples and hypothetical scenarios may limit its ecological validity for high-stakes real-world decisions. Future research should explore other forms of decision avoidance, such as status quo bias, and consider the role of trait-based power or power stability in these dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

<p id="C2">The present study aimed at exploring the role of power in choice deferral (a subcategory of decision avoidance) by studying the moderating role of choice difficulty (Experiment 1) and the mediating role of decision process (Experiment 2). The results showed that choice difficulty can moderate the effect of power on choice deferral, when there is not a dominating option in the choice options, preference for deferral is more pronounced for powerless individuals than for powerful individuals. Additionally, the variance in the proportion of time spent on each attribute mediated the effect of power on choice deferral. The results indicated that lower power can lead to more choice of deferral options (especially in difficult decisions), and decision processing may play an important role in the effect of power on choice deferral.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2019influence,
  author = {Xiaoming Li and Song-Yuan JIANG},
  title = {{The influence of power on choice deferral}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3724/sp.j.1042.2019.00447},
}
Figure