The Influence of Passengers’ Perceived Social Responsibility Efforts on Their Satisfaction in Public-Private-Partnership Urban Rail Transit Projects

Caiyun Cui, Meng Liu, Yong Liu, Bo Xia, Martin Skitmore, Han Guo-boSustainability 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how passengers' perceptions of social responsibility (SR) efforts by Public-Private-Partnership (PPP) urban rail transit (URT) projects influence their satisfaction. The research reveals that SR efforts don't directly impact satisfaction but rather do so indirectly, sequentially mediated by passengers' perceptions of service quality and value. This highlights the importance of not just engaging in SR but effectively communicating it to enhance passenger experience.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As urban rail transit (URT) projects increasingly adopt Public-Private-Partnership (PPP) models to manage large investments and ensure sustainability, understanding passenger satisfaction becomes crucial. While the concept of social responsibility (SR) is recognized as a way to guarantee passenger rights and promote urban development, its specific impact on passenger satisfaction within PPP URT projects remained unclear. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by exploring the mechanisms through which passengers' perceptions of SR efforts translate into their satisfaction with these transit systems.

Methods

The study employed a quantitative approach, utilizing a questionnaire survey to collect data from 436 passengers of three typical PPP URT projects in China. The survey measured passengers' perceptions of SR effort, perceived quality, perceived value, and overall satisfaction using a 5-point Likert scale. The researchers then developed a theoretical framework based on social responsibility and satisfaction theories. Statistical analysis, including bootstrapping and serial multiple mediation modeling, was used to test the proposed hypotheses and examine the direct and indirect relationships between the variables.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from a questionnaire survey administered to 436 passengers of three specific PPP URT projects in China: Beijing No. 4 metro line, Dalian No. 3 rail transit line, and the first-stage project of the Huhehot No. 1 Rail Transit Line. The survey was conducted between March and May 2020.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SR is an Indirect Driver of Satisfaction: The most significant finding is that passengers' perceived social responsibility efforts don't directly lead to satisfaction. Instead, SR acts as an antecedent that influences perceptions of quality and value, which in turn drive satisfaction. This suggests that simply doing good isn't enough; passengers need to perceive the quality and value derived from those SR efforts.
  • The Mediating Power of Quality and Value: Both perceived quality and perceived value play crucial, sequential mediating roles. Passengers' positive perceptions of SR efforts likely lead them to expect and experience better service quality and greater value for their money, ultimately resulting in higher satisfaction.
  • Urban Context Matters: Passengers in non-first-tier cities reported higher levels of perceived SR effort, quality, value, and satisfaction compared to those in first-tier cities. This could be due to higher expectations and more competition in major urban centers.
  • Demographics Influence Value Perception: While many demographic factors didn't significantly impact perceptions, younger passengers (≤25) and students perceived higher value from URT services, possibly due to a greater emphasis on functional and emotional aspects of value rather than just individual affective dimensions.

Key Results

  • Hypothesis 1 (H1) Supported: Perceived SR effort positively influences user satisfaction with PPP URT projects.
  • Hypothesis 2 (H2) Supported: Perceived quality mediates the relationship between perceived SR effort and user satisfaction.
  • Hypothesis 3 (H3) Supported: Perceived value mediates the relationship between perceived SR effort and user satisfaction.
  • Hypothesis 4 (H4) Supported: The relationship between perceived SR effort and user satisfaction is sequentially and doubly mediated by perceived quality and perceived value.
  • Total Effect: The total effect of perceived SR effort on user satisfaction was strong (c = 0.953, p < 0.001).
  • Indirect Effects: All indirect effects were significant. The largest indirect effect was through perceived quality (0.210), followed by perceived value (0.116), and the smallest was the serial effect through both (0.062).
  • Demographic Differences: Passengers in non-first-tier cities showed significantly higher perceptions across all variables (SR, quality, value, satisfaction) compared to those in first-tier cities. Younger passengers and students reported higher perceived value.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that, as with many questionnaire-based studies, the results are impacted by the limited sample capacity. The reliance on an online survey due to the COVID-19 pandemic is also noted as a limitation. Future research could involve more face-to-face surveys for further confirmation. Additionally, the study suggests exploring other project-related antecedents and social responsibility antecedent factors for more effective future management of PPP URT projects. The theoretical framework developed in this study could also be applied to similar PPP infrastructure projects in different contexts.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the rapid development of public-private-partnership (PPP) urban rail transit (URT) projects in China, their social responsibility (SR) is considered to provide a useful way of guaranteeing passengers’ rights and to help urban sustainable development. However, what remains largely unknown is how passengers’ perceptions of the SR effort of such projects’ influences their satisfaction. To bridge this knowledge gap, the current study first proposes a conceptual model based on social responsibility and satisfaction theories. Hypotheses are then tested through bootstrapping analysis based on data drawn from a questionnaire survey of 436 residents from three typical PPP URT projects. The results show that the relationship between the passengers’ perceived SR effort and their satisfaction with PPP URT projects is sequentially and doubly mediated by perceived quality and perceived value. The findings contribute to the current body of knowledge in social responsibility and user satisfaction by introducing passenger-perceived SR effort as an antecedent factor, and offer valuable practical and managerial implications for the projects’ operation management to help promote urban sustainability.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cui2021influence,
  author = {Caiyun Cui and Meng Liu and Yong Liu and Bo Xia and Martin Skitmore and Han Guo-bo},
  title = {{The Influence of Passengers’ Perceived Social Responsibility Efforts on Their Satisfaction in Public-Private-Partnership Urban Rail Transit Projects}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/su132313108},
}
Figure