The Influence of Negative Workplace Gossip on Knowledge Sharing: Insight from the Cognitive Dissonance Perspective

Xiaolei Zou, Xiaoxi Chen, Chen Fengling, Chuxin Luo, Hongyan LiuSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how negative workplace gossip impacts knowledge sharing among employees, proposing that it erodes organizational trust, which in turn hinders knowledge sharing. The research also highlights that employees with higher self-efficacy are better equipped to mitigate these negative effects.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Organizations increasingly recognize knowledge sharing as crucial for sustainable development and competitive advantage. However, informal communication channels, particularly workplace gossip, can complicate this. While gossip is pervasive, its specific impact on knowledge sharing, especially negative gossip, remains underexplored. This paper addresses the gap by examining how negative workplace gossip influences employees' willingness to share knowledge, considering the psychological mechanisms involved. It seeks to understand if gossip acts as a barrier or enabler to formal knowledge sharing and how individual differences might play a role.

Methods

The study employed a two-stage questionnaire survey with 173 Chinese employees. This approach was designed to mitigate common method bias.

  • Stage 1 (T1): Participants completed demographic information and a workplace gossip scale.
  • Stage 2 (T2): A month later, participants filled out scales for organizational trust, self-efficacy, and knowledge sharing.

Statistical analyses included descriptive statistics, correlation analysis, confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) to assess construct validity, and hierarchical regression analysis combined with bootstrapping to test mediation and moderation hypotheses.

Datasets

The study utilized data from a survey of 173 full-time employees in Guangdong province, China. No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Gossip as a Trust-Eroder: Negative workplace gossip, rather than being a neutral information exchange, actively damages an employee's trust in their organization. This is explained through cognitive dissonance theory: when employees engage in behavior (gossiping) that contradicts their self-perception as good employees, they rationalize it by devaluing the organization, leading to decreased trust.
  • Trust as the Bridge to Silence: The erosion of organizational trust directly translates into a reluctance to share knowledge. When employees don't trust their organization, they are less likely to contribute their valuable insights, fearing it might not be valued or could even be used against them.
  • Self-Efficacy as a Buffer: Employees with higher self-efficacy are more resilient to the negative impacts of gossip. They are better equipped to manage the cognitive dissonance, maintain a positive self-view, and are less likely to let decreased organizational trust deter them from sharing knowledge. They can cope with the situation more constructively.
  • Cognitive Dissonance as the Core Mechanism: The study grounds its findings in cognitive dissonance theory, offering a psychological explanation for why negative gossip leads to reduced knowledge sharing, moving beyond simple behavioral observations.

Key Results

  • Negative Workplace Gossip (NWG) negatively impacts Organizational Trust (OT): A significant negative effect was found (β = −0.24, p < 0.01), supporting Hypothesis 1.
  • Organizational Trust (OT) mediates the relationship between NWG and Knowledge Sharing (KS): The study found that NWG negatively influences OT, which in turn negatively influences KS. The mediation was found to be significant and, in fact, a full mediation, meaning OT fully explained the relationship between NWG and KS (indirect effect = –0.222, significant). This supports Hypothesis 2.
  • Self-Efficacy moderates the mediation effect: Self-efficacy significantly moderated the mediation of OT on the NWG-KS relationship. Specifically, the indirect effect of NWG on KS through OT was stronger when self-efficacy was low (effect = −0.078, p < 0.05) compared to when it was high (effect = −0.039, p < 0.05). This supports Hypothesis 3b.
  • Self-Efficacy moderates the relationship between OT and KS: The interaction between OT and self-efficacy was significant (β = −0.23, p < 0.05), indicating that self-efficacy mitigates the positive relationship between OT and KS. This supports Hypothesis 3a.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Implicit Information: The study acknowledges that workplace gossip is often implicit and tacit knowledge sharing is hard to transform into explicit knowledge. Future research could explore willingness to share explicit knowledge after gossip.
  • Scale Development: The workplace gossip scale used, while approved, is still in an exploratory stage in China. Future research could develop more reliable and valid scales for the Chinese context.
  • Self-Reported Data: All measurements were self-reported, introducing potential common-method variance. Longitudinal or laboratory studies are suggested for further verification.
  • Sample Generalizability: The sample was primarily from southern China, limiting generalizability. Future studies should increase sample size, regional scope, and include diverse enterprise types.
  • Control Variables: While some control variables were included, their lack of significant correlation might be due to sample limitations.
  • Additional Mediators/Moderators: The study suggests that other potential mediating and moderating factors exist. Future research could explore cross-level studies considering organizational factors (structure, culture, technology) and individual traits (e.g., dark triad) that influence knowledge sharing dilemmas.

Summary updated

Abstract

Increasing attention is drawn to the effect of workplace gossip on the organization. Negative workplace gossip is a negative evaluation of others behind their back in the workplace. Based on the cognitive dissonance theory, the study explored the relationship between negative workplace gossip and knowledge sharing, through the mediation of organizational trust and the moderation of self-efficacy. The regression results of a two-stage questionnaire survey on 173 Chinese employees suggested that negative workplace gossip negatively influenced employees’ knowledge sharing through organizational trust. Additionally, findings also showed that self-efficacy moderated the mediation of organizational trust in the relationship between negative workplace gossip and knowledge sharing. This research provided a new theoretical perspective on the impact of workplace gossip, which has management implications for informal communication and team-building.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zou2020influence,
  author = {Xiaolei Zou and Xiaoxi Chen and Chen Fengling and Chuxin Luo and Hongyan Liu},
  title = {{The Influence of Negative Workplace Gossip on Knowledge Sharing: Insight from the Cognitive Dissonance Perspective}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su12083282},
}
Figure