The influence of model parameters on the prediction of gravitational wave signals from stellar core collapse

Simon Scheidegger, Roger Käppeli, S. C. Whitehouse, Tobias Fischer, M. LiebendörferSpringer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology) 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive 3D simulation study of stellar core collapse supernovae, investigating how various physical parameters (equation of state, rotation, magnetic fields, and neutrino physics) influence the predicted gravitational wave (GW) signals. The findings highlight the crucial role of postbounce neutrino physics and suggest that while some GW features can distinguish between different physics, a full understanding requires advanced detectors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Stellar core-collapse supernovae are cataclysmic events that release immense energy, a significant portion of which is expected to be emitted as gravitational waves (GWs). However, predicting the precise GW signal from these events is incredibly challenging due to the complex physics involved, including the behavior of matter under extreme densities (equation of state), the initial rotation of the star, the presence and evolution of magnetic fields, and the intricate processes of neutrino emission and absorption. These uncertainties make it difficult to interpret potential GW observations and use them to probe the physics of supernovae. This paper aims to systematically explore how variations in these key physical parameters affect the predicted GW signatures, providing a more nuanced understanding of what GW detectors might observe and what information can be extracted.

Methods

The authors employed a suite of 25 three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamical (MHD) simulations of stellar core collapse. These simulations utilized a 15 solar mass progenitor model and incorporated several key physics treatments:

  • Equations of State (EoS): Two main finite-temperature EoS were used: Lattimer-Swesty (LS) with varying compressibilities and the Shen EoS.
  • Neutrino Physics: A parameterized deleptonization scheme was used for the collapse phase, accurate up to about 5 ms postbounce. For three representative models, a more sophisticated "leakage" scheme based on the Isotropic Diffusion Source Approximation (IDSA) was implemented for longer-term neutrino physics.
  • General Relativistic Potential: A spherically symmetric effective general relativistic potential was used to account for gravitational effects.
  • Magnetic Fields: Both toroidal and poloidal magnetic fields were included, with strengths varied to explore their influence.
  • Rotation: Initial rotation rates were systematically varied.
  • Gravitational Wave Extraction: GW signals were extracted using the quadrupole formula, with different formulations employed and compared for robustness.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on numerical simulations rather than observational datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Postbounce Neutrino Physics is Crucial: Including neutrino physics beyond the initial collapse phase (e.g., via a leakage scheme) significantly alters the GW signal, potentially by a factor of 10, making it indispensable for quantitative predictions.
  • Prompt Convection as a GW Source: In non-rotating or slowly rotating models, GWs are primarily generated by prompt convection in the proto-neutron star (PNS) within the first ~30 ms after bounce. This convection is driven by negative entropy gradients.
  • EoS Imprints on Prompt Convection GWs: The GW signal from prompt convection can indirectly distinguish between the LS and Shen EoS. LS models tend to produce GWs in a higher frequency band (~150-500 Hz) compared to Shen models (~150-350 Hz). However, current detectors like LIGO may not be sensitive enough to fully resolve these differences.
  • Rotation and Type I GW Bursts: Moderate to rapid rotation leads to a characteristic "type I" GW burst at core bounce, with amplitude scaling roughly linearly with the ratio of rotational to gravitational energy (below ~10%).
  • Low T/|W| Instability and Narrow-Band GWs: Faster rotation rates (≥ 2π rad/s) can trigger non-axisymmetric, narrow-band GW emission during the postbounce phase due to a low T/|W| dynamical instability in the PNS.
  • Magnetic Field Effects Vary: Weak magnetic fields have little impact on the GW signal. However, strong initial poloidal fields (≥ 10¹² G) can lead to jet-like explosions and a "type IV" GW signal with a characteristic memory effect. Conversely, strong toroidal fields can counteract jet formation.
  • Degeneracy in GW Signals: It is generally difficult to unambiguously attribute specific GW signal features to individual input physics parameters, especially in rotating models, due to a significant degeneracy in the results.

Key Results

  • Amplitude Alterations: Postbounce neutrino physics can alter GW amplitudes by up to a factor of 10.
  • Frequency Bands for EoS: Prompt convection GWs from LS EoS peak around 150-500 Hz, while Shen EoS models peak around 150-350 Hz.
  • Rotation and Amplitude: For rotation rates below ~10%, maximum GW amplitude at bounce scales roughly linearly with the rotation rate.
  • Detectability: Galactic core-collapse supernovae are potentially detectable by LIGO (if rotating) or advanced LIGO (even if not or slowly rotating), with Signal-to-Noise Ratios (SNRs) of at least unity for some models at 10 kpc.
  • Strong Magnetic Field Impact: Strong poloidal fields can lead to type IV GW signals, while strong toroidal fields can suppress jet formation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Neutrino Physics Approximations: The parameterized deleptonization scheme is only accurate for the initial collapse phase. The leakage scheme, while improving postbounce treatment, overestimates neutrino cooling. Future work will include more complete neutrino transport, including electron neutrino scattering and μ/τ neutrinos.
  • Newtonian Gravity: The use of a Newtonian gravitational potential, even with relativistic corrections, is a limitation. The authors acknowledge that for phenomena like jet formation, a full general relativistic treatment might be necessary.
  • Grid Resolution: The uniform grid resolution may underresolve the PNS surface, potentially affecting the development and GW signal of instabilities.
  • Degeneracy: The significant degeneracy in GW signals with respect to various parameters makes it challenging to uniquely identify the progenitor's properties from GW observations alone.

The authors plan to improve the postbounce neutrino physics in future simulations and investigate the inclusion of spiral structures in the gravitational potential.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a gravitational wave (GW) analysis of an extensive series of three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamical core-collapse simulations. Our 25 models are based on a 15 $M_{\odot}$ progenitor stemming from (i) stellar evolution calculations; (ii) a spherically symmetric effective general relativistic potential, either the Lattimer-Swesty (with three possible compressibilities) or the Shen equation of state for hot, dense matter; and (iii) a neutrino parametrisation scheme that is accurate until about 5 ms postbounce. For three representative models, we also included long-term neutrino physics by means of a leakage scheme, which is based on partial implementation of the isotropic diffusion source approximation (IDSA). We systematically investigated the effects of the equation of state, the initial rotation rate, and both the toroidal and the poloidal magnetic fields on the GW signature. We stress the importance of including of postbounce neutrino physics, since it quantitatively alters the GW signature. Slowly rotating models, or those that do not rotate at all, show GW emission caused by prompt and proto-neutron star (PNS) convection. Moreover, the signal stemming from prompt convection allows for the distinction between the two different nuclear equations of state indirectly by different properties of the fluid instabilities. For simulations with moderate or even fast rotation rates, we only find the axisymmetric type I wave signature at core bounce. In line with recent results, we could confirm that the maximum GW amplitude scales roughly linearly with the ratio of rotational to gravitational energy at core bounce below a threshold value of about 10%. We point out that models set up with an initial central angular velocity of 2π rad s-1 or faster show nonaxisymmetric narrow-band GW radiation during the postbounce phase. This emission process is caused by a low T/|W| dynamical instability. Apart from these two points, we show that it is generally very difficult to discern the effects of the individual features of the input physics in a GW signal from a rotating core-collapse supernova that can be attributed unambiguously to a specific model. Weak magnetic fields do not notably influence the dynamical evolution of the core and thus the GW emission. However, for strong initial poloidal magnetic fields (≳1012 G), the combined action of flux-freezing and field winding leads to conditions where the ratio of magnetic field pressure to matter pressure reaches about unity which leads to the onset of a jet-like supernova explosion. The collimated bipolar out-stream of matter is then reflected in the emission of a type IV GW signal. In contradiction to axisymmetric simulations, we find evidence that nonaxisymmetric fluid modes can counteract or even suppress jet formation for models with strong initial toroidal magnetic fields. The results of models with continued neutrino emission show that including of the deleptonisation during the postbounce phase is an indispensable issue for the quantitative prediction of GWs from core-collapse supernovae, because it can alter the GW amplitude up to a factor of 10 compared to a pure hydrodynamical treatment. Our collapse simulations indicate that corresponding events in our Galaxy would be detectable either by LIGO, if the source is rotating, or at least by the advanced LIGO detector, if it is not or only slowly rotating.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{scheidegger2010influence,
  author = {Simon Scheidegger and Roger Käppeli and S. C. Whitehouse and Tobias Fischer and M. Liebendörfer},
  title = {{The influence of model parameters on the prediction of gravitational wave signals from stellar core collapse}},
  booktitle = {Springer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology)},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1051/0004-6361/200913220/pdf},
}
Figure