The Influence of Interior Structure and Thermal State on Impact Melt Generation Upon Large Impacts Onto Terrestrial Planets

Lukas Manske, Thomas Ruedas, Ana‐Catalina Plesa, Philipp Baumeister, Nicola Tosi, N. A. Artemieva, K. WünnemannJournal of Geophysical Research Planets 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how a planet's internal structure and thermal history influence the amount of melt generated by large impacts. By combining thermal evolution models with detailed 2D impact simulations, the authors reveal that planet size and impactor size have a complex, inversely related effect on melting efficiency, and they propose new empirical formulas to better predict melt generation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding impact melt generation is crucial for deciphering planetary evolution, as it plays a role in processes like magma ocean formation and crustal evolution. Previous models often simplified target planets as homogeneous and isothermal, which is unrealistic. This paper addresses the need for a more nuanced understanding by accounting for the significant influence of a planet's radial structure (crust, mantle, core) and its thermal state (age, temperature distribution) on the amount of melt produced during impacts. Specifically, it aims to improve upon existing "scaling laws" that often underestimate melt production in complex planetary environments.

Methods

The authors employ a two-pronged approach:

  1. Planetary Thermal and Structural Evolution Modeling: They use parameterized convection models to simulate the global thermal evolution of generic terrestrial planets of varying sizes and core-to-planet radius ratios over billions of years. This generates detailed thermal profiles and crustal thicknesses at different ages.
  2. 2D Impact Simulations: The pre-impact thermal states and structures are then used as input for fully dynamical 2D impact simulations using the iSALE2D shock physics code. These simulations track the thermodynamic state of the material, accounting for three melting mechanisms: shock melting, decompression melting, and plastic work melting. A novel Lagrangian tracer method is used to quantify melt volumes and their origins.

Datasets

The study uses a combination of:

  • Generic Planetary Models: A range of planet sizes (0.1 to 1.5 Earth radii) and core size ratios (0.2, 0.5, 0.8) are modeled.
  • Thermal Evolution Data: Thermal profiles are generated at 1, 3, and 4.5 billion years after planet formation.
  • Impactor Flux Data: The lunar impactor flux is used to estimate cumulative melt production over geological timescales.
  • Material Properties: Equations of state (M-ANEOS) and material properties for basalt (crust) and dunite (mantle) are used, based on existing experimental data and literature.

No new benchmark datasets are introduced; rather, the study generates its own simulation data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Divergent Melting Efficiency: Larger planets are more efficient at generating melt when struck by smaller impactors, while smaller planets are more efficient with larger impactors. This counter-intuitive finding is linked to the interplay of lithosphere thickness and thermal/pressure profiles.
  • Earth-like Planets are Melt Maxima: Melting efficiency peaks are generally highest on Earth-sized planets.
  • Core Size Matters (Sometimes): Core size ratio only significantly affects melt production for large cores and older planets, where it leads to decreased melt.
  • Beyond Shock Melting: Decompression and plastic work melting can contribute significantly to total melt, especially for larger impactors, and traditional scaling laws that only consider shock melting are insufficient.
  • Age Matters: As planets cool over time, impact-induced melt production substantially decreases.
  • Moon-sized Planets Accumulate Most Melt (Relatively): When considering cumulative melt over their evolution, Moon-sized planets produce the most melt relative to their volume.

Key Results

  • Melting efficiency decreases significantly with planetary age (40-60% reduction from 1 to 4.5 Gyr).
  • Plastic work melting can contribute up to 20-30% of the total melt, and decompression melting up to 50%.
  • Empirical formulas are proposed to predict melt generation as a function of radial structure and thermal age, improving upon existing scaling laws.
  • For a lunar impactor flux, Moon-sized planets accumulate the most melt relative to their volume over 4.5 Gyr.

Limitations and Future Work

  • 2D Simulations: The study is limited to 2D simulations, meaning impact angles are restricted to 90°. While 3D simulations could reveal more complex effects, the authors argue that the general trends are captured.
  • Single Impact Velocity: A single impact velocity (15 km/s) was used, though scaling relations are discussed to account for variations.
  • No Vaporization/Ejecta Loss: The models do not explicitly track vaporization or the permanent loss of melt/ejecta, though their impact is discussed as likely minor for most scenarios.
  • Extrapolation Limits: The derived scaling laws should not be extrapolated to impactor sizes comparable to the target planet (e.g., Moon-forming event) or to very different target conditions.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest incorporating thermal profiles, solidus/liquidus functions, and equations of state more directly into future parameterizations. Further investigation into the effects of impact angle and velocity on melt production is also warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We investigate the melt production of planetary impacts as a function of planet size ( = 0.1–1.5), impactor size ( = 1–1,000 km), and core size ratio ( = 0.2–0.8) using a combination of parameterized convection models and fully dynamical 2D impact simulations. To this end, we introduce a new method to determine impact‐induced melt volumes which we normalize by the impactor volume for better comparability. We find that this normalized melt production, or melting efficiency, is enhanced for large planets when struck by smaller impactors, while for small planets, melting efficiency is elevated when impacted by larger impactors. This diverging behavior can be explained by the thickness of the planets' thermal boundary layer and the shapes of their thermal and lithostatic pressure profiles. We also find that melting efficiency maxima are usually highest on Earth‐size planets. We show that the melting efficiency is only affected by core size ratio for large cores and older planets, where melt production is decreased significantly compared to smaller core size ratios. Projecting the lunar impactor flux on the generic planets, we find that Moon‐sized planets produce the most melt throughout their evolution, relative to planet volume. Contrary to previous scaling laws, our method accounts for melt production by decompression or plastic work in addition to shock melting. We find that traditional scaling laws underestimate melt production on length scales where variations in the target planets' lithology, temperature, and lithostatic pressure become significant. We propose empirical formulas to predict melt generation as a function of radial structure and thermal age.
BibTeX
@article{manske2025influence,
  author = {Lukas Manske and Thomas Ruedas and Ana‐Catalina Plesa and Philipp Baumeister and Nicola Tosi and N. A. Artemieva and K. Wünnemann},
  title = {{The Influence of Interior Structure and Thermal State on Impact Melt Generation Upon Large Impacts Onto Terrestrial Planets}},
  journal = {Journal of Geophysical Research Planets},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1029/2024je008481},
}
Figure