The influence of general practitioners on access points to health care in a system without gatekeeping: a cross-sectional study in the context of the QUALICOPC project in Austria

Kathryn Hoffmann, Aaron George, Tessa van Loenen, Jan De Maeseneer, Manfred MaierCroatian 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

In Austria's healthcare system, where patients have direct access to specialists without needing a GP referral, specialist visits are very common. Even having a regular GP doesn't significantly reduce these self-referrals, especially for patients with chronic conditions, who also show higher rates of emergency department visits. This highlights that simply having a GP isn't enough to effectively manage patient flow and coordinate care in such a system.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper investigates how the absence of a "gatekeeping" system, where General Practitioners (GPs) act as the primary point of contact and referral to specialists, influences patient access to healthcare. Specifically, it examines the rates of specialist visits and emergency department (ED) visits in Austria, a country with open access to healthcare. The study aims to understand if having a usual GP, or having a chronic condition, impacts these access patterns, and whether the GP's role is sufficient to regulate patient pathways within the healthcare system. This is crucial because while gatekeeping systems can prevent unnecessary visits, they can also lead to delays. Conversely, open-access systems might lead to overutilization of specialist and emergency services, potentially increasing costs and fragmenting care, especially for patients with complex needs like those with chronic diseases.

Methods

This study employed a cross-sectional questionnaire design as part of the larger QUALICOPC project. Fieldworkers recruited 1596 consecutive patients from 184 GP offices across Austria. The survey collected data on patients' experiences with primary care access, coordination, and continuity, along with demographic information and health status. Key questions focused on whether patients had a usual GP, the frequency of their GP and specialist visits in the past year, and their reasons for visiting emergency departments. Statistical analysis involved descriptive statistics, univariate, and multivariable logistic regression models to assess the influence of having a usual GP and chronic conditions on specialist and ED visits, while controlling for other factors.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the QUALICOPC project, a multi-country initiative assessing primary care quality, costs, and equity. In Austria, data was collected between November 2011 and May 2012. The dataset comprised patient experience questionnaires from 1596 participants recruited from 184 GP offices. No new datasets were introduced by this specific paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • GP as a "Usual Source of Care" is Insufficient: The study strongly suggests that simply having a GP whom patients typically consult first is not enough to regulate access to specialist care or prevent unnecessary ED visits in an open-access system.
  • High Specialist Utilization is the Norm: Austria's system, lacking gatekeeping, leads to a very high rate of specialist visits, even for routine issues, which is significantly higher than in countries with gatekeeping.
  • Chronic Conditions Complicate Access: Patients with chronic diseases are more likely to visit specialists and, crucially, are also more likely to present to the ED, even when they have a usual GP. This indicates a potential breakdown in care coordination for these vulnerable patients.
  • GP Awareness Gap: A significant portion of patients reported that their GP was not informed about the results of specialist visits, highlighting a major flaw in care continuity and coordination.
  • Perceived ED Benefits: Patients sometimes opt for the ED due to a belief that it provides better or faster care, or that their condition is beyond a GP's scope, suggesting potential misunderstandings about GP capabilities or unmet patient expectations.

Key Results

  • Over 90% of patients identified having a usual GP.
  • 85.5% of all participants had visited a specialist at least once in the previous year, with 38.3% visiting a specialist three or more times.
  • 26.4% of participants had consulted a hospital ED at least once in the previous year.
  • Having a usual GP did not significantly decrease the likelihood of visiting a specialist.
  • However, having a usual GP was associated with a significantly increased likelihood of visiting an ED, even after adjusting for other factors (OR 2.33, 95% CI 1.14-4.77).
  • Patients with chronic diseases were significantly more likely to visit specialists and the ED. In the adjusted model, chronic disease was associated with a higher likelihood of ED visits (OR 1.85, 95% CI 1.31-2.60).
  • Female sex, secondary education level, and frequent GP visits (5+ times in the past year) were associated with higher specialist visits.
  • Younger age (18-40) and frequent GP visits were associated with higher ED visits.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Selection Bias: The study sample consisted of patients recruited from GP offices on a voluntary basis, which might have led to an underestimation of specialist visits and an overestimation of patients with a usual GP, as those who actively avoid GPs might not have been included.
  • Memory Bias: The retrospective nature of the questionnaire could introduce memory bias.
  • Limited Assessment of Reasons: The reasons for specialist visits were not fully assessed beyond the presence of chronic disease.
  • Representativeness: The demographic distribution of the sample was not fully representative of the Austrian population, limiting generalizability.

Future work could focus on developing strategies to incentivize patients to follow optimal pathways, improve primary care organization (e.g., extended office hours), and implement system-level changes like gatekeeping processes or financial incentives to better regulate access and improve care coordination, particularly for chronic care patients. Further investigation into patient perceptions of ED versus GP care is also warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Visiting specialists in Austria is quite common, and the simple presence of a GP as a usual source of care is insufficient to regulate pathways within the health care system. This can be particularly difficult for chronic care patients who often require care at different levels of the system and show higher frequency of ED presentations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hoffmann2019influence,
  author = {Kathryn Hoffmann and Aaron George and Tessa van Loenen and Jan De Maeseneer and Manfred Maier},
  title = {{The influence of general practitioners on access points to health care in a system without gatekeeping: a cross-sectional study in the context of the QUALICOPC project in Austria}},
  booktitle = {Croatian},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3325/cmj.2019.60.316},
}

Loading related content...

Figure