The Influence of Event Valence and Emotional States on the Metaphorical Comprehension of Time

Weiqi Zheng, Ye Liu, Chang Hong Liu, Yu‐Hsin Chen, Qian Cui, Xiaolan FuFrontiers in Psychology 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how our emotions influence our understanding of time, specifically through spatial metaphors like "moving forward." They found that positive future events make us favor an "ego-moving" perspective (we move through time), while negative events can shift us towards a "time-moving" perspective (time moves towards us). Crucially, the motivation behind our current emotions (approach vs. avoidance) also plays a significant role, especially when thinking about neutral future events.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

We often talk about time using spatial language: "the future is ahead," "we're running out of time," or "the deadline is approaching." This is known as the temporal-spatial metaphor. Within this, two main ways of conceptualizing time's movement exist: the "ego-moving" perspective, where we move through time (e.g., "I'm approaching my birthday"), and the "time-moving" perspective, where time moves towards us (e.g., "my birthday is approaching me"). While previous research suggests emotions influence this choice (positive emotions favoring ego-moving, negative favoring time-moving), it was unclear if this was due to the valence (positive/negative) of the emotion or its underlying motivational dimension (approach vs. avoidance). This paper aims to disentangle these factors.

Methods

The researchers conducted two main studies.

Study 1: Participants were exposed to short scenarios describing future events with either positive (happiness), negative-approach (anger), or negative-avoidance (anxiety) emotional valence. They then answered two types of questions designed to reveal their temporal perspective:

  1. Ambiguous Temporal Question: A classic linguistic puzzle (e.g., "The meeting originally scheduled for next Wednesday has been moved forward two days. What day is it now?"). Answers like "Friday" suggest ego-moving, while "Monday" suggests time-moving.
  2. Visualized Schema Question: Participants viewed diagrams illustrating the ego-moving and time-moving perspectives, accompanied by descriptive sentences.

Study 2 (split into 2a and 2b): This study focused on how current emotional states influence the perception of neutral future events. Participants were induced into happy, angry, or anxious states using either short stories (2a) or by recalling and writing about personal emotional experiences (2b). They then answered the same two types of temporal perspective questions as in Study 1.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized participant responses to experimental stimuli (scenarios, stories, questions) rather than pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Valence Matters for Future Events: When thinking about a future event, the emotional valence (positive vs. negative) seems to be the primary driver of temporal perspective. Positive future events strongly encourage an ego-moving view.
  • Motivation Dominates for Neutral Events: When contemplating a neutral future event, the motivational dimension of our current emotional state is more influential. Approach-motivated emotions (happiness, anger) lean towards ego-moving, while avoidance-motivated emotions (anxiety) lean towards time-moving.
  • Anger is Complex: Anger, a negative emotion, can sometimes align with approach motivation, leading to an ego-moving perspective, especially when participants are prompted to recall or write about their experiences (Study 2b).
  • Method Matters: The way emotions are induced can influence results. Recalling and writing about experiences (Study 2b) seemed to create stronger emotional states than reading short stories (Study 2a), leading to more pronounced effects on temporal perspective.
  • Cultural Nuances in Ambiguity: The classic ambiguous temporal question, which shows mixed results in English speakers, appears less ambiguous in Chinese, with participants consistently favoring the ego-moving perspective. This highlights how language and culture can shape even abstract cognitive processes.

Key Results

Study 1 (Future Event Valence): * Ambiguous Temporal Question: Participants in the happy group overwhelmingly chose the ego-moving perspective ("Friday"). Angry and anxious groups also showed a preference for ego-moving, though less pronounced than the happy group. * Visualized Schema Question: The happy group strongly favored ego-moving. However, for the angry and anxious groups, there was no significant preference between ego-moving and time-moving. * Overall: Emotional valence of future events influenced perspective choice, with positive events strongly promoting ego-moving.

Study 2a (Induced Emotional State - Stories): * Ambiguous Temporal Question: Across all groups (happy, angry, anxious), participants strongly preferred the ego-moving perspective. * Visualized Schema Question: No significant preference was found for either ego-moving or time-moving in any of the emotional groups. * Overall: Inducing emotions via stories didn't strongly differentiate temporal perspectives, especially on the visualized schema.

Study 2b (Induced Emotional State - Writing): * Ambiguous Temporal Question: Happy and angry groups strongly preferred ego-moving. The anxious group showed no significant preference. * Visualized Schema Question: The anxious group significantly preferred the time-moving perspective. Happy and angry groups showed no significant preference. * Overall: When participants actively recalled and wrote about emotions, avoidance motivation (anxiety) clearly led to a time-moving perspective for neutral events.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Intertwined Factors: The study acknowledges that in real life, event valence and current emotional state are often entangled. Future research should explore their interaction.
  • Individual Differences: Participants were not distinguished by personality traits like behavioral approach/avoidance sensitivity or alexithymia. Future studies could investigate how these individual differences mediate the observed effects.
  • Ecological Validity: While the study aimed for higher ecological validity than previous work, future research could explore more complex, real-world scenarios.
  • Consistency of Questions: The authors note that the visualized schema and ambiguous temporal questions sometimes yielded different results, suggesting they might tap into slightly different cognitive processes. Further work could explore why this consistency varies.
  • Cultural Specificity: The findings regarding the ambiguous temporal question in Chinese suggest cultural differences in how this metaphor is interpreted, warranting further cross-linguistic investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Time is generally conceptualized in terms of space as reflected in temporal-spatial metaphors. Two observation perspectives have been proposed in the front-back axis of the temporal-spatial metaphor. One is called "ego-moving perspective" and the other "time-moving perspective." They are used to represent different relative motion between time and the observer. Previous studies have demonstrated the psychological reality of both perspectives. They also provided evidence that emotion can influence a perspective choice. In general, a positive emotion tends to facilitate the adoption of ego-moving perspective, whereas, a negative emotion tends to promote the adoption of time-moving perspective. However, it is unclear how the motivational dimension of emotion might influence the preference. The current study aimed to address the question by identifying conditions in which emotional valence or motivational attribute affects the choice of time movement perspective. An ambiguous temporal question and a visualized time motion schema were adopted to probe participants' metaphorical representation of time when they were affected by emotion. Study 1 investigated how a future emotional event would affect participants' choice of the time movement perspective. The results showed that positive future events led to a higher propensity to adopt an ego-moving perspective compared with negative future events. Study 2 explored participants' tendency to choose time movement perspective for a vague or neutral future event, after they were induced into a particular emotional state. The results showed that when being in an emotional state of approach-motivation individuals were more likely to adopt an ego-moving perspective. In contrast, being in an emotional state of avoidance-motivation, individuals were more likely to take a time-moving perspective. Taken together, these results suggest that the emotional valence of future events can influence the choice of time movement perspectives; and the motivational dimension of present emotional states plays an important role when contemplating a neutral future event.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zheng2019influence,
  author = {Weiqi Zheng and Ye Liu and Chang Hong Liu and Yu‐Hsin Chen and Qian Cui and Xiaolan Fu},
  title = {{The Influence of Event Valence and Emotional States on the Metaphorical Comprehension of Time}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00410},
}
Figure