The Influence of COVID-19 on Irrational Consumption Behavior in a Chinese Sample: Based on a Serial Mediating Model

Hu Yue-Qian, Xie Piao, Wang Ying, Zhixin Huang, Yi-Ting Wu, Hailong SunFrontiers in Psychology 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the perceived severity of the COVID-19 pandemic influences irrational consumer behavior in China. It reveals that while pandemic severity doesn't directly predict irrational buying, it significantly impacts it through a serial mediation of perceived scarcity and negative mentality. This highlights how fear and resource concerns during crises can drive impulsive purchasing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic, like other public health emergencies, has been associated with widespread irrational consumption behaviors (ICB), such as panic buying of essential goods. While previous research has explored general factors influencing ICB (e.g., personal characteristics, marketing stimuli), there's a need for a clearer understanding of how severe public health crises specifically trigger these behaviors. This paper aims to bridge this gap by examining the psychological mechanisms through which the perceived severity of a pandemic, like COVID-19, leads to ICB, focusing on the mediating roles of perceived scarcity and negative mentality.

Methods

The researchers employed a cross-sectional online survey to collect data from 466 participants in China. They utilized established scales to measure:

  • Perceived Pandemic Severity (PPS): Assessed through questions about the number of casualties, scope of spread, and duration of the pandemic.
  • Perceived Scarcity (PS): Measured using a 5-item scale focusing on the perceived insufficiency of resources.
  • Negative Mentality (NM): Assessed with an 8-item scale adapted from research on SARS, capturing feelings of nervousness and fear related to the epidemic.
  • Irrational Consumption Behavior (ICB): Measured with a 4-item scale assessing impulsiveness and blindness in purchasing decisions.

Statistical analyses included correlation, reliability tests, confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) to establish discriminant validity, and serial mediation analysis using Hayes' PROCESS macro to test the proposed model. Control variables such as gender, age, and family income were also considered.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 466 participants in China via an online questionnaire administered through Wenjuanwang, a Chinese online survey platform. No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Scarcity as a Driver: The study strongly supports the scarcity theory, demonstrating that when individuals perceive a lack of resources (due to a pandemic), their decision-making is significantly altered, leading to irrational behaviors.
  • The Power of Perception: It's not just the objective reality of a pandemic, but how individuals perceive its severity that matters. This perception acts as the initial trigger.
  • Fear and Uncertainty Fuel Buying: Negative mentality, characterized by anxiety and fear stemming from the pandemic, plays a crucial role in amplifying the link between perceived scarcity and irrational buying.
  • Serial Mediation is Key: The most impactful pathway identified is the serial mediation: perceived pandemic severity leads to perceived scarcity, which in turn fosters a negative mentality, ultimately culminating in irrational consumption behavior. This suggests a cascading effect.

Key Results

  • Direct Effect is Not Significant: Perceived pandemic severity (PPS) did not directly predict irrational consumption behavior (ICB).
  • Indirect Effects are Significant:
    • Perceived scarcity (PS) significantly mediated the relationship between PPS and ICB (Hypothesis 2 supported).
  • Negative mentality (NM) significantly mediated the relationship between PPS and ICB (Hypothesis 3 supported).
  • PS and NM acted as serial mediators, with PPS influencing ICB through the sequence of PS → NM (Hypothesis 4 supported).
  • Quantitative Findings: The study reported various correlation coefficients and mediation effect sizes (e.g., indirect effect of PPS on ICB via PS and NM: b=0.037, boot SE=0.014, 95% CI = (0.014, 0.071)). The direct effect of PPS on ICB was found to be non-significant (β = -0.049, SE=0.069, p=0.479).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cross-Sectional Design: The study's cross-sectional nature limits causal inference and makes it difficult to entirely rule out common method bias. Future research could employ longitudinal or experimental designs.
  • Self-Reported Data: Reliance on questionnaires means data is self-reported, which can be subject to recall bias and social desirability. Collecting data during actual purchasing events would be beneficial.
  • Cultural Specificity: The study was conducted in China. While psychological constructs are often generalizable, sociocultural factors can influence ICB. Future work should explore cross-cultural comparisons.
  • Other Mediators: The authors suggest exploring other potential mediators, such as individual differences (e.g., personality traits) and governmental interventions/credibility, which could further explain the influence of pandemics on ICB.

Summary updated

Abstract

Based on the scarcity theory, this study focuses on exploring the relationship between the severity of public health emergencies (i.e., COVID-19) and individual irrational consumer behaviors through the serial mediating variables of perceived scarcity (PS) and negative mentality (NM). An online questionnaire was used to collect data from participants in China and we obtained 466 effective (115 male and 351 female) questionnaires in total. The findings showed that the relationship between each pair of factors - perceived pandemic severity, PS, NM, and irrational consumption behaviors - was significantly positive. Although the perception of the severity of this public health emergency did not directly predict irrational consumer behavior, the effect was mediated by PS and NM independently and serially. These findings reveal that people who strongly perceive scarcity and are prone to negative attitudes are more likely to demonstrate irrational consumer behaviors (such as rushing to buy and hoard living supplies) once the public perceives a public health emergency as severe. This effect occurs because the PS that results from the epidemic affects people's cognition, emotion, and behavior.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yueqian2021influence,
  author = {Hu Yue-Qian and Xie Piao and Wang Ying and Zhixin Huang and Yi-Ting Wu and Hailong Sun},
  title = {{The Influence of COVID-19 on Irrational Consumption Behavior in a Chinese Sample: Based on a Serial Mediating Model}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2021.718797},
}
Figure