The Influence Factors of Medical Disputes in Shanghai and Implications - From The Perspective of Doctor, Patient and Disease

Yu Liu, Yonghai Bai, Pei WangResearch 2021 · DOI

Introduction

Medical disputes in China have experienced a significant surge since the early 2000s, precipitating a "mistrust crisis" that impacts healthcare delivery and the safety of medical professionals. This phenomenon is driven by a complex interplay between the rising demand for health services and an evolving legal and social framework. To address these tensions, it is essential to move beyond anecdotal evidence and quantify the specific factors—categorized by doctor, patient, and disease—that trigger these disputes. This study analyzes medical dispute cases in Shanghai to identify primary triggers and the risk factors that escalate minor disagreements into high-level disputes involving significant financial compensation.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a retrospective analysis using multistage sampling to collect data on 561 medical disputes occurring over a three-year period across eight hospitals in Shanghai. After filtering for complete data, 520 cases were analyzed. The sample included a representative mix of hospital tiers: two Tertiary (high-level), two Secondary, and four primary community hospitals.

Data analysis involved:

  • Descriptive Statistics: To categorize the frequency of various causes.
  • One-way ANOVA (Kruskal-Wallis H test): To identify variables significantly associated with the "level" (severity) of the dispute.
  • Logistic Regression: To determine which variables were actual predictors of dispute escalation.

The study utilized a custom "Questionnaire on Medical Dispute Case Analysis" covering 23 items across six dimensions, including demographic, medical, patient, disease, communication, and handling factors. Disputes were categorized into four levels based on compensation amounts, with Level 4 being the lowest (<100,000 RMB) and Level 1 being the highest (>1 million RMB).

Key Findings

The Primary Drivers of Disputes

The study found that 87.1% of disputes were attributed to doctor-related factors, while 13.9% were linked to patient-related factors.

Doctor-Related Factors: - Lack of Communication (28.82%): This was the single largest factor, suggesting that many disputes are rooted in interpersonal friction rather than clinical errors. - Low Technical Level (16.91%): Deficiencies in clinical skill remain a significant contributor. - Other factors: Lack of responsibility (8.86%), defective case records (6.92%), and inadequate experience (6.44%).

Patient-Related Factors: - Misunderstanding of Medical Behavior (43.48%): Patients often lack a clear understanding of clinical procedures. - High Expectation of Prognosis (25%): There is a tendency for patients to view medicine as a guaranteed service rather than a field with inherent risks and limitations.

Severity and Outcomes

The vast majority of disputes (78%) were categorized as Level 4 (the lowest severity tier), followed by Level 3 (18%) and Level 2 (4%). No Level 1 disputes were recorded in this sample. Notably, patient death was the catalyst for 33.54% of all disputes, making it the highest single outcome-related trigger.

Interestingly, 57.69% of disputes occurred in "simple general cases" rather than complex surgeries. This suggests a "Simple Case Trap," where patients and families have a lower tolerance for complications when the initial condition is perceived as routine.

Predictors of Dispute Escalation

While communication issues cause the highest volume of disputes, they do not necessarily lead to the most severe ones. Logistic regression analysis revealed that the factors most strongly predicting a higher "level" of dispute (and thus higher compensation) were:

  1. Classification of the disease: Complexity of the underlying condition.
  2. Treatment effect: Adverse outcomes such as death or significant aggravation.
  3. Violations of diagnosis/treatment regulations: Procedural or ethical breaches by medical staff.
  4. Doctor’s deficient technical level: Serious clinical errors.

Conclusions and Implications

The findings highlight that while improving communication is vital for reducing the overall number of disputes, mitigating high-severity disputes requires a focus on clinical rigor and adherence to regulations.

Hospitals should prioritize:

  • Enhanced Communication Training: To bridge the gap between medical reality and patient expectations.
  • Quality Control: Specifically regarding medical records and adherence to treatment regulations.
  • Standardized Referral Mechanisms: Ensuring that critically ill patients are managed in appropriate settings to mitigate the risk of high-level disputes.

Future research should expand to nationwide surveys to develop "early intervention indicators" that can help healthcare providers identify and de-escalate potential disputes before they reach critical levels.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Based on the cases collected in eight hospitals in Shanghai in recent three years, causes of medical disputes in Shanghai and influence factors of medical dispute levels were explored, and targeted suggestions were put forward. Methods Multistage sampling were used to collect 561 cases of medical disputes occurred in two Tertiary hospitals, two Secondary hospitals and four primary hospitals. The causes of medical disputes were analyzed by descriptive statistics and the factors affecting medical dispute were analyzed by means of one-way ANOVA and Logistic regression analysis. Results Factors of doctor and patient are involved in the causes of medical disputes, with 87.1% disputes related to doctors and 13.9% related to patients. The doctor’s factors include lack of communication (28.82%), low technical level (16.91%), lack of sense of responsibility (8.86%), defective case records (6.92%), imperfect operation (6.44%), inadequate experience (6.44%), inadequate condition evaluation (5.8%), irregular management process (4.03%), violation of diagnosis and treatment regulation (4.03%), misdiagnosis and mistreatment (3.54%), belated diagnosis and treatment (2.58%), postoperative complications (2.42%), equipment problems (1.13%), missed diagnosis (0.81%), poor condition monitoring (0.48%), unreasonable charge (0.48%) and poor service attitude (0.32%). The patient's factors include misunderstanding of medical behavior (43.48%), high expectation of prognosis (25%), bad attitude (13.04%), inadequate medical knowledge (7.61%), disturbance (6.52%), poor compliance (3.62%) and mistrust (1.09%). Among all medical disputes, there are 406 cases of level-4 medical disputes (78%), 95 cases of level-3 medical disputes (18%), 19 cases of level-2 medical disputes (4%), and no level-1 medical dispute. Meanwhile, the classification of diseases, treatment effect, doctors' violation of diagnosis and treatment regulation, and low technical level are the reasons for the level differences in medical disputes. Conclusions Factors of doctor in medical disputes in Shanghai mainly include inadequate communication and low technical level while the patient’s factors mainly contain misunderstanding of medical behavior and high expectation of the prognosis. Level-3 and 4 medical disputes take up the major part in all medical disputes. The classification of diseases, treatment effect, doctors' violation of diagnosis and treatment regulation, and doctor’s deficient technical level are high-risk factors requiring critical attention in medical disputes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2021influence,
  author = {Yu Liu and Yonghai Bai and Pei Wang},
  title = {{The Influence Factors of Medical Disputes in Shanghai and Implications - From The Perspective of Doctor, Patient and Disease}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-918597/v1},
}
Figure