The Improvisational State of Mind: A Multidisciplinary Study of an Improvisatory Approach to Classical Music Repertoire Performance

David F. Dolan, Henrik Jeldtoft Jensen, Pedro A. M. Mediano, Miguel Molina-Solana, Hardik Rajpal, Fernando E. Rosas, John SlobodaFrontiers in Psychology 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the "improvisational state of mind" in classical musicians by comparing prepared and improvised performances. They found that improvisation leads to distinct sonic and movement characteristics, heightened audience engagement, and increased neural complexity in both performers and listeners, suggesting a shared, altered state of consciousness.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Classical music performance has historically emphasized strict adherence to a composer's score, limiting improvisation. However, historical accounts suggest that improvisation was once a more integral part of musical mastery. This paper addresses the gap in understanding the nature and effects of improvisation in classical music by directly comparing prepared and improvised performances of the same piece. The authors aim to characterize the "improvisational state of mind" in performers and explore its potential transfer to the audience, moving beyond anecdotal evidence and previous studies that focused primarily on jazz or lacked rigorous scientific measurement.

Methods

The study employed a multidisciplinary approach, combining:

  • Sonic and Performance Analysis: Detailed listening and analysis of audio recordings to identify differences in timing, dynamics, timbre, phrasing, and risk-taking.
  • Continuous Body Motion Tracking: Using Microsoft Kinect v2 sensors to capture the 3D movements of performers, analyzing for differences in coordination and overall movement.
  • Post-performance Assessments: Questionnaires for performers and audience members to gather subjective experiences and ratings of the performances.
  • Real-Time Continuous Monitoring of Brain Activity (EEG): Measuring EEG signals from performers and audience members using 19 electrodes to analyze neural complexity via Lempel-Ziv (LZ) complexity. LZ complexity is used as a proxy for brain entropy, awareness, and alertness.

Datasets

The study utilized data from:

  • Live Chamber Music Concert: A performance of a movement from Franz Schubert's "Shepherd on the Rock" by a professional trio (voice, flute, piano).
  • Audience: 22 adults with varying levels of musical experience and training.
  • Performers: The professional trio.

No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, the study aimed to provide a comprehensive analysis of a live performance scenario.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Improvisational State of Mind" is Distinct: The study provides strong evidence that improvisation induces a different mental and physiological state in performers compared to prepared performances.
  • Shared Experience: This improvisational state appears to be communicable to the audience, leading to a heightened shared experience.
  • Flow and Primary States: The findings align with concepts of "flow" (effortless engagement) and "primary states" (high entropy, creative cognition) from psychology and neuroscience, suggesting the improvisational state of mind embodies aspects of both.
  • Reduced Movement, Increased Coherence: Counterintuitively, improvised performances involved less overall body movement and better coordination between performers, suggesting a shift from external, metronomic control to a more internalized, macro-structural focus.
  • Audience Engagement: Audiences rated improvised performances as more emotionally compelling and musically convincing, regardless of their musical training or whether they could see the performers.

Key Results

  • Sonic Differences: Improvised performances featured a wider range of timbral changes, more dynamic diversity, slower but subjectively faster tempo, and longer, more coherent phrasing.
  • Movement Analysis: Musicians exhibited reduced overall body movement in improvised performances, with less uncoordinated motion between them.
  • Audience Ratings: Improvised versions were rated significantly higher on "emotionally compelling" (3.8 vs. 2.6) and "musically convincing" (4.1 vs. 3.2) compared to prepared versions. These effects were independent of audience musical training or visual access.
  • EEG Complexity: Lempel-Ziv (LZ) complexity of EEG signals was significantly higher in the improvised condition for both performers and audience members (increase of 0.009). This increase was primarily localized in the right hemisphere, associated with creativity.
  • Power Spectrum: Higher frequencies (beta and gamma bands) were more active during improvised performances, while lower frequencies (delta, theta, alpha) were more active during prepared performances, mirroring transitions between sleep and awake states.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: The study involved a small number of participants (3 performers, 4 audience members for EEG).
  • Generalizability: While the study used Schubert, a different composer and period than previous work, further research across a wider range of composers and styles is needed to confirm the generalizability of the findings.
  • Intrusiveness of Measurement: While efforts were made to be non-intrusive, the use of EEG and motion capture still represents an experimental setting.

Future work suggested includes developing less intrusive measurement techniques, exploring inter-brain synchronization between improvising musicians, and investigating the potential therapeutic benefits of improvisation for well-being. The authors also emphasize the need for further research to fully corroborate LZ complexity as a potential biomarker for the improvisational state of mind.

Summary updated

Abstract

The recent re-introduction of improvisation as a professional practice within classical music, however cautious and still rare, allows direct and detailed contemporary comparison between improvised and "standard" approaches to performances of the same composition, comparisons which hitherto could only be inferred from impressionistic historical accounts. This study takes an interdisciplinary multi-method approach to discovering the contrasting nature and effects of prepared and improvised approaches during live chamber-music concert performances of a movement from Franz Schubert's "Shepherd on the Rock," given by a professional trio consisting of voice, flute, and piano, in the presence of an invited audience of 22 adults with varying levels of musical experience and training. The improvised performances were found to differ systematically from prepared performances in their timing, dynamic, and timbral features as well as in the degree of risk-taking and "mind reading" between performers, which included moments of spontaneously exchanging extemporized notes. Post-performance critical reflection by the performers characterized distinct mental states underlying the two modes of performance. The amount of overall body movements was reduced in the improvised performances, which showed less unco-ordinated movements between performers when compared to the prepared performance. Audience members, who were told only that the two performances would be different, but not how, rated the improvised version as more emotionally compelling and musically convincing than the prepared version. The size of this effect was not affected by whether or not the audience could see the performers, or by levels of musical training. EEG measurements from 19 scalp locations showed higher levels of Lempel-Ziv complexity (associated with awareness and alertness) in the improvised version in both performers and audience. Results are discussed in terms of their potential support for an "improvisatory state of mind" which may have aspects of flow (as characterized by Csikszentmihalyi, 1997) and primary states (as characterized by the Entropic Brain Hypothesis of Carhart-Harris et al., 2014). In a group setting, such as a live concert, our evidence suggests that this state of mind is communicable between performers and audience thus contributing to a heightened quality of shared experience.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dolan2018improvisational,
  author = {David F. Dolan and Henrik Jeldtoft Jensen and Pedro A. M. Mediano and Miguel Molina-Solana and Hardik Rajpal and Fernando E. Rosas and John Sloboda},
  title = {{The Improvisational State of Mind: A Multidisciplinary Study of an Improvisatory Approach to Classical Music Repertoire Performance}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01341},
}
Figure