TL;DR
This paper details significant improvements to the NIM-1 joule balance, reducing its uncertainty in Planck constant measurements to 7.2 x 10⁻⁶. It also introduces the design of a new, more compact and vacuum-compatible joule balance, NIM-2, aiming for even higher precision to support the redefinition of the kilogram.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The kilogram, the base unit of mass in the International System of Units (SI), is currently defined by a physical artifact, the International Prototype of the Kilogram (IPK). However, comparisons have shown that the IPK and its official copies exhibit a drift over time, making it an unstable standard. To address this, the scientific community is working towards redefining the kilogram based on fundamental physical constants, such as the Planck constant. The joule balance is one method being developed to achieve this, but it faces challenges in achieving the required precision. Specifically, the NIM-1 joule balance, while demonstrating the principle, was limited by uncertainties arising from self-heating of coils, the balance's mechanical stability (swinging of the coil), and its large size, which prevented vacuum operation. This paper tackles these limitations by presenting improvements to NIM-1 and outlining the design of a next-generation instrument, NIM-2, to overcome these hurdles.
Methods
The paper describes two main thrusts: improving the existing NIM-1 joule balance and designing the new NIM-2.
Improvements to NIM-1:
- Reducing Coil Self-Heating: Initially, enameled copper wire coils were used, leading to significant heating (over 100W total). This caused coil expansion, airflow disturbances, and sensor drift. Attempts were made with superconducting coils, but Meissner effect issues arose. The solution involved redesigning the coils to be more compact, reducing heating power by two-thirds while maintaining electrical force. This reduced the uncertainty contribution from self-heating from 56 ppm to 7 ppm.
- Improving Balance Stability and Length Measurement: To mitigate the swing of the suspended coil, a 2-meter long beam was used, but this made it susceptible to external disturbances. A new approach involved keeping the suspended coil stable and moving the exciting coil using a linear driving stage (20mm range). A laser-based position locking system, incorporating piezoelectric ceramic control and a heterodyne interferometer, was implemented to achieve sub-nanometer precision in length determination, reducing the uncertainty to 0.5 ppm.
- Enhancing Mass Measurement: An E2 class 200g mass standard replaced the previous copper mass, improving the mass measurement uncertainty to 0.25 ppm.
- Improving Control System: A voltage source was replaced with a current source for the balance's control system, significantly reducing reading drift and improving repeatability to 2 mg, leading to a force weighing uncertainty of 1 ppm.
- Alignment: A capacitive displacement sensor was developed to measure and correct for horizontal movement of the exciting coil, with a resolution of 1 µm.
Design of NIM-2:
- Compact Size and Vacuum Compatibility: NIM-2 is designed to be significantly smaller than NIM-1 to allow for vacuum operation, which is crucial for reducing air-related uncertainties.
- New Weighing Device: A commercial mass comparator with a 5kg capacity, 1µg resolution, and 15µg repeatability is being integrated to replace the long beam balance.
- Magnetic Damping: To compensate for the lack of oil damping in a vacuum environment, a 3-dimensional magnetic damping device is being developed.
- New Electromagnet: To further reduce self-heating and increase magnetic field strength, a new electromagnet design using ferromagnetic material is being implemented. This design aims for a closed magnetic circuit, improved shielding, and a significantly increased electromagnetic force (500g, 2.5 times that of NIM-1).
- Active Vibration Isolation: An active control vibration isolation base is being designed to further enhance the stability of the apparatus.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on instrument design and measurement principles rather than data-driven model training.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The kilogram's artifact-based definition is a significant metrological challenge: The observed drift in the IPK highlights the need for a fundamental constant-based redefinition.
- Joule balance offers a promising alternative to watt balance: It provides a different electrical method for measuring the Planck constant, complementing other approaches.
- Self-heating of coils is a major hurdle for joule balances: Significant engineering effort is required to mitigate this, either through optimized coil design or advanced materials.
- Mechanical stability is paramount: Even small vibrations and drifts in the balance system can introduce substantial uncertainties, necessitating sophisticated active and passive damping mechanisms.
- Vacuum operation is essential for high-precision mass measurements: Eliminating air currents and pressure fluctuations is critical for achieving the target uncertainties.
- NIM-2 represents a significant step forward: The design incorporates lessons learned from NIM-1, aiming for a compact, vacuum-compatible system with enhanced precision.
Key Results
- NIM-1 Improvements: The relative uncertainty of the joule balance NIM-1 has been reduced from 7.7×10⁻⁵ to 7.2×10⁻⁶.
- Planck Constant Measurement: The Planck constant measured with the improved NIM-1 is h=6.6261041(470)×10⁻³⁴ Js.
- Comparison to CODATA: The relative difference between the measured Planck constant and the CODATA2010 value is 5×10⁻⁶.
- Uncertainty Reduction: Key uncertainty contributions like self-heating of coils and length measurement have been significantly reduced (e.g., self-heating from 56 ppm to 7 ppm, length measurement from 49 ppm to 0.5 ppm).
Limitations and Future Work
Limitations of NIM-1:
- Size and Vacuum: NIM-1's large size prevents it from being placed in a vacuum chamber, limiting length measurement precision in air to the 10⁻⁶ level.
- Balance Resolution and Repeatability: The resolution and short-time repeatability of the balance are limiting factors.
- Coil Self-Heating: While reduced, self-heating remains a concern.
Future Work:
- Continued Improvement of NIM-1: Further improvements are ongoing for the NIM-1 apparatus.
- Construction and Testing of NIM-2: The design and construction of the new joule balance NIM-2 are in progress. The paper details the design considerations and components, with the system expected to be mounted by the end of 2015 and ready for testing. The goal for NIM-2 is to achieve uncertainties below 0.05 ppm to meet the requirements for the redefinition of the kilogram.
- New Measurement Techniques: For NIM-2, a magnetic flux linkage measurement is proposed as a new approach for measuring mutual inductance, especially with the new electromagnet.
Summary updated