The Importance of Water-Hydrocarbon Phase Equilibria During Reservoir Production and Drilling Operations

Huiyu Zhou, J.‐c. de Hemptinne, Aleksandër DhimaRevue 1998 · DOI

Abstract

The inevitable presence of water in high pressure-high temperature (HP/HT) reservoirs leads to a number of new challenges for petroleum engineers. A brief state of the art on water-hydrocarbon phase equilibria is presented. It appears that large amounts of water may be present in the hydrocarbon phase (up to 10% molar), and non-negligible amounts of gas can dissolve in water. Based on experimental data, a large number of models have been developed. However, concerning the limitations of the data, caution is expressed about the correctness of some models. Recent studies have proven the usefulness of Henry's constants to predict hydrocarbon solubilities in water. The new challenges that are raised by this problem are discussed based on a number of recent publications. The water present in the hydrocarbon may lead to salt deposits downwell, and it must be taken into account in order to estimate the amount of gas in place. It can also result in modifications of the saturation pressure. Due to the presence of water, additional treatment is needed for pipe transport. On the other hand, the large amount of hydrocarbons dissolved in the water phase may result in a modification of the hydrocarbon composition, especially when reservoir pressure becomes very low. The increased toxicity of the water, containing either H2S or aromatics, can become a real burden for gas reservoirs in contact with aquifers or when disposing of production water. During drilling, large amounts of dissolved gas can become very hazardous, increasing the risk of eruption. A particular attention must be paid to acid gas injection in reservoirs, as the true effect of the injected gas may not be straightforward to predict. In conclusion, in light of the industrial importance of this information, some general guidelines are provided concerning additional data to be gathered and ideas for improving current models.

Introduction: Breaking the Immiscibility Myth

For decades, the petroleum industry operated under the assumption that water and hydrocarbons are essentially immiscible. In conventional, lower-temperature reservoirs, treating reservoir water as an inert, separate phase was a sufficient approximation. However, as exploration and production push into high-pressure, high-temperature (HP/HT) environments, this "immiscibility myth" is failing. At extreme conditions, the mutual solubility of these phases becomes significant, with water content in the gas phase potentially reaching 10-20 mole percent.

Water mole fraction in the gas phase as a function of temperature and pressure, illustrating significant solubility in HP/HT conditions.

Engineering Challenges in HP/HT Environments

The failure to account for these phase behaviors creates several critical "blind spots" in reservoir engineering:

  • Reserves Estimation: Neglecting water vapor in the gas phase leads to an overestimation of hydrocarbon reserves. Studies show that failing to account for water-gas exchanges can lead to a 5 bar deviation in $P/Z$ plots, resulting in significant asset valuation errors.
  • Flow Assurance: As gas moves toward the wellbore, pressure drops can cause water to evaporate, leaving behind salt deposits (scale). This scaling can rapidly choke production and require expensive interventions.
  • Drilling Safety: Gas dissolving into water-based drilling muds at high pressure can be "invisible" to standard pit-level sensors because it does not significantly change the mud volume. As the mud circulates toward the surface and pressure drops, the gas rapidly desorbs, potentially leading to dangerous blowouts or "kicks."

Modeling and Prediction

Predicting these complex interactions requires sophisticated thermodynamic modeling. The industry primarily relies on three approaches:

  • Cubic Equations of State (EoS): Modified Peng-Robinson or Soave-Redlich-Kwong models are standard but require specialized "alpha functions" to handle the polar nature of water.
  • Electrolyte Activity Models: Models like Pitzer or Setchenow are essential for accounting for the "salting-out" effect, where dissolved salts in brine reduce hydrocarbon solubility.
  • Henry’s Law: This remains a superior method for predicting dilute hydrocarbon solubility in the aqueous phase, particularly when adjusted for high-pressure effects using the Krychevsky-Kasarnovsky equation.

Chemical Drivers of Solubility

Water solubility in liquid hydrocarbons is not solely a function of molecular weight; it is deeply influenced by chemical structure. The "double bond index" serves as a key metric here: aromatics (such as benzene) can hold significantly more water than paraffins due to specific molecular interactions.

Correlation between water solubility and the double bond index of various hydrocarbons, highlighting the increased capacity of aromatics to hold water.

Furthermore, the presence of acid gases like $H_2S$ and $CO_2$ complicates the picture. In sour gas reservoirs, $H_2S$ is highly soluble in water. As reservoir pressure declines during production, $H_2S$ can "bubble out" of the connate water, leading to an unexpected spike in $H_2S$ concentrations in the produced gas stream late in the field's life.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While current models provide a "workhorse" for industry calculations, they face limitations in HP/HT scenarios. There is a critical need for more experimental data on heavy hydrocarbons and aromatics at temperatures exceeding 100°C. Future work must focus on integrating more robust "association models" that can fundamentally account for hydrogen bonding in polar substances, ensuring safer and more accurate management of HP/HT assets.

Summary updated

Abstract

The inevitable presence of water in high pressure-high temperature reservoirs leads to a number of new challenges for petroleum engineers. A brief state of the art on water-hydrocarbon phase equilibria is presented. It appears that large amounts of water may be present in the hydrocarbon phase (up to 10% molar), and non negligible amounts of gas can dissolve in water. Based on experimental data, a large number of models have been developed. However, concerning the limitations of the data, caution is expressed about the correctness of some models. Recent studies have proven the usefulness of Henry's constants to predict hydrocarbon solubilities in water. The new challenges that are raised by this problem are discussed based on a number of recent publications. The water present in the hydrocarbon may lead to salt deposits downwell, and it must be taken into account in order to estimate the amount of gas in place. It can also result in modifications of the saturation pressure. Due to the presence of water, additional treatment is needed for pipe transport. On the other hand, the large amount of hydrocarbons dissolved in the water phase may result in a modification of the hydrocarbon composition, especially when reservoir pressure becomes very low. The increased toxicity of the water, containing either H2S or aromatics, can become a real burden for gas reservoirs in contact with aquifers or when disposing of production water. During drilling, large amounts of dissolved gas can become very hazardous, increasing the risk of eruption. A particular attention must be paid to acid gas injection in reservoirs, as the true effect of the injected gas may not be straightforward to predict. In conclusion, in light of the industrial importance of this information, some general guidelines are provided concerning additional data to be gathered and ideas for improving current models.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou1998importance,
  author = {Huiyu Zhou and J.‐C. de Hemptinne and Aleksandër Dhima},
  title = {{The Importance of Water-Hydrocarbon Phase Equilibria During Reservoir Production and Drilling Operations}},
  booktitle = {Revue},
  year = {1998},
  doi = {10.2516/ogst:1998025},
}

Loading related content...

Figure