The implementation of e-learning tools to enhance undergraduate bioinformatics teaching and learning: a case study in the National University of Singapore

Shen Jean Lim, Asif Mohammad Khan, Mark De Silva, Kuan Siong Lim, Yongli Hu, Chay Hoon Tan, Tin Wee TanBMC Bioinformatics 2009 · DOI · OpenReview

Introduction

Bioinformatics education requires a delicate balance between biological theory and computational practice. Traditional lecture-based methods often struggle to convey the investigative nature of the field. Problem-Based Learning (PBL) offers a solution by emphasizing student-led inquiry, but it is notoriously difficult to manage at scale. This case study explores how the National University of Singapore (NUS) integrated e-learning tools—specifically the Learning Activity Management System (LAMS) and wikis—to provide the necessary "scaffolding" for undergraduate bioinformatics students.

Methodology

The study involved two distinct cohorts: a small Year 3 cohort (26 students) and a large Year 2 cohort (252 students). Two primary technologies were deployed:

  1. LAMS (Learning Activity Management System): Used to create digital "learning sequences" that guided students through specific tasks, allowing for real-time progress monitoring.
  2. Wikis (MediaWiki): Provided a collaborative space for documenting hypotheses, coordinating assignments, and compiling reports.

Key Insights

Digital Scaffolding and Workflow

A core finding was the value of structured digital workflows. Over 60% of students across both cohorts reported that breaking down complex PBL activities into sequential steps via LAMS enhanced their learning experience by reducing cognitive load.

LAMS as a Revision Tool

In the larger Year 2 cohort, LAMS proved exceptionally effective for exam preparation. Nearly 90% of these students indicated that the tool positively impacted their revision process, suggesting that structured digital sequences are excellent for reinforcing complex material.

Student perceptions of LAMS in the Year 2 cohort, highlighting high satisfaction with revision and workflow support.

The Engagement Challenge

While the Year 2 cohort found the tools highly engaging, the smaller Year 3 cohort experienced "workload fatigue." As the bioinformatics problems grew more complex and the stakes higher, the perceived "fun" of using LAMS decreased significantly over the course of the semester.

Comparison of student responses between PBL sessions 2 and 5 for the Year 3 cohort, showing a decline in the 'fun' factor.

Results and Discussion

The quantitative data highlights a divergence between cohorts. While 92.59% of Year 2 students found learning with LAMS more exciting than traditional methods, the Year 3 cohort's "fun" rating dropped from 50% to 26.32% over five sessions. This suggests that while e-learning tools are powerful for large-scale management and revision, maintaining long-term engagement in smaller, high-stakes groups requires more creative and varied content design.

Conclusion

The study demonstrates that e-learning tools can successfully scaffold PBL in bioinformatics, even for large classes. However, scalability remains a challenge, as the "human element" of facilitation is difficult to automate. Future efforts will focus on increasing the interactivity of LAMS sequences and lowering the technical barriers to wiki collaboration to ensure technology supports, rather than hinders, the learning process.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background The rapid advancement of computer and information technology in recent years has resulted in the rise of e-learning technologies to enhance and complement traditional classroom teaching in many fields, including bioinformatics. This paper records the experience of implementing e-learning technology to support problem-based learning (PBL) in the teaching of two undergraduate bioinformatics classes in the National University of Singapore. Results Survey results further established the efficiency and suitability of e-learning tools to supplement PBL in bioinformatics education. 63.16% of year three bioinformatics students showed a positive response regarding the usefulness of the Learning Activity Management System (LAMS) e-learning tool in guiding the learning and discussion process involved in PBL and in enhancing the learning experience by breaking down PBL activities into a sequential workflow. On the other hand, 89.81% of year two bioinformatics students indicated that their revision process was positively impacted with the use of LAMS for guiding the learning process, while 60.19% agreed that the breakdown of activities into a sequential step-by-step workflow by LAMS enhances the learning experience Conclusion We show that e-learning tools are useful for supplementing PBL in bioinformatics education. The results suggest that it is feasible to develop and adopt e-learning tools to supplement a variety of instructional strategies in the future.
BibTeX
@article{lim2009implementation,
  author = {Shen Jean Lim and Asif Mohammad Khan and Mark De Silva and Kuan Siong Lim and Yongli Hu and Chay Hoon Tan and Tin Wee Tan},
  title = {{The implementation of e-learning tools to enhance undergraduate bioinformatics teaching and learning: a case study in the National University of Singapore}},
  journal = {BMC Bioinformatics},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1186/1471-2105-10-s15-s12},
}
Figure