The Impacts of Market Segmentation on Thermal Power Generation Efficiency

Minghui Liu, Chunhua Ju, Yan WangFrontiers in Energy Research 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Market segmentation—provincial protectionism that creates trade barriers—significantly hinders the efficiency of thermal power generation in China. By analyzing data from 30 provinces between 2005 and 2017, this study finds that these market distortions stifle the "innovation effect," preventing high-efficiency plants from outcompeting less efficient local rivals and slowing down the adoption of cleaner, better technologies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China’s power industry is the backbone of its economy, but it faces a "twin problem": the need for massive output and the urgent requirement to reduce carbon emissions. While thermal power (mostly coal) remains dominant, its efficiency varies wildly across regions.

The authors argue that a major culprit for this inefficiency is market segmentation. Since 1988, China has operated on a provincial power market model. To protect local GDP and tax revenue, provincial governments often favor local power plants over more efficient ones from neighboring provinces—a "beggar-thy-neighbor" strategy. This paper quantifies exactly how much these invisible provincial borders hurt the industry's overall productivity and environmental goals.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated multi-stage analytical framework:

  • Non-radial Direction Distance Function (NDDF): Unlike standard models that assume all inputs and outputs change at the same rate, NDDF allows for independent adjustments. This is crucial for modeling "desirable" outputs (electricity) alongside "undesirable" ones (CO2 emissions).
  • Amazon Glacier Cost (Relative Price Method): To measure market segmentation, the authors used price variances of power, coal, and oil between provinces. The logic is simple: in a perfectly integrated market, prices should converge; large price gaps indicate high segmentation.
  • MMUEI (Metafrontier Malmquist-Luenberger Unified Efficiency Index): This was used to measure dynamic efficiency changes over time, which the authors then decomposed into three parts: technical efficiency change (catching up), best practice gap change (innovation), and technology gap ratio change (leadership).
  • Econometric Modeling: They used Fixed Effects and GMM (System Generalized Method of Moments) regressions to ensure the results were robust and accounted for endogeneity (the "chicken and egg" problem of variables influencing each other).

Datasets

The study utilized a panel dataset covering 30 Chinese provinces from 2005 to 2017. Data sources included:

  • China Electric Power Yearbook (Capital and Power Generation data).
  • China Labor Statistical Yearbook (Labor input).
  • China Price Statistical Yearbook (Fuel prices for the segmentation index).
  • Carbon emission coefficients were derived from established IPCC-style methodologies to calculate the "undesirable output" of CO2.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Innovation Stifle: The most critical finding is that market segmentation hurts efficiency primarily through the "innovation effect." When a local market is protected, there is less incentive for power plants to invest in R&D or adopt cutting-edge technologies because they aren't competing against the national "best-in-class" performers.
  • The 2008 Peak: Market segmentation peaked around 2008. The authors attribute this to the global financial crisis; local governments likely increased market intervention to ensure local economic stability and protect local jobs.
  • Regional Disparities: The Eastern region is the efficiency leader, benefiting from better technology and perhaps more open markets. The Western region lags significantly, showing the lowest dynamic efficiency.
  • The "Umbrella" Effect: Local governments provide an "umbrella" of subsidies and protection to local firms, which prevents the natural "survival of the fittest" process that usually drives industry-wide efficiency.

Key Results

  • Negative Impact: Market segmentation has a statistically significant negative effect on efficiency. Specifically, the thermal power generation efficiency decreases by 1.6799 for every unit increase in the market segmentation index.
  • Slow Progress: The average dynamic efficiency (MMUEI) across China was 1.00057, indicating that while efficiency is improving, the pace is incredibly slow.
  • Control Variables:
    • Ownership Structure: A higher proportion of state-owned assets was correlated with lower efficiency.
  • Environmental Regulation: Stricter regulations (measured by SO2 emission limits) actually promoted efficiency, suggesting that "green" pressure forces plants to modernize.
  • Coal Prices: Higher coal prices led to higher efficiency, as plants were forced to improve fuel utilization to maintain margins.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Recency: The study concludes in 2017. While it captures the start of the 2015 power system reforms, it may not reflect the full impact of more recent "dual control" energy policies or the massive recent push toward carbon neutrality (30/60 goals).
  • Renewable Integration: The paper focuses strictly on thermal power. As China integrates more wind and solar, the "market segmentation" of the grid becomes even more complex, as variable renewable energy requires even better cross-provincial coordination.
  • Policy Path: The authors suggest that the central government should move away from evaluating local officials solely on provincial GDP, as this is the root incentive for protectionism. Future research could investigate if "Green GDP" metrics successfully reduce market segmentation.

Summary updated

Abstract

China’s power industry is in a critical transformation period. The new round of power system reform in 2015 will have a profound impact on China’s power industry. Therefore, it’s necessary to analyze the influencing factors of thermal power generation efficiency. Based on the thermal power generation industry related data in China’s 30 provinces from 2005 to 2017, this paper studies the impacts of market segmentation on thermal power generation efficiency in China. And the empirical result shows that the market segmentation exhibit significant negative effects on the thermal power generation efficiency, that is, the thermal power generation efficiency significantly decrease 1.6799 for each unit increase of market segmentation index of thermal power industry. Besides, by decomposing the dynamic thermal power efficiency index, we find that the “innovation effect” is the primary channel for the market segmentation to make effects on the thermal power generation efficiency. Furthermore, our findings are still robust after considering endogenous problems and eliminating the relevant data. Finally, research conclusions of our study paper provide empirical supports for the efficient development of China’s power market.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2022impacts,
  author = {Minghui Liu and Chunhua Ju and Yan Wang},
  title = {{The Impacts of Market Segmentation on Thermal Power Generation Efficiency}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2021.811577},
}
Figure