The Impact of Tourist Operant Resources on Online Citizenship Behavior in Sustainable Tourism

Ting Liu, Ma Chun, Jiaqi Xue, Gang Li, Qiuli LuSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores how tourists' own resources (knowledge, skills) can drive their online citizenship behavior (like recommending sustainable tourism) when interacting with online travel agencies (OTAs). It finds that perceived value mediates this relationship, and the effectiveness of these resources is influenced by how well tourists and OTAs understand each other (knowledge distance) and how well OTAs integrate resources.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The tourism industry is increasingly focused on sustainability, but engaging tourists in this effort, particularly through value co-creation, remains a challenge. While previous research has looked at tourist engagement with destinations or local communities, there's a gap in understanding how tourists interact with Online Travel Agencies (OTAs) to co-create value in sustainable tourism. Specifically, the paper addresses how tourists' "operant resources" – their knowledge, skills, and experience – can translate into online citizenship behaviors (like sharing positive experiences or helping others) that benefit both the tourist and the OTA, ultimately promoting sustainable tourism. It also investigates the conditions under which this process might lead to "value co-destruction" rather than co-creation.

Methods

The study employs a quantitative approach using survey data. They developed and validated multi-item scales to measure key constructs: tourist operant resources, perceived value (functional and emotional), knowledge distance, resource integration capability, and online citizenship behavior. Hierarchical regression analysis was used to test the direct, mediating, and moderating effects proposed in their conceptual model. They also used bootstrapping to further validate the mediation effects.

Datasets

The study collected data from 301 tourists who had used customized sustainable tourism services from OTAs in China. Participants were recruited through tourism forums, WeChat groups, and an online market research company. A screening question ensured participants had chosen sustainable tourism products.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Tourist Resources are Key Drivers: Tourists aren't just passive consumers; their own knowledge and skills (operant resources) are crucial for engaging in value co-creation and, subsequently, online citizenship behavior.
  • Value as a Bridge: Perceived value (both functional and emotional) acts as a crucial intermediary, translating the investment of tourist operant resources into the desire to engage in online citizenship behaviors.
  • The "Sweet Spot" of Understanding: Knowledge distance isn't always bad. A moderate level of difference in understanding between tourists and OTA personnel can actually lead to the highest functional value, as it encourages productive interaction and new value generation. Too little or too much distance is detrimental.
  • OTA's Role in Integration is Critical: The ability of OTA service personnel to effectively integrate tourist input with the OTA's resources is vital. When this capability is high, it amplifies the positive impact of tourist operant resources on both functional and emotional value.
  • Not All Interactions Lead to Value: The study hints at the potential for value co-destruction if resources are misused or poorly integrated, highlighting the importance of the moderating factors.

Key Results

  • Hypothesis H1 Supported: Tourist operant resources were found to have a significant positive effect on online citizenship behavior (β = 0.552, p < 0.01).
  • Hypothesis H2 Supported: Perceived value (both functional and emotional) partially mediated the relationship between tourist operant resources and online citizenship behavior. The mediation effect size for functional value was 41.25%, and for emotional value was 34.87%.
  • Hypothesis H3 Supported (Partially): Knowledge distance exerted an inverted U-shaped moderating effect on the relationship between tourist operant resources and functional value (β = −0.216, p < 0.01). However, it did not significantly moderate the relationship with emotional value.
  • Hypothesis H4 Supported: Resource integration capability positively moderated the relationship between tourist operant resources and both functional value (β = 0.128, p < 0.05) and emotional value (β = 0.190, p < 0.01).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Scope: The study focused solely on the interaction between tourists and OTAs. Future research could explore interactions with other stakeholders like destination attractions, local communities, hotels, and governments.
  • Sustainable Tourism Focus: The study specifically targeted tourists interested in sustainable tourism. Future comparative research could investigate differences in motivations and behaviors between these tourists and those who are not.
  • Moderating Factors: While knowledge distance and resource integration capability were examined, other moderating factors like personal characteristics, cultural backgrounds, and technical factors could be explored to deepen understanding.
  • Value Co-Destruction Nuances: While the study touches upon the conditions that might lead to value co-destruction, further in-depth research on this aspect is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sustainability has emerged as a critical concern in the tourism industry. In sustainable tourism, the question of how to engage tourists in value co-creation has started to receive attention. Based on service-dominant logic, this paper develops an integrated model to reveal the impact of tourist operant resources on online citizenship behavior from the perspective of interactions between tourists and online travel agencies (OTAs). Empirical research is conducted using data collected from 301 tourists with customized sustainable tourism experiences. The results show that tourist operant resources are positively associated with online citizenship behavior, with the perceived value (functional value and emotional value) playing a partially mediating role in this relationship. Knowledge distance between tourists and OTA service personnel exerts an inverted U-shaped moderating effect on the relationship between tourist operant resources and functional values, but it does not have a moderating effect on the relationship between tourist operant resources and emotional values. Resource integration capability positively moderates the impact of tourist operant resources on functional and emotional values. This study reveals the contingency role of tourist operant resources in the entire value co-creation process in the context of sustainable tourism and provides practical guidance for OTAs to promote tourists’ online citizenship behavior to develop sustainable tourism.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023impact,
  author = {Ting Liu and Ma Chun and Jiaqi Xue and Gang Li and Qiuli Lu},
  title = {{The Impact of Tourist Operant Resources on Online Citizenship Behavior in Sustainable Tourism}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su152316148},
}
Figure