The impact of short-term incentives on physical activity in a UK behavioural incentives programme

Cother Hajat, Ali Hasan, Shaun Subel, Adam NoachNpj Digit. Medicine 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that short-term, tangible incentives significantly increase and sustain physical activity levels in a large UK population. The findings suggest that this approach can be a powerful tool for public health initiatives aiming to combat rising inactivity rates.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Physical inactivity is a growing global health concern, contributing to increased mortality and healthcare costs. While behavioral economics principles suggest incentives can drive change, and technology like wearables is increasingly used, there's a need to understand the real-world impact and sustainability of these interventions, especially when combining technology with incentives. Previous research often relies on lab settings or short follow-up periods, leaving questions about long-term effectiveness and generalizability. This paper investigates whether ongoing, short-term incentives, delivered through a wellness program, can lead to sustained increases in physical activity and positively impact health outcomes.

Methods

The study employed a prospective, longitudinal design, analyzing data from UK members of the Vitality wellness program. They compared participants' physical activity levels before and after the introduction of the Vitality Active Rewards (VAR) program, which offered short-term incentives (cinema tickets, Starbucks vouchers) for verified physical activity.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Verified Data: Physical activity was primarily measured using verified data from gym visits, wearable trackers (steps, heart rate), and Parkrun participation. This reduces reliance on self-reporting bias.
  • Categorization: Participants were categorized into low-, medium-, and high-active groups based on their baseline physical activity levels.
  • Before-and-After Comparison: The study compared data from the 24 months before VAR introduction (years 1-2) with the 24 months after (years 3-4).
  • Secondary Outcomes: Beyond physical activity, the study also examined predicted health outcomes (relative risk of mortality from inactivity) and satisfaction with exercise levels.
  • Staggered Incentives: The VAR program was introduced in phases (Starbucks, then cinema tickets), allowing researchers to observe the impact of staggered incentive introduction.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 11,881 participants enrolled in the UK Vitality wellness program. This dataset included:

  • Verified Physical Activity Data: Accrued points from gym visits, wearable trackers, and Parkrun events.
  • Self-Reported Data: Information collected through regular Vitality Health Reviews, including exercise frequency, duration, intensity, and satisfaction.

The data spanned a 4-year period (February 2013 to January 2017), with 24 months pre-VAR and 24 months post-VAR.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Short-Term Incentives Drive Significant Change: The most striking finding is the dramatic increase in physical activity, particularly among those who were initially less active. This highlights the power of immediate, tangible rewards.
  • Sustained Impact: The positive effects of the incentives were not fleeting; physical activity levels continued to increase and were sustained for at least two years after the program's introduction.
  • Staggering Matters: The phased introduction of incentives appeared to play a role in sustaining engagement, suggesting a strategic approach to incentive delivery can be beneficial.
  • Broader Health Implications: The study projected a significant reduction in the relative risk of mortality due to inactivity, underscoring the public health potential of such programs.
  • Satisfaction Boost: Members reported significantly higher satisfaction with their exercise levels after engaging with the VAR program, which is crucial for long-term adherence.
  • Gender and Age Differences: While overall improvements were seen, females showed a slightly higher relative increase in activity than males. The over-65 age group showed less impact, though they remained more active than national averages.

Key Results

  • Overall Active Days: Increased by 56% at follow-up compared to baseline.
  • Low-Active Members: Saw a staggering 554% increase in annual active days.
  • Medium-Active Members: Experienced a 205% increase in annual active days.
  • High-Active Members: Showed a 17% increase in annual active days.
  • Meeting WHO Recommendations: The percentage of weeks meeting WHO recommendations increased by 19% overall, with a 316% improvement for low-active members.
  • Self-Reported Active Minutes: Increased by 45% overall, and a remarkable 712% for low-active members.
  • Relative Risk of Mortality (PARR): Reduced by 7% for low-active, 5% for medium-active, and 3% for high-active members.
  • Satisfaction: Shifted from 49.4% happy with exercise levels at baseline to 84.9% happy post-VAR.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalizability: While the study is large-scale and real-world, the participants are members of a specific wellness program, which may not be representative of the entire population.
  • Intensity Discrimination: The study could not precisely differentiate the intensity of moderate or high-intensity activities for all participants. Future work could leverage advanced wearable technology for more granular data.
  • Long-Term Sustainability: While sustained for two years, the absolute long-term impact beyond this period, especially after potential removal of incentives, requires further investigation.
  • Triggers for Engagement: Identifying the key factors that encourage members to participate in incentive programs is a crucial area for future research to enable broader implementation.
  • Manifestation of Health Outcomes: Future research should aim to verify if the predicted improvements in health outcomes (e.g., reduced mortality) actually manifest over longer periods.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{hajat2019impact,
  author = {Cother Hajat and Ali Hasan and Shaun Subel and Adam Noach},
  title = {{The impact of short-term incentives on physical activity in a UK behavioural incentives programme}},
  journal = {Npj Digit. Medicine},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41746-019-0164-3},
}
Figure