The Impact of Self-Relevance on Preschool Children’s Sharing

Wenjie Zhang, Songmei Xiang, Hongmei Dai, Mengmeng Ren, Yuqi Shen, Wei Fan, Yiping ZhongFrontiers in Psychology 2019 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates how self-relevance—the psychological overlap between oneself and another—affects sharing behavior in preschool children. Using a forced-choice resource distribution paradigm, researchers examined children aged 3–6 in both first-party and third-party situations. Experiment 1 (first-party) involved 75 children sharing resources across non-costly, costly, and envy-inducing payoff structures. Experiment 2 (third-party) involved 62 children acting as neutral distributors. Results across both experiments (N = 137) revealed a clear "self-relevance gradient": children shared most with friends (high self-relevance), followed by acquaintances (moderate), and least with strangers (low). This selective generosity became more stable and sophisticated as children reached ages 5–6, particularly when sharing involved personal cost or social comparison.

Introduction

Preschoolers are often characterized as either inherently prosocial or naturally self-interested. However, recent research suggests their generosity is more nuanced, functioning as a calculated gradient based on social distance. This study addresses the mechanics of "selective generosity" by exploring how self-relevance—the degree of social and psychological connection—influences resource distribution. While previous studies often relied on a binary friend-vs-stranger comparison, this research introduces the "acquaintance" category to map a more complete social hierarchy. Furthermore, it contrasts first-party sharing (where the child incurs a cost) with third-party distribution (where the child acts as a neutral judge) to see how self-interest interacts with social preferences.

Methods

The researchers employed a forced-choice resource distribution paradigm using M&M chocolates as the currency. To quantify social distance, they used an adapted version of the Inclusion of Other in the Self (IOS) scale, categorizing recipients into three levels: High Self-Relevance (Friends), Moderate Self-Relevance (Acquaintances), and Low Self-Relevance (Strangers).

Experimental process overview showing the social distance categorization using the IOS scale and the resource distribution task interface.

Experimental Design

  • Experiment 1 (First-Party): Children acted as "dictators," choosing between two options that affected both themselves and a recipient. Payoff structures included non-costly (1:1 vs. 1:0), costly (1:1 vs. 2:0), and envy (0:0 vs. 1:2).
  • Experiment 2 (Third-Party): Children acted as neutral distributors between two other recipients (e.g., a friend and an acquaintance) with no personal gain or loss. Payoff structures included non-bias (3:1 vs 1:3), high self-bias, and low self-bias.

Results and Key Insights

The Gradient of Giving

Generosity in preschoolers is not a simple toggle switch. In both experiments, the main effect of self-relevance was highly significant ($p < 0.001$). Children demonstrated a clear hierarchy: Friends > Acquaintances > Strangers. This suggests that parochialism—favoring one's own group—is a fundamental organizational principle in early social development.

The "Age 5" Leap

While 3-year-olds show a preference for friends, their behavior is often inconsistent. When self-interest is high (e.g., costly trials), their ability to distinguish between acquaintances and strangers often collapses. By age 5–6, children become more sophisticated social navigators, maintaining the self-relevance gradient even when it costs them resources. This suggests that as the self-concept matures, the impact of social hierarchy on behavior becomes more stable.

The Envy Paradox

In the "Envy" condition of Experiment 1 (choosing between 0:0 and 1:2), older children (5–6) shared less than the younger group. This likely reflects a more mature sense of social comparison; older children are more sensitive to the perceived unfairness of a peer receiving more than them, leading to a preference for neither party receiving anything over an unequal distribution favoring the peer.

Discussion and Limitations

The study demonstrates that self-relevance is a primary driver of sharing behavior, with effects strengthening as children age. However, several factors warrant further investigation:

  • Cultural Context: Conducted in China, the results may reflect collectivist values where group benefit is prioritized. Cross-cultural studies are needed to determine if this gradient is universal or culturally specific.
  • Cognitive Mechanisms: The "Age 5 leap" might be driven by developments in executive function or Theory of Mind. Future research should integrate these cognitive measures to clarify the underlying drivers of social maturity.
  • Psychology of Envy: While older children showed increased sensitivity to unequal distributions, the specific motivation—whether driven by spite or a desire for equity—remains to be fully disentangled.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study was designed to investigate the impact of self-relevance between preschool children and recipients on children's sharing behavior in dictator games using a forced-choice resource distribution paradigm. Experiment 1: A total of 75 children aged 3-6 years were evaluated in a first-party situation in which they were distributed as recipients and dictators and shared resources with distracting recipients with different extents of self-relevance under three different payoff structures, including non-costly, costly, and envy structures. Children could choose between a sharing option and a non-sharing option. The results showed that, in a first-party situation, children aged 3-6 years old typically share more resources with highly self-relevant recipients (friends) than with moderately self-relevant recipients (acquaintances) and lowly self-relevant recipients (strangers) and that they share more resources with moderately self-relevant recipients (acquaintances) than lowly self-relevant recipients (strangers). Experiment 2: A total of 62 children aged 3-6 years old were evaluated in a third-party situation in which they were distributed not as recipients but only dictators, making decisions between the options of sharing more or sharing less with distracting recipients who had different extents of self-relevance under three different payoff structures, such as non-bias, high self-bias, and low self-bias. The results showed that, in a third-party situation, children typically share in a similar manner to that of Experiment 1, meaning that children display selective generosity and that the self-relevance between the children and recipients played a key role. Across age groups, this study of preschool children (total <i>N</i> = 137) demonstrates a degree of effect of self-relevance on preschool children's sharing in first-party and third-party situations, with highly self-relevant recipients receiving a more preferential share in the dictator game than those with low self-relevance, although this effect was stronger in the older preschool children.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2019impact,
  author = {Wenjie Zhang and Songmei Xiang and Hongmei Dai and Mengmeng Ren and Yuqi Shen and Wei Fan and Yiping Zhong},
  title = {{The Impact of Self-Relevance on Preschool Children’s Sharing}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2019.01028},
}
Figure