The Impact of Scour on Laterally Loaded Piles Bored and Socketed in Marine Clay

Chentao Li, Yang Xiao, Jieqing Liu, Qingwei Lin, Taotao Zhang, Jiaming LiuJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how underwater scour affects the lateral load capacity of bored piles used in marine structures. Using 3D finite element analysis validated with field data, the study quantifies the reduction in pile capacity due to different scour types and geometries, ultimately proposing a new semi-empirical formula for engineers to quickly assess these impacts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bridges and offshore structures in deep water often rely on bored pile foundations. A critical threat to these foundations is scour, the erosion of soil around them by water flow. Scour can significantly reduce the soil's support, leading to increased pile deflection, reduced lateral capacity, and potentially catastrophic structural failure. While the general phenomenon of scour is understood, there's a need for a practical, quantitative method to assess its specific impact on the lateral load-bearing capacity of bored piles socketed into marine clay, especially considering various scour scenarios.

Methods

The researchers employed a three-dimensional finite element (FE) numerical analysis using PLAXIS 3D. The core of their approach involved:

  • Model Calibration: A detailed FE model of a drilled pile was created and validated against existing field test data of a laterally loaded pile in soft marine clay that did not experience scour. This step ensured the model's accuracy in simulating soil-pile interaction.
  • Scour Simulation: The FE model was then adapted to simulate various scour conditions. This included modeling:
  • Global Scour: Represented by removing a soil layer of varying thickness (0 to 3 times the pile diameter).
  • Local Scour: Modeled by creating scour holes with varying depths (S₁/D), widths (Sᵥ), and slope angles (α).
  • Lateral Load Application: After establishing the scour conditions, lateral loads were applied to the pile head to simulate real-world forces.
  • Semi-Empirical Formula Development: Based on the FE simulation results, the authors developed a new formula to predict the reduction in lateral pile capacity due to scour. This formula combines the effects of global and local scour and is expressed using dimensionless parameters.

Datasets

The study utilized field test data from a previously published study on a laterally loaded drilled pile (LTP-4) at the Incheon Bridge site for model calibration and validation. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Scour is a significant threat: The study unequivocally demonstrates that scour substantially reduces the lateral load capacity of bored piles in marine clay. This underscores the importance of considering scour in foundation design.
  • Scour depth is paramount: The depth of both global and local scour emerged as the most critical factor influencing the reduction in pile capacity. Deeper scour leads to a more pronounced loss of capacity.
  • Scour type matters: While both global and local scour reduce capacity, their effects and the resulting pile behavior can differ. The paper quantifies these differences.
  • Local scour geometry is influential: For local scour, the depth (S₁/D) has the most significant impact, followed by width (Sᵥ) and slope angle (α). However, the width's impact is less pronounced once it exceeds a certain threshold.
  • Bending moments increase: Scour not only reduces lateral capacity but also increases bending moments along the pile length, potentially shifting the location of maximum bending further down. This necessitates careful consideration of pile reinforcement.
  • A practical predictive tool: The development of a semi-empirical formula offers a valuable, quick method for engineers to estimate the impact of scour on pile capacity without needing complex FE analyses for every scenario.

Key Results

  • Capacity Reduction: Global scour with depths of 1D, 2D, and 3D reduced pile capacity by 14.32%, 29.31%, and potentially more, respectively. Local scour at depths of 1.0D and 1.5D reduced capacity by 11.93% and 15.90%, respectively.
  • Formula Validation: The proposed semi-empirical formula (Equation 9) was validated against numerical results and existing literature, showing good agreement and providing a reliable estimation tool.
  • Parameter Sensitivity: Scour depth and type were found to be strongly related to capacity reduction, while scour hole width and slope angle had a moderate influence.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Simplified Piling Process: The study simplified the pile installation process, which might lead to slight deviations from real-world conditions.
  • No Vertical Load Consideration: The analysis focused solely on lateral loads. The combined effect of vertical and lateral loads under scour conditions was not investigated.
  • Limited Field Data: While validated against one field test, more extensive field data, especially for combined scour scenarios and different soil types, would enhance confidence.
  • No Upper Fixation: The formula does not account for the effect of upper pile fixation.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Investigating the interaction between global and local scour more deeply.
  • Exploring the impact of vertical loads and pile length on scour effects.
  • Expanding the validation with more field data and different soil conditions.
  • Considering the effect of upper pile fixation in the formula.

Summary updated

Abstract

The majority of long-span bridges and offshore construction in deep water are supported by bored pile foundations. Pile foundations under water will be susceptible to scour, which will pose a significant danger to their safe operation. A three-dimensional finite element (FE) numerical analysis was conducted to examine the influence of scour on the responses of laterally loaded drilled piles in marine clays. First, the FE numerical model was calibrated using field test data of a drilled pile that did not include scour in soft marine clay. The findings of numerical modeling reveal that scour decreases the ultimate lateral capacity of socketed drilled piles, with the percentage of reduction being strongly related to scour types and depth, but moderately related to scour hole width and slope angle. Finally, a semi-empirical formula for calculating the effects of scour on the lateral capacity of socketed drilled piles following scour is presented. This method may be utilized fast and effectively to calculate scour’s effects.
BibTeX
@article{li2022impact,
  author = {Chentao Li and Yang Xiao and Jieqing Liu and Qingwei Lin and Taotao Zhang and Jiaming Liu},
  title = {{The Impact of Scour on Laterally Loaded Piles Bored and Socketed in Marine Clay}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse10111636},
}
Figure