The impact of regional heterogeneity in whole-brain dynamics in the presence of oscillations

Yonatan Sanz Perl, Gorka Zamora‐López, Ernest Montbrió, Martí Monge-Asensio, Jakub Vohryzek, Sol Fittipaldi, Cecilia González Campo, Sebastián Moguilner, Agustín Ibáñez, Enzo Tagliazucchi, B.t. Thomas Yeo, Morten L. Kringelbach, Gustavo DecoNetwork 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how regional differences in brain structure and function impact large-scale brain dynamics, particularly when the brain is in an oscillating state. By using two different computational models and fitting them to fMRI data, the researchers found that incorporating these regional variations significantly improves the models' ability to replicate real brain activity, especially in cases of neurodegeneration like Alzheimer's disease.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The brain is a complex system with immense variability across its regions in terms of cellular makeup, connectivity, and function. While computational models have been useful in understanding how these variations influence brain activity, most previous work focused on asynchronous brain states. However, the brain often operates in a synchronous, oscillating state, and the role of regional differences in this oscillatory regime remained poorly understood. This paper aims to bridge that gap by investigating how regional heterogeneity affects whole-brain dynamics when the system is exhibiting oscillatory behavior, a ubiquitous phenomenon in brain activity.

Methods

The authors employed two whole-brain models capable of exhibiting oscillatory behavior, both incorporating a "Hopf bifurcation" – a point where a system can transition from a stable, non-oscillating state to a self-sustained oscillation.

  1. Stuart-Landau (SL) Oscillator Model: A phenomenological model using coupled nonlinear oscillators, a well-established approach for modeling brain dynamics near bifurcations.
  2. Exact Mean-Field (EMF) Model: A more biophysically grounded model derived from quadratic integrate-and-fire neurons, offering a more detailed representation of local neuronal populations.

Both models were fitted to empirical fMRI data. The regional heterogeneity was introduced by modulating the models' bifurcation parameters using structural information (T1w/T2w MRI signal ratio, indicative of myelin content) and functional information (global brain connectivity). They then evaluated the models' performance using several metrics: functional connectivity (FC), global brain connectivity (GBC), causal ignition (CI), and the Kuramoto order parameter (KoP) for synchronization.

Datasets

  • Human Connectome Project (HCP) dataset: Resting-state fMRI data from 1000 healthy participants was used for fitting the models and establishing baseline functional and structural properties.
  • Alzheimer's Disease (AD) dataset: Resting-state fMRI data from 39 AD patients and 35 healthy controls was used to investigate the impact of disease-specific regional heterogeneity.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Oscillations Matter: The presence of oscillations is crucial for accurately modeling brain dynamics, and regional heterogeneity plays a significant role in this oscillatory regime.
  • Heterogeneity is Key: Simply including regional variations (structural or functional) significantly improves the models' ability to capture empirical brain activity, outperforming homogeneous models.
  • Disease-Specific Heterogeneity is Powerful: For modeling neurodegenerative conditions like Alzheimer's, using disease-specific functional heterogeneity (derived from AD patient data) leads to much better model fits than using healthy control heterogeneity or a homogeneous model.
  • Models Behave Similarly at the Brink: Both the simpler phenomenological SL model and the more complex biophysical EMF model show similar improvements when regional heterogeneity is included, especially near the Hopf bifurcation point. This suggests that the SL model, despite its simplicity, captures essential dynamics.
  • T1w/T2w Ratio as a Proxy: The T1w/T2w MRI signal ratio proved to be a useful proxy for regional heterogeneity, influencing the models' ability to reproduce empirical data.

Key Results

  • Both the SL and EMF models showed improved fitting of empirical data (FC, GBC, CI) when regional heterogeneity was incorporated, compared to homogeneous models.
  • For AD patients, models incorporating AD-specific functional heterogeneity (based on GBC) showed significantly better performance in reproducing empirical FC, GBC, and CI compared to models using healthy control heterogeneity or a homogeneous model.
  • The study found that optimal model performance often occurred near the Hopf bifurcation, suggesting that the brain operates at a critical point between stable states and sustained oscillations.
  • Statistical significance (P < 0.001) was consistently observed for the improvements gained by including regional heterogeneity across various metrics and models.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The authors note that computing causal ignition (CI) directly on the Alzheimer's dataset was not possible due to data limitations, requiring a simplified proxy.
  • Scope of Heterogeneity: While the study focused on T1w/T2w ratio and GBC for heterogeneity, the authors acknowledge that other sources of regional variation (e.g., gene expression, cytoarchitecture) exist and were not explored here.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest extending this framework to incorporate multiple classes of heterogeneities (structural and functional, specific and non-specific) simultaneously to build more comprehensive models. They also propose investigating the interplay between different types of brain maps and their impact on oscillatory models. Furthermore, they highlight the need for integrative models of neurodegeneration that can account for the inherent heterogeneity in these diseases.

Summary updated

Abstract

Large variability exists across brain regions in health and disease, considering their cellular and molecular composition, connectivity, and function. Large-scale whole-brain models comprising coupled brain regions provide insights into the underlying dynamics that shape complex patterns of spontaneous brain activity. In particular, biophysically grounded mean-field whole-brain models in the asynchronous regime were used to demonstrate the dynamical consequences of including regional variability. Nevertheless, the role of heterogeneities when brain dynamics are supported by synchronous oscillating state, which is a ubiquitous phenomenon in brain, remains poorly understood. Here, we implemented two models capable of presenting oscillatory behavior with different levels of abstraction: a phenomenological Stuart-Landau model and an exact mean-field model. The fit of these models informed by structural- to functional-weighted MRI signal (T1w/T2w) allowed us to explore the implication of the inclusion of heterogeneities for modeling resting-state fMRI recordings from healthy participants. We found that disease-specific regional functional heterogeneity imposed dynamical consequences within the oscillatory regime in fMRI recordings from neurodegeneration with specific impacts on brain atrophy/structure (Alzheimer's patients). Overall, we found that models with oscillations perform better when structural and functional regional heterogeneities are considered, showing that phenomenological and biophysical models behave similarly at the brink of the Hopf bifurcation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{perl2022impact,
  author = {Yonatan Sanz Perl and Gorka Zamora‐López and Ernest Montbrió and Martí Monge-Asensio and Jakub Vohryzek and Sol Fittipaldi and Cecilia González Campo and Sebastián Moguilner and Agustín Ibáñez and Enzo Tagliazucchi and B.T. Thomas Yeo and Morten L. Kringelbach and Gustavo Deco},
  title = {{The impact of regional heterogeneity in whole-brain dynamics in the presence of oscillations}},
  booktitle = {Network},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1162/netn\_a\_00299},
}
Figure