The Impact of Preferential Policy on Corporate Green Innovation: A Resource Dependence Perspective

Chuang Li, Shihai Feng, Qiang Yuan, Junnian Wei, Shiqi Wang, Dongdong HuangSustainability 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that China's 2017 R&D tax reduction policy significantly boosts both the quantity and quality of green innovation in small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). The policy's effectiveness is driven by increased R&D investment and eased financing constraints, with its impact being particularly strong for non-state-owned firms, those in resource-scarce industries, and those in highly polluted regions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Governments worldwide are increasingly using preferential policies, like R&D tax breaks, to encourage corporate green innovation and drive sustainable development. However, there's a lack of clarity on how these policies actually work and when they are most effective. Existing research often focuses on large corporations, overlooking the crucial role of Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (SMEs), which are vital for a green transition but often face resource limitations. This paper aims to fill these gaps by exploring the mechanisms behind R&D tax policies' impact on SMEs' green innovation and identifying the specific conditions that amplify their effectiveness.

Methods

The study employs a Difference-in-Differences (DID) approach, using China's 2017 R&D tax reduction policy for technology-based SMEs as a quasi-natural experiment. This method allows researchers to compare the changes in green innovation outcomes for treated SMEs (those eligible for the policy) against a control group of similar SMEs that did not receive the policy.

To understand the "how," the researchers developed a dual-mediation framework. This framework investigates two key pathways:

  1. Internal Mechanism: How tax reductions increase R&D investment intensity within firms.
  2. External Mechanism: How tax reductions alleviate financing constraints, making it easier for firms to access capital.

The study also incorporates multi-level contextual moderators to address the "when" question, examining how firm ownership (state-owned vs. non-state-owned), industry resource munificence, and regional pollution levels influence the policy's effectiveness.

Datasets

The study utilizes a balanced panel dataset of 7048 enterprise-year observations from Chinese SMEs listed on the New Third Board, Growth Enterprise Market, and National Equities Exchange and Quotations. The data spans from 2013 to 2020, with 2013-2016 serving as the pre-policy baseline and 2017-2019 as the policy implementation period. Patent data from the China National Research Data Service (CNRDS) was used to measure green innovation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dual Impact of Tax Policy: R&D tax reductions aren't just about giving money back; they work through two distinct but complementary channels: boosting internal R&D spending and easing external financial pressures.
  • SMEs as Sensitive Receivers: SMEs, often resource-constrained, are particularly responsive to these policies. Their reliance on external support makes them more attuned to the incentives offered by tax breaks.
  • Context is King: The effectiveness of R&D tax policies is not uniform. It's significantly amplified in specific contexts:
  • Non-State-Owned Enterprises: These firms, lacking the inherent advantages of state-owned counterparts, benefit more from the policy's resource injection.
  • Resource-Constrained Industries: Firms in industries facing scarcity are more dependent on external support, making them more receptive to tax incentives.
  • High-Pollution Regions: These regions often face greater environmental pressures and costs, making them more inclined to leverage policies that support green innovation.
  • Quantity vs. Quality: While the policy boosts both the number of green patents (quantity) and the sophistication of those patents (quality), the study hints that sustained R&D investment might contribute more significantly to innovation quality.

Key Results

  • Significant Positive Impact: The DID analysis shows that R&D tax reductions significantly promote green innovation in SMEs, with the interaction term being statistically significant at the 0.1% confidence level.
  • Mediating Effects:
    • R&D tax reductions significantly reduce financing constraints (KZ).
  • R&D tax reductions significantly increase R&D investment intensity (lrdratio).
  • Both reduced financing constraints and increased R&D investment intensity positively impact both the quantity (greenrd) and quality (greenrdq) of green innovation.
  • Heterogeneity Analysis:
    • Non-SOEs show a stronger positive impact of R&D tax reductions on green innovation compared to SOEs.
  • Firms with low ROA (indicating higher financial constraints) exhibit a stronger policy effect.
  • Enterprises in regions with higher PM pollution levels show a stronger policy promotion effect, particularly for green innovation quality.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Data Scope: The study focuses on technology-based SMEs listed on specific boards in China. Future research could explore other types of firms or regions.
  • Short-Term Focus: The DID method primarily captures short- to medium-term impacts. The long-term cumulative effects of continuous policy support and potential "path dependence" for green innovation are not fully explored.
  • Potential Negative Effects: The study acknowledges the need for research into potential negative effects, such as firms engaging in short-term innovation behaviors or becoming overly dependent on subsidies.
  • Broader Context: While the study examines ownership, industry, and regional factors, future work could delve deeper into corporate governance, market competition, and industry technology maturity.

Future research could also leverage advancements in tax data (like China's Golden Tax system) to conduct more dynamic matching of policies and corporate behaviors, and extend the observation window to better understand long-term policy impacts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Government support has long been viewed as a key driver of sustainable transformation and green technological progress. However, the underlying mechanisms (“how”) through which preferential policies influence green innovation, as well as the contextual conditions (“when”) that shape their effectiveness, remain insufficiently understood. Drawing on resource dependence theory, this study develops a dual-mediation framework to investigate how preferential tax policies promote both the quantity and quality of green innovation—by enhancing R&D investment as an internal mechanism and alleviating financing constraints as an external mechanism. These effects are especially salient among non-state-owned enterprises, firms in resource-constrained industries, and those situated in environmentally challenged regions—contexts that entail higher dependence on external support for sustainable development. Leveraging China’s 2017 R&D tax reduction policy as a quasi-natural experiment, this study uses a sample of high-tech small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) to test the hypotheses. The findings provide robust evidence on how preferential policies contribute to corporate sustainability through green innovation and identify the conditions under which policy tools are most effective. This research offers important implications for designing targeted, sustainability-oriented innovation policies that support SMEs in transitioning toward more sustainable practices.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2025impact,
  author = {Chuang Li and Shihai Feng and Qiang Yuan and Junnian Wei and Shiqi Wang and Dongdong Huang},
  title = {{The Impact of Preferential Policy on Corporate Green Innovation: A Resource Dependence Perspective}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/su17156834},
}
Figure