The Impact of Low-Carbon Pilot City Policy on Corporate Green Technology Innovation in a Sustainable Development Context—Evidence from Chinese Listed Companies

Jun Wang, Zhuofei Liu, Long Shi, Jinghua TanSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how China's "Low-Carbon Pilot City" policy influences green technology innovation in listed companies. The findings reveal that the policy successfully stimulates green patent applications, particularly among non-state-owned enterprises and those in economically developed eastern regions, and that digital transformation further amplifies this effect.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Climate change is a pressing global issue, and China, as a major emitter, is actively seeking strategies for sustainable development. A key initiative is the "Low-Carbon Pilot City" policy, designed to encourage a low-carbon economy. While previous research has examined the macro-level impacts of this policy on energy efficiency and carbon emissions, there's a significant gap in understanding its micro-level effects on corporate green technology innovation. This paper aims to fill that gap by analyzing how the policy specifically drives innovation within Chinese listed companies, moving beyond aggregate city or industry-level analyses.

Methods

The core methodology employed is a multi-period Difference-in-Difference (DID) model. This approach is well-suited for evaluating the impact of policy interventions by comparing outcomes in regions that implemented the policy (treatment group) with those that did not (control group) over time. The "multi-period" aspect is crucial because China's pilot cities were designated in three distinct batches (2010, 2012, and 2017), meaning the policy's introduction varied across regions.

To address potential selection bias and ensure the robustness of the results, the authors also employed Propensity Score Matching (PSM). PSM helps create more comparable treatment and control groups by matching firms based on observable characteristics, thereby mitigating the "self-selection bias" that can arise when regions voluntarily adopt pilot policies. The study also includes a parallel trend test to confirm that the treatment and control groups exhibited similar trends in green innovation before the policy intervention.

Datasets

The study utilizes a comprehensive dataset of Chinese A-share listed companies from 2007 to 2019. This dataset includes:

  • Patent Data: Specifically, green patent applications, sourced from the State Intellectual Property Office of the People's Republic of China. The "Green List" from the World Intellectual Property Organization was used to classify these patents.
  • Corporate-level Data: Financial and operational data for listed companies, obtained from the CSMAR database.
  • City-level Data: Economic and environmental indicators from China City Statistical Yearbooks.

The sample was restricted to manufacturing enterprises, as green technology innovation is most active in this sector.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Policy Effectiveness: The low-carbon pilot city policy isn't just symbolic; it demonstrably drives tangible innovation in green technologies. This suggests that targeted policy interventions can be effective levers for environmental progress.
  • Heterogeneity Matters: The impact of the policy isn't uniform. It disproportionately benefits certain types of firms and regions, highlighting the need for nuanced policy design and implementation.
  • Digitalization as an Amplifier: The study reveals that digital transformation isn't just about efficiency; it actively enhances a company's ability to innovate in green technologies, especially when spurred by policy. This points to a synergistic relationship between digital adoption and environmental innovation.

Key Results

  • Overall Impact: The low-carbon pilot city policy significantly promotes green technology innovation, as measured by the number of green patent applications. The estimated effect suggests an approximate 4.5% increase in green patent applications.
  • Ownership Matters: Non-state-owned enterprises (non-SOEs) show a much stronger positive response to the policy compared to state-owned enterprises (SOEs). The policy significantly promotes green innovation in non-SOEs, while its effect on SOEs is not significant.
  • Geographic Differences: Enterprises in the eastern region of China, which is more economically developed, experience a greater boost in green technology innovation from the policy compared to those in the central and western regions.
  • Sectoral Differences: Companies listed on the Growth Enterprise Market (GEM), typically smaller, growth-oriented firms, benefit more from the policy than those on the main board. This is attributed to their greater reliance on intellectual property and flexibility.
  • Digitalization Boost: Listed companies with a high degree of digitalization are significantly more active in green technology innovation under the low-carbon pilot city policy. Conversely, firms with low digitalization show no significant policy effect.
  • Patent Type: The policy primarily promotes green invention patents, which are generally more innovative, rather than green utility model patents.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Data Availability: Insufficient data disclosure led to some missing values, potentially affecting the completeness of the analysis.
  • Equity Structure Heterogeneity: The analysis of different equity structures yielded limited conclusions, suggesting this area requires further in-depth research.
  • Generalizability: While the study focuses on China, the specific policy context and its impact might differ in other countries.

Future research could delve deeper into the nuances of equity structures and explore the policy's impact across a wider range of industries and regions. The findings also suggest that further policy support for digitalization and targeted incentives for SOEs could enhance the effectiveness of low-carbon initiatives.

Summary updated

Abstract

The low-carbon pilot city policy is an important initiative to explore the path of a win-win situation for both the economy and the environment. Since 2010, China has established 87 low-carbon pilot cities. This policy implementation aims to encourage green technology innovation among listed companies, thereby achieving sustainable corporate growth through the promotion of energy efficiency and renewable energy. This paper aims to unveil the relationship between low-carbon pilot city policies and green technology innovation. This paper explores the impact of policy implementation based on patent data of Chinese listed companies from 2007 to 2019. Empirical results show that the policy can promote green technology innovation among listed companies in the pilot cities. This finding still holds in the parallel trend test and the PSM-Multi-period DID test. Second, the policy has a greater effect on the green-technology innovation of non-state enterprises and can promote more green technology innovation activities of enterprises in the eastern region compared with other areas. Furthermore, in terms of different stock sectors, the low-carbon pilot city policy can significantly promote GEM-affiliated enterprises’ green technology innovation activities. Finally, listed companies with a high degree of digital transformation are more active in green technology innovation in the context of low-carbon pilot city policy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2022impact,
  author = {Jun Wang and Zhuofei Liu and Long Shi and Jinghua Tan},
  title = {{The Impact of Low-Carbon Pilot City Policy on Corporate Green Technology Innovation in a Sustainable Development Context—Evidence from Chinese Listed Companies}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su141710953},
}
Figure