The Impact of Innovation Policy Mix on Innovation Capability of SMEs

Tian ZhouFrontiers in Business Economics and Management 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Innovation is a key driver of economic development, with Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (SMEs) serving as primary innovation subjects in China. However, innovation's inherent risks and positive externalities necessitate government support. This study analyzes the impact of supply-based, demand-based, and environmental-based innovation policies on listed SMEs from 2015 to 2019. We find that supply and environmental policies significantly enhance innovation capability, while demand-based policies currently show no significant impact. Furthermore, supply and environmental policies exhibit a complementary synergy that effectively alleviates corporate financing constraints. These effects vary across regions and firm characteristics, suggesting a need for more tailored policy applications.

Introduction

SMEs are the backbone of China's innovation landscape, yet they frequently encounter a "financing wall" where high costs and uncertainty stifle creative output. While the Chinese government has introduced numerous support policies, the current mix is heavily imbalanced. Over 90% of these policies focus on supply (subsidies) or the environment (tax breaks), while less than 10% focus on creating demand through procurement. This paper investigates the efficacy of these individual policy tools and, more importantly, whether they work better together or simply overlap.

Methods and Data

The research utilizes a sample of 2,299 observations from A-share listed SMEs covering the period from 2015 to 2019. Data is drawn from major Chinese databases including CSMAR, CNRDS, and the China Government Procurement Network.

Following Rothwell’s framework, policies are categorized into:

  • Supply-based: Direct financial support and subsidies.
  • Demand-based: Government procurement and market creation.
  • Environmental-based: Tax incentives, such as R&D super-deductions.

A fixed-effects regression model is employed to measure the impact of these policies on innovation output, measured by patent applications lagged by one year. Additionally, the SA index is used to test whether policy synergy eases financing constraints.

Key Results: Individual and Joint Policy Impact

Regression analysis reveals that supply-based and environmental-based policies have significant positive impacts on innovation output. As shown in Figure 1, the individual coefficients for Supply (0.324) and Env (0.353) are both positive and statistically significant at the 1% level.

In contrast, demand-based policies (Demand) fail to show a significant effect across the models. This suggests that current government procurement systems may favor existing, low-risk products over innovative new ones, or that "rent-seeking" behavior limits the policy's effectiveness.

Regression results showing the impact of individual and combined innovation policies on patent output.

The Synergy Effect and Financing Constraints

A critical finding is the synergy between supply and environmental policies. When modeled together, they are complementary: subsidies provide immediate cash flow, while tax deductions reduce long-term costs.

As demonstrated in Figure 2, the interaction between supply and environmental policies (Supply*Env) is significantly positive for innovation (0.040) and significantly negative for financing constraints (-0.012 on the SA index). This indicates that the policy mix effectively eases the financing burden for SMEs by signaling stability to external investors, thereby attracting additional private funding.

Mechanism testing of policy synergy and its impact on financing constraints (SA index).

Conclusion and Policy Implications

The study highlights that while supply and environmental policies are effective, the failure of demand-side policies represents a missed opportunity. Policy design should move away from generalized support toward a more balanced and tailored approach. Specifically, the government should reform procurement systems to target "first-unit" innovative products and consider regional differences; for instance, environmental policies provide stronger incentives for firms in central and western regions, while supply-based policies are more effective in the east.

Summary updated

Abstract

Innovation has become an important engine for promoting rapid economic development to high-quality development in the 21st century. Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) are the most important innovation subjects in China, but due to the risk characteristics and positive externalities of innovation, innovation cannot only rely on the spontaneous behavior of enterprises, but also needs the support of national innovation policies. Based on this, this paper takes the listed SMEs from 2015 to 2019 as a sample to study the impact of three types of innovation policies—supply-based innovation policies, demand-based innovation policies, and environmental-based innovation policies on the innovation activities of SMEs. Further, we will explore whether there is synergy between different types of policies from the perspective of policy tool combination. The study found that supply-based innovation policy and environmental-based innovation policy can significantly improve the innovation capability of enterprises, while demand-based innovation policy has no significant impact. In addition, supply-based policies and environmental-based policies are complementary, which can alleviate the inhibitory effect of corporate financing constraints on innovation. This conclusion still holds under different robustness tests. Finally, this paper finds that the single and combined effects of innovation policies show differences in enterprises with different characteristics. For enterprises in the eastern region, high-tech enterprises, and large-scale enterprises, the supply-based innovation policy has a stronger role in promoting innovation. For enterprises in the central and western regions and high-tech enterprises, the environmental innovation policy has a stronger incentive for innovation, and the policy synergies exist only in eastern enterprises, high-tech enterprises and small-scale enterprises.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2022impact,
  author = {Tian Zhou},
  title = {{The Impact of Innovation Policy Mix on Innovation Capability of SMEs}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Business Economics and Management},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.54097/fbem.v4i1.397},
}
Figure