The impact of information technology on accounting systems towards SME performance in Malaysia

Shamsul Nahar Abdullah, Azbariyah Aziz, Batrisyia Qysara SaifulazriJournal of Social Economics Research 2023 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates the impact of accounting information systems (AIS) on the performance of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in Malaysia. Given the critical role of SMEs in the national economy, understanding the drivers of their success is paramount. The research tests five key features of an accounting system—accuracy, efficiency, reliability, data quality, and ease of use—against firm performance. Using a sample of 112 respondents from SMEs in the Klang Valley, the study employed a quantitative approach with data collected via online questionnaires. The findings reveal that three specific features are positively and significantly related to SME performance: accuracy, reliability, and data quality. Consequently, for an accounting system to effectively support management decision-making, it must prioritize the generation of precise and dependable data. The study also highlights the necessity of continuous training and a strong organizational culture to maintain high standards of data integrity.

Introduction

Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (SMEs) are the backbone of the Malaysian economy, yet they frequently struggle with high failure rates due to volatile market conditions and intense competition. While many firms have adopted automated accounting information systems (AIS) to improve operations, it has remained unclear which specific technological attributes actually translate into superior business outcomes.

This research moves beyond the basic question of IT adoption to identify the qualitative characteristics of software that serve as primary catalysts for firm success. By focusing on the Malaysian context, particularly the industrial hub of the Klang Valley, the study provides actionable insights for SME owners and managers looking to optimize their digital transformation efforts.

Methodology

The researchers employed a quantitative methodology grounded in the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) and Data Processing Theory.

Survey Instrument and Sampling

A closed-ended questionnaire using a five-point Likert scale was developed, drawing from established academic literature. Data was collected via convenience sampling from 112 valid respondents, including accountants, managers, and executives. The majority of respondents (58.9%) were aged 21-30, reflecting a young professional demographic in the sector.

Variables

The study analyzed five independent variables representing AIS features and their impact on the dependent variable, SME Performance.

Table 1: Variables and levels of measurement used in the study.

Multiple Regression Analysis was utilized to test the relationships between these variables and determine which features significantly contribute to organizational performance.

Results and Discussion

Software Usage Profile

The descriptive analysis of the dataset provided a breakdown of the AIS software currently utilized by Malaysian SMEs. The results indicate a concentrated market, with Sage (28%) and Auto Count (21%) being the most popular choices among the surveyed firms.

Table 2: Frequency and percentage of accounting software used by surveyed SMEs.

The "Trust Trio" of Performance Drivers

The regression model was robust, with an Adjusted $R^2$ of 0.71, meaning the tested AIS features explain 71% of the variance in SME performance. The analysis identified three significant predictors:

  • Data Quality ($p < 0.01$): This emerged as the strongest predictor of performance. High-quality data ensures that management has the relevant information needed for strategic planning.
  • Reliability ($p < 0.05$): A significant positive impact was found, suggesting that dependable system outputs are crucial for operational stability.
  • Accuracy ($p < 0.10$): Moderately significant, accuracy ensures that financial reporting is error-free, supporting precise decision-making.

The Efficiency Paradox

Interestingly, the statistical model showed that Efficiency and Ease of Use did not have a significant independent impact on performance in this sample. This suggests that for Malaysian SMEs, the correctness and trustworthiness of the output are far more vital than the speed or user-friendliness of the system. In a competitive environment, the integrity of data outweighs the convenience of the interface.

Conclusion and Future Work

The study concludes that AIS is not a "set it and forget it" solution. To drive performance, systems must produce accurate, reliable, and high-quality data. This requires a synergy between technology and human capital; companies must invest in continuous training for accountants and foster an organizational culture that values data excellence.

Limitations

Future research should address the geographic concentration of this study by including samples from East Malaysia. Additionally, moving from convenience sampling to random sampling would enhance the generalizability of the findings. Incorporating "soft" variables such as management style and external environmental factors could also provide a more holistic view of SME success in the digital age.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study seeks to investigate the impact of accounting information systems on the performance of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in Malaysia. SMEs were the focus of this study due to their importance to the economy. The features of an accounting system, namely accuracy, efficiency, reliability, data quality, and ease of use, were tested against the performance of a sample of SMEs that implemented an Accounting Information System (AIS) in their companies. A closed-ended questionnaire consisting of a five-point Likert scale was used to gather the data. Convenience sampling was utilized to collect data from a sample size of 112 respondents using questionnaires distributed via online platforms, including social media, messaging applications, and email. The findings revealed that only three features of an accounting information system were positively related to the performance of SMEs in Malaysia, namely accuracy, reliability, and ease of use. Therefore, an accounting system must generate accurate, reliable, and easy-to-use data to assist management in making informed decisions. Companies need to provide internal and external training for accountants and decision-makers and give organizational culture the attention it deserves as it impacts accounting data quality. This training should aim to promote a strong work ethic and a culture of excellence.
BibTeX
@article{abdullah2023impact,
  author = {Shamsul Nahar Abdullah and Azbariyah Aziz and Batrisyia Qysara Saifulazri},
  title = {{The impact of information technology on accounting systems towards SME performance in Malaysia}},
  journal = {Journal of Social Economics Research},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.18488/35.v10i2.3406},
}
Figure