The Impact of High-Tech Policies on Corporate ESG Performance: Evidence from China

Feiwei Qin, Mao ZhangSustainability 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how China's "new quality productivity" (NQP) policy impacts corporate Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) performance. The research finds that NQP significantly boosts ESG performance, primarily by easing financing constraints and enhancing employee innovation, with a notable positive effect on environmental and social aspects.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In an era of increasing resource and environmental constraints, China is promoting "new quality productivity" (NQP) as a key driver for high-quality economic development. While NQP is linked to technological innovation and sustainable growth, its specific impact on corporate ESG performance and the underlying mechanisms remain underexplored. Existing research often focuses on ESG's impact on financial performance or general corporate strategies, leaving a gap in understanding how a specific high-tech policy like NQP influences a company's ESG standing. This paper aims to fill this gap by examining NQP's micro-level effects on ESG performance in Chinese listed companies.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • New Quality Productivity Index Construction: A novel index for NQP at the enterprise level was constructed using machine learning techniques, specifically text mining of annual reports. This involved:
  • Defining NQP based on factors like "quality people," "new labor information," "technological innovation," and "sustainable development."
    • Preparing text data and performing Chinese word segmentation using the Jieba library.
  • Developing a bespoke dictionary by expanding seed words from government policy reports and industry documents, enhanced by a similarity algorithm (cosine similarity) and Word2Vec embeddings.
  • Calculating the NQP index using TF-IDF weighting.
  • Econometric Analysis: Regression models were used to assess the impact of NQP on ESG performance and to explore mediating mechanisms.
  • Direct Impact: A regression model (Equation 2) was used to test the direct relationship between NQP and ESG performance.
  • Mechanism Analysis: Separate models were constructed to test the mediating roles of financing constraints (SA index, Equation 3) and innovation efficiency (RD index, Equation 4).
  • Robustness Checks: The study employed several methods to ensure the reliability of its findings, including:
  • First-order difference GMM model to address potential endogeneity.
  • Replacing ESG rating data with Bloomberg ESG ratings.
  • Adding a lagged term for NQP.
  • Incorporating a provincial time trend.
  • Omitted variable regression analysis.
  • Heterogeneity Analysis: The study examined how NQP's impact varies across different types of enterprises, specifically by age (long-established vs. short-established) and pollution level (heavily polluting vs. non-heavily polluting).
  • ESG Uncertainty Analysis: An ESG uncertainty index was constructed to investigate its moderating effect on the NQP-ESG relationship.

Datasets

  • Company Data: Annual reports of A-share listed companies on the Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchanges from 2012 to 2022.
  • Databases: CSMAR and Wind databases were used for company financial and ESG data.
  • ESG Ratings: Huazheng ESG rating data was the primary source, with Bloomberg ESG rating used for robustness checks.
  • Policy Documents: Government policy reports (e.g., "14th Five-Year Plan") and industry governance documents were used to construct the NQP dictionary.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • NQP as a Policy Lever for ESG: The study strongly suggests that government policies promoting "new quality productivity" can be a powerful tool to drive corporate ESG improvements, not just economic growth.
  • Financing Constraints as a Key Mediator: A significant finding is that NQP helps companies overcome financing hurdles. This is crucial because easier access to capital allows firms to invest more in ESG initiatives.
  • Innovation Efficiency is Crucial: NQP's positive impact on ESG is partly channeled through enhanced innovation efficiency, suggesting that technological advancement directly fuels better environmental and social practices.
  • Environmental and Social Focus: NQP appears to have a more pronounced positive effect on the environmental and social dimensions of ESG, aligning with its focus on sustainable and green development.
  • ESG Uncertainty Dampens Impact: The positive effects of NQP on ESG performance are weakened in environments with high ESG rating uncertainty, highlighting the importance of clear and consistent ESG reporting standards.
  • Heavily Polluting Firms Benefit More: Enterprises in heavily polluting industries show a stronger positive response to NQP in terms of ESG performance, likely due to increased pressure and incentives to adopt greener practices.

Key Results

  • Significant Positive Impact: New quality productivity has a statistically significant positive impact on corporate ESG performance, with the coefficient for NEP being 0.0514 (at the 1% level).
  • Financing Constraints Alleviated: NQP significantly mitigates financing constraints, with the estimated coefficient for SA being significantly negative.
  • Innovation Efficiency Enhanced: NQP positively impacts innovation efficiency, supporting Hypothesis 3.
  • Heterogeneity: Long-established enterprises and heavily polluting enterprises show a more pronounced positive impact of NQP on their ESG performance.
  • ESG Uncertainty Moderation: The interaction term between NQP and ESG uncertainty was statistically significant and negative, indicating that uncertainty diminishes NQP's positive impact.
  • Sub-item Impact: NQP significantly enhances environmental (E) and social (S) ratings, but its impact on corporate governance (G) ratings was not statistically significant.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Scope: The study focuses exclusively on Chinese companies and does not account for variations in other economies or industries.
  • ESG Uncertainty Measurement: While an ESG uncertainty index was constructed, the methodology for combining ratings from different agencies might have limitations.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest:
  • Investigating the moderating effect of regional heterogeneity on the NQP-ESG relationship.
  • Exploring the interaction between NQP and other corporate performance dimensions (e.g., financial performance, brand reputation).
  • Conducting international comparative studies to analyze NQP and ESG practices across different countries and regions.

Summary updated

Abstract

In light of resource and environmental constraints, the economic growth model is undergoing significant transformations. New quality productivity is the latest high-tech policy in China’s current development. Comprehensively improving the new quality productivity level of enterprises is the core driving force behind promoting productivity progress and sustainable development. The objective of this study was to employ machine learning techniques to comprehensively assess the level of new quality productivity exhibited by enterprises and to identify the spatiotemporal evolution characteristics thereof. Additionally, the study sought to investigate the impact and the specific mechanism of new quality productivity on the ESG performance of enterprises from a micro perspective. The study revealed that new quality productivity has a considerable impact on the ESG performance of enterprises, particularly in cases where the enterprise has a long history and is engaged in significant pollution. The underlying mechanism is that new quality productivity can enhance an enterprise’s ESG performance by alleviating financing constraints and improving the efficiency of employee innovation. Additionally, further research indicated that new quality productivity primarily influences the environmental and social ratings of enterprises.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qin2024impact,
  author = {Feiwei Qin and Mao Zhang},
  title = {{The Impact of High-Tech Policies on Corporate ESG Performance: Evidence from China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/su162310321},
}
Figure