The Impact of Global Value Chain Embedding on Corporate Risk Taking of China’s A-Share Market-Listed Companies from 2000–2016

Junli Wang, Wendong Lv, Yao Zhao, Na XuSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how Chinese companies' integration into global value chains (GVCs) influences their risk-taking behavior. It finds that GVC embedding generally encourages risk-taking, primarily through increased R&D investment, but this effect is dampened by financial constraints.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As China aims to move its industries up the global value chain, understanding the implications for corporate behavior is crucial. While GVC participation is linked to improved innovation and efficiency, it also exposes companies to various risks. This paper addresses the question of how embedding in GVCs specifically impacts a company's willingness to take risks, a key driver of profit and growth. It seeks to uncover the mechanisms behind this relationship and identify moderating factors, particularly in the context of developing economies like China.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative approach using panel data from Chinese A-share market-listed companies between 2000 and 2016. They utilized multiple regression analysis to test their hypotheses.

  • Measuring GVC Embedding: A novel micro-level measurement of GVC embeddedness was developed by matching CSMAR and China Customs import/export data. This approach, building on existing methods like KWW and WWZ but adapted for firm-level analysis, allows for a more granular understanding of individual company participation.
  • Measuring Risk Taking: Corporate risk-taking was measured using the volatility of adjusted Return on Assets (Adj_Roa), specifically through two metrics: RiskT1 (standard deviation of Adj_Roa) and RiskT2 (range of Adj_Roa).
  • Mediating and Moderating Effects: The study used a three-step method to test the mediating role of R&D investment and a regression model to examine the moderating effect of financing constraints.
  • Endogeneity Test: To address potential reverse causality (i.e., risk-taking influencing GVC embedding), an instrumental variable approach (2SLS) was employed.

Datasets

  • CSMAR Database: Provided financial data for listed companies.
  • China Customs Import and Export Data: Used for calculating GVC embeddedness.
  • China Wonder Database (Wind): Provided R&D expenditure data.

The study focused on a sample of 1102 listed companies from 2000 to 2016, resulting in 5292 valid observations after data cleaning and matching.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • GVCs as a Catalyst for Risk-Taking: The core idea is that by engaging with global markets and supply chains, companies are exposed to new opportunities and competitive pressures that necessitate a higher tolerance for risk. This isn't just about passive participation; it's about actively seeking higher value-added segments.
  • R&D as the Bridge: The study highlights R&D investment as a critical intermediary. Companies embedding themselves in GVCs are incentivized to innovate and improve their offerings, which inherently involves risk. This investment in R&D is what translates GVC participation into increased corporate risk-taking.
  • Financing Constraints as a Bottleneck: The research points out that while GVCs can encourage risk-taking, the ability to do so is significantly constrained by a company's financial health. Companies facing tight financing are less able to invest in R&D and take on riskier projects, even if GVC participation offers the potential for higher returns.
  • Policy Implications for Developing Economies: The findings suggest that governments in developing countries should focus on improving financial markets to reduce financing constraints, thereby enabling companies to better leverage GVC participation for innovation and risk-taking.

Key Results

  • Hypothesis 1 Supported: GVC embedding was found to be significantly positively correlated with corporate risk-taking (RiskT1 and RiskT2). This indicates that as companies integrate more deeply into global value chains, their propensity to take risks increases.
  • Hypothesis 2 Supported: R&D investment was confirmed to play a significant mediating role. GVC embedding positively influences R&D investment, which in turn enhances corporate risk-taking.
  • Hypothesis 3 Supported: Financing constraints were found to negatively moderate the relationship between GVC embedding and corporate risk-taking. Higher financing constraints weaken the positive impact of GVC embedding on risk-taking.
  • Control Variables: Firm age and capital expenditure (Cap) were positively associated with risk-taking, while enterprise growth was negatively associated.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Window: The study's data spans from 2000 to 2016. The authors acknowledge that significant global economic shifts (e.g., trade protectionism, COVID-19) have occurred since then, suggesting future research should incorporate more recent data to capture these evolving dynamics.
  • Focus on Investment: The current research primarily examines the impact of GVC embedding on enterprise investment decisions related to risk-taking. Future work could explore how GVC embedding affects financing decisions, such as capital structure.
  • Internal Governance: The study acknowledges that internal factors like governance structure and manager characteristics also influence risk-taking. Future research could delve into the regulatory effects of these internal factors.
  • Enterprise Heterogeneity: The study focused on Chinese A-share listed companies. Given the significant heterogeneity among enterprises, future research could analyze the participation and risks faced by different types of companies within the GVC.
  • COVID-19 Impact: The authors specifically suggest exploring how the COVID-19 pandemic has affected Chinese enterprises' GVC participation and what measures have been taken to mitigate its economic impact.

Summary updated

Abstract

Moving towards the high end of the global value chain (GVC) is an inevitable trend of the development of Chinese enterprises, and the level of enterprises’ risk-taking behavior is directly related to their profit acquisition in the global value chain. Based on the matching data of CSMAR and the “General Administration of Customs of the People’s Republic of China”, this paper explores how the embedding of the global value chain affects the risk-taking behavior of enterprises. It is found that (1) R&D investment is an important factor for listed companies to enhance their risk taking by embedding in the global value chain; however, financial constraints will negatively affect this factor. (2) The study’s findings also indicated that improving innovation capacity and increasing R&D investment is crucial for enterprises in developing countries to raise their corporate value. Moreover, it is helpful for enterprises to escape the jaws of danger in the GVC wave. It is advised that the government develop a financial market or enhance the external environment to encourage enterprises’ development. This study reveals the specific impact of global value chain embedding on corporate risk-taking behavior, provides new empirical evidence for understanding the micro mechanism of the relationship between global value chain embedding and economic growth, and has great practical significance for promoting Chinese enterprises to the high-end of the global value chain.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2022impact,
  author = {Junli Wang and Wendong Lv and Yao Zhao and Na Xu},
  title = {{The Impact of Global Value Chain Embedding on Corporate Risk Taking of China’s A-Share Market-Listed Companies from 2000–2016}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su142012969},
}
Figure