The Impact of Foreign Direct Investment on Urban Green Total Factor Productivity and the Mechanism Test

Mingliang Zhao, Yue Gao, Qing Liu, Wei SunInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that while foreign direct investment (FDI) in China generally hinders urban green total factor productivity (GTFP), scientific and technological innovation acts as a crucial mediating factor, and industrial structure upgrades can mitigate this negative impact. The study also highlights significant regional disparities in FDI's effect on GTFP, suggesting a need for tailored policy interventions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As China continues to attract substantial foreign direct investment (FDI), a critical question arises: what is the true impact of this investment on the nation's environmental sustainability and economic efficiency? While FDI can bring capital and technology, concerns persist about its potential to exacerbate pollution and hinder the development of a "green economy." Specifically, this paper investigates how FDI affects "green total factor productivity" (GTFP) – a measure of how efficiently cities use resources and minimize environmental damage while producing economic output. The authors aim to untangle the complex mechanisms through which FDI influences GTFP, considering factors like technological innovation and industrial structure, and to understand if these effects vary across different types of cities in China.

Methods

The researchers employed a Slack-Based Model (SBM) directional distance function to measure GTFP. This advanced technique accounts for both desired outputs (economic growth) and undesired outputs (pollution) in its efficiency calculations. To analyze the relationships, they utilized a panel fixed-effects model, which is suitable for analyzing data across multiple entities (cities) over time, controlling for unobserved city-specific and time-specific factors. To test the mediating role of scientific and technological innovation, they employed the Sobel test and bootstrap random sampling. The moderating effect of industrial structure upgrading was examined by including an interaction term between FDI and industrial structure in the regression model.

Datasets

The study utilized panel data from 284 prefecture-level cities in China spanning from 2004 to 2019. The data sources included various official statistical yearbooks, such as the China Environmental Statistical Yearbook, China Industrial Statistical Yearbook, China Science and Technology Statistical Yearbook, and China Energy Statistical Yearbook. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing data was compiled and analyzed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Pollution Haven" Hypothesis Holds (Mostly): The study provides evidence supporting the "pollution haven" hypothesis, suggesting that FDI, on average, negatively impacts urban GTFP. This is a significant finding, as it challenges the notion that FDI is always a net positive for environmental sustainability.
  • Technology Progress is the Bottleneck: The primary driver of FDI's negative impact on GTFP is its detrimental effect on green technology progress. This implies that FDI might be hindering the adoption and development of truly innovative, clean technologies.
  • Innovation as a Double-Edged Sword: While FDI can sometimes lead to technology spillovers, the study found that scientific and technological innovation acts as a crucial mediating factor. It can partially offset the negative effects of FDI, suggesting that fostering domestic innovation is key to harnessing FDI's benefits.
  • Industrial Structure Matters: The upgrading of industrial structure plays a positive moderating role. This means that as industries become more sophisticated and less reliant on heavy, polluting sectors, the negative impact of FDI on GTFP is lessened.
  • Regional Disparities are Pronounced: The impact of FDI is not uniform across China. Resource-based cities, non-coastal cities, and cities along the China-Europe Railway Express routes experience a more pronounced negative effect from FDI on their GTFP. This highlights the need for differentiated policy approaches.

Key Results

  • Overall FDI Impact: A 1% increase in FDI is associated with a 0.77% decrease in urban GTFP (based on the benchmark regression in Table 4, column 1).
  • Mechanism of Impact: FDI's negative impact is primarily driven by a hindrance to green technology progress (Table 5).
  • Mediating Effect of Innovation: Scientific and technological innovation significantly mediates the relationship between FDI and GTFP, showing a positive influence (Table 7).
  • Moderating Effect of Industrial Structure: The interaction term between FDI and industrial structure upgrading has a positive and significant effect on GTFP, indicating that industrial upgrading can mitigate FDI's negative impact (Table 8).
  • Heterogeneous Impacts:
    • Resource-based cities experience a stronger inhibitory effect from FDI compared to non-resource-based cities.
  • Non-coastal cities are more negatively affected than coastal cities.
  • Cities along the China-Europe Railway Express routes show a greater negative impact from FDI than non-opening cities.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study primarily uses data from eastern and central China. They suggest that future research should incorporate data from western China to obtain more universal conclusions. Additionally, while the study explores the impact of FDI, it also notes the importance of considering environmental regulation and resource endowment as significant factors influencing GTFP. The paper also implicitly suggests that further investigation into the specific types of FDI and their associated technologies would be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper employs the slack-based model directional distance function to measure the green total factor productivity of each city, using the panel data of 284 prefecture-level cities in China from 2004 to 2019 and considering the unexpected output. The results are as follows: ① Foreign direct investment significantly suppresses the improvement of urban green total factor productivity, and the negative impact on the green technology progress index is the main reason to inhibit the increase of the green total factor productivity. The results are still significant through a series of robustness tests such as replacing variables and eliminating outliers; the positive intermediary effect of scientific and technological innovation exists, and the Sobel test and bootstrap random sampling test are passed. The upgrading of industrial structure has a positive regulating effect on the improvement of urban green total factor productivity. ② The impact of foreign direct investment on urban green total factor productivity has regional heterogeneity. The inhibitory effect of foreign direct investment on resource-based cities and non-coastal cities is greater than that on non-resource-based cities and coastal cities, and the negative impact on China-Europe train opening cities is greater than that on non-opening cities. Accordingly, the paper puts forward policy suggestions from the aspects of improving the quality of foreign direct investment and implementing differentiated management.
BibTeX
@article{zhao2022impact,
  author = {Mingliang Zhao and Yue Gao and Qing Liu and Wei Sun},
  title = {{The Impact of Foreign Direct Investment on Urban Green Total Factor Productivity and the Mechanism Test}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph191912183},
}
Figure