The impact of expected child-rearing expenses on childbirth based on the matching of two Korean panel data

Eunseol Kim, Seong Hyeok Moon, Jeong Rim Lee, Yoon Kyung Choi, Namhee Do, Dongha LeeInternational Journal of Child Care and Education policy/International Journal of Child Care and Education 2017 · DOI

Abstract

In Korea, recent upward trends in age of marriage and downward trends in fertility rates have motivated the Korean government to provide childbirth grants and Early Childhood Education and Care (ECEC) subsidies. Through such provisions, the government hopes to lower parents’ concerns regarding child-rearing expenses and to promote higher birth rates. Using combined data from the Panel Study of Korean Children (PSKC) and the Korea Longitudinal Study of Women and Families (KLoWF), this study analyzes the relationship between birth rates and anticipated child-rearing expenses. The method of kernel matching was used to combine and analyze information on children from the KLoWF and the child care environment as well as on child-rearing expenses from the PSKC. The study’s findings suggest a significant but weak relationship between birth rates and the anticipated financial costs for raising a child. This relationship is more prominent in the low-education and low-income group than in economically well-situated and highly educated families. Based on the results, we suggest the following policy recommendations: firstly, further research needs to be conducted to determine the effects of governmental support on child-rearing. Secondly, customized support that considers family income and education should be provided to improve birth rates.

Introduction: The Demographic Crisis in South Korea

South Korea is currently grappling with a severe demographic crisis, characterized by one of the lowest total fertility rates in the world. As shown in Figure 1, the fertility rate has plummeted from over 4.5 in 1970 to approximately 1.2 by 2014. This downward trend, coupled with an increasing average age of marriage, has prompted the Korean government to implement various financial incentives, such as Early Childhood Education and Care (ECEC) subsidies and childbirth grants. The primary goal of these policies is to alleviate the financial burden of child-rearing and encourage families to have more children.

Fig. 1 Total fertility rate trends in Korea (1970–2014).

Addressing the Data Gap

Despite these efforts, measuring the actual effectiveness of financial subsidies is challenging due to a significant "data gap" in existing research. Researchers often face two types of datasets:

  1. Cost-focused datasets: These provide detailed information on child-rearing expenses but typically only include families who already have children.
  2. Behavioral datasets: These track the decision-making processes and socio-economic status of women of childbearing age but often lack specific financial data regarding anticipated costs.

Because prospective parents make decisions based on anticipated future costs rather than current ones, it is difficult to analyze how specific price signals—such as a ₩100,000 subsidy—actually impact the probability of a woman choosing to have a child.

Methodology: Bridging Datasets with Kernel Matching

To overcome this data gap, this study employs a statistical technique called Kernel Matching to combine two major Korean panel surveys: the Panel Study of Korean Children (PSKC) and the Korea Longitudinal Study of Women and Families (KLoWF).

The PSKC provides granular data on child-rearing environments and direct expenses (e.g., childcare center fees) for 2,150 households. The KLoWF tracks the childbirth trajectories and socio-economic status of over 9,000 women. By treating women in the KLoWF as the primary subjects, the researchers "imputed" expected costs by finding their "statistical twins" in the PSKC.

The matching process utilized the Mahalanobis distance to measure socio-demographic similarity based on variables such as age, education, marriage status, and household assets. An Epanechnikov kernel was then used to calculate weighted averages of costs from the PSKC to estimate the "expected cost" for each woman in the KLoWF. Finally, a logit regression was performed to determine how these imputed expected costs influenced actual childbirth history over a five-year period.

Key Findings: The "Drop in the Bucket" Effect

The study reveals that while anticipated child-rearing expenses do discourage childbirth, the relationship is statistically significant but weak. A primary takeaway is the "Drop in the Bucket" effect: a ₩100,000 (approximately $75–$80 USD) monthly subsidy is largely insufficient to alter childbirth decisions.

This lack of impact stems from the fact that direct childcare costs represent only a small fraction of the total cost of raising a child to adulthood in Korea. Parents must also consider long-term expenses such as private tutoring (hagwons), housing, and higher education. Consequently, a small monthly subsidy does little to offset the massive lifetime financial commitment of parenthood.

Socio-Economic Disparities and the Quantity-Quality Tradeoff

The negative impact of child-rearing costs is significantly more pronounced in low-income and low-education groups. For women who did not attend university, an increase of ₩100,000 in monthly child-rearing costs decreased the probability of childbirth by 0.6%. In contrast, for highly educated and high-income families, the direct cost of childcare had almost no statistical impact on the decision to have a child.

This disparity can be explained by the "Quantity–Quality Tradeoff" model. In Korea, many families choose to have fewer children not necessarily because they cannot afford them, but because they prefer to concentrate their financial resources on maximizing the "quality" (education and future life outcomes) of a single child. Furthermore, for highly educated women, the "hidden" opportunity costs—such as lost wages and career disruption—likely outweigh the direct financial costs of childcare.

Conclusion and Policy Implications

The findings suggest that current government subsidies may be too small to significantly change behavior, particularly for middle- and high-income families. Based on these results, the study offers two major policy recommendations:

  1. Multifaceted Support: Future research and policy should move beyond simple cash subsidies. The government should investigate social infrastructure improvements, such as shorter working hours and enhanced job security, to create a more "parent-friendly" environment.
  2. Customized Assistance: Support should be tailored to family income and education levels. Low-income families may benefit more from direct financial aid, while high-income families may require policies that address opportunity costs and the competitive education landscape.

Ultimately, addressing Korea's demographic crisis requires a comprehensive approach that considers both the direct and indirect costs of raising children in a highly competitive society.

Summary updated

Abstract

In Korea, recent upward trends in age of marriage and downward trends in fertility rates have motivated the Korean government to provide childbirth grants and Early Childhood Education and Care (ECEC) subsidies. Through such provisions, the government hopes to lower parents’ concerns regarding child-rearing expenses and to promote higher birth rates. Using combined data from the Panel Study of Korean Children (PSKC) and the Korea Longitudinal Study of Women and Families (KLoWF), this study analyzes the relationship between birth rates and anticipated child-rearing expenses. The method of kernel matching was used to combine and analyze information on children from the KLoWF and the child care environment as well as on child-rearing expenses from the PSKC. The study’s findings suggest a significant but weak relationship between birth rates and the anticipated financial costs for raising a child. This relationship is more prominent in the low-education and low-income group than in economically well-situated and highly educated families. Based on the results, we suggest the following policy recommendations: firstly, further research needs to be conducted to determine the effects of governmental support on child-rearing. Secondly, customized support that considers family income and education should be provided to improve birth rates.
BibTeX
@article{kim2017impact,
  author = {Eunseol Kim and Seong Hyeok Moon and Jeong Rim Lee and Yoon Kyung Choi and Namhee Do and Dongha Lee},
  title = {{The impact of expected child-rearing expenses on childbirth based on the matching of two Korean panel data}},
  journal = {International Journal of Child Care and Education policy/International Journal of Child Care and Education},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1186/s40723-017-0029-7},
}
Figure