The Impact of Eclipsing GNSS Satellites on the Precise Point Positioning

Xinyun Cao, Shoujian Zhang, Kaifa Kuang, Tianjun Liu, Kang GaoRemote 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how GNSS satellite eclipses, which cause deviations from nominal attitudes, impact the accuracy of Precise Point Positioning (PPP). They found that using modeled attitudes significantly improves GLONASS and BDS PPP accuracy, while deleting eclipsing satellites can sometimes degrade performance due to poor satellite geometry.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Precise Point Positioning (PPP) relies on accurate satellite attitude information for high-precision positioning. However, GNSS satellites experience "eclipses" when they enter Earth's shadow or undergo maneuvers, causing their attitudes to deviate from their standard, nominal orientations. These non-nominal attitudes can introduce errors, particularly through the "wind-up effect" and "Phase Center Offset" (PCO) corrections, which degrade PPP accuracy. Different satellite generations have varying attitude control models, making it crucial to understand how these deviations affect modern multi-GNSS PPP. This paper aims to quantify this impact and evaluate different strategies for handling eclipsing satellites.

Methods

The researchers analyzed three strategies for dealing with eclipsing satellites:

  1. Strategy 1 (S1): Delete data from eclipsing satellites.
  2. Strategy 2 (S2): Use the nominal attitude model, even during eclipses.
  3. Strategy 3 (S3): Use a modeled attitude that accounts for non-nominal behavior during eclipses.

They developed and applied models to determine when satellites enter eclipsing regimes and calculated their non-nominal yaw angles. The study then compared the positioning accuracy, observation residuals, and convergence times of these three strategies for single-system (GPS, GLONASS, Galileo, BDS) and multi-GNSS (GR, GREC) PPP in both static and kinematic modes.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 65 globally distributed MGEX (Multi-GNSS Experiment) stations collected over a 31-day period in July 2017. These stations were chosen because they could track signals from GPS, GLONASS, Galileo, and BDS. The reference coordinates for these stations were obtained from IGS SINEX weekly solutions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Attitude Matters: Non-nominal satellite attitudes during eclipses are not just a minor inconvenience; they directly impact PPP accuracy, especially for systems with larger PCO values.
  • System-Specific Impacts: The effect of eclipses is not uniform across all GNSS. GLONASS and BDS are more sensitive due to their larger PCO values and specific attitude control behaviors (e.g., longer shadow crossing durations for GLONASS, attitude switches for BDS).
  • Deleting Isn't Always Best: Simply removing data from eclipsing satellites (S1) can sometimes lead to worse solutions and longer convergence times, particularly for kinematic PPP, due to reduced satellite geometry (PDOP).
  • Modeled Attitudes are Key: Using modeled attitudes (S3) generally provides the most significant improvements in accuracy for systems like GLONASS and BDS, outperforming both nominal attitudes (S2) and simply deleting data (S1).
  • Multi-GNSS Buffers Effects: As more GNSS systems are combined, the impact of individual eclipsing satellites diminishes due to improved satellite geometry and redundancy.

Key Results

  • GLONASS/BDS Improvement: For single-system static and kinematic PPP, using modeled attitudes (S3) significantly improved accuracy for GLONASS (up to ~12% in static, ~11% in kinematic) and BDS (up to ~35% in static, ~54% in kinematic) compared to using nominal attitudes (S2). Deleting satellites (S1) also showed improvements but was often less effective than S3.
  • GPS/Galileo Minor Impact: GPS and Galileo PPP accuracy saw only slight improvements with S1 and S3 compared to S2. This is attributed to smaller PCO values for GPS and the limited number of Galileo satellites.
  • Kinematic PPP Challenges: For kinematic PPP, especially with GLONASS and BDS, deleting eclipsing satellites could lead to worse solutions or longer convergence times due to degraded satellite geometry.
  • Multi-GNSS Robustness: When combining four GNSS systems (GREC), the accuracy improvements from using modeled attitudes or deleting eclipsing satellites became non-significant, highlighting the robustness gained from multi-GNSS.
  • Convergence Time: While deleting satellites could sometimes increase convergence time, using modeled attitudes generally maintained or slightly improved convergence times, especially in multi-GNSS scenarios.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Galileo FOC Attitude Model: The study notes that the official attitude control model for Galileo FOC satellites was released later than the experimental period. Using nominal or IOV satellite attitudes for FOC might have limited the potential improvements for Galileo-only PPP. Future work could re-evaluate this with updated models.
  • BDS Satellite Geometry: The paper points out that the poor satellite geometry of GLONASS and BDS kinematic PPP, especially at lower latitudes, can make deleting eclipsing satellites detrimental. This suggests a need for careful consideration of satellite geometry when implementing these strategies.
  • Consistency of Models: The authors suggest that further improvements in single-system PPP accuracy could be achieved if modeled attitudes are more consistently aligned with actual satellite control models, particularly for Galileo FOC. This would also benefit multi-GNSS PPP.

Summary updated

Abstract

When satellites enter into the noon maneuver or the shadow crossing regimes, the actual attitudes will depart from their nominal values. If improper attitude models are used, the induced-errors due to the wind-up effect and satellite antenna PCO (Phase Center Offset) will deteriorate the positioning accuracy. Because different generations of satellites adopt different attitude control models, the influences on the positioning performances deserve further study. Consequently, the impact of three eclipsing strategies on the single-system and multi-GNSS (Global Navigation Satellite System) Precise Point Positioning (PPP) are analyzed. According to the results of the eclipsing monitor, 65 globally distributed MGEX (Multi-GNSS EXperiment) stations for 31-day period in July 2017 are selected to perform G/R/E/C/GR/GREC PPP in both static and kinematic modes. The results show that the influences of non-nominal attitudes are related to the magnitude of the PCO values, maximum yaw angle differences, the duration of maneuver, the value of the sun angle and the satellite geometric strength. For single-system, using modeled attitudes rather than the nominal ones will greatly improve the positioning accuracy of GLONASS-only and BDS-only PPP while slightly contributions to the GPS-only and GALILEO-only PPP. Deleting the eclipsing satellites may sometimes induce a longer convergence time and a worse solution due to the poor satellite geometry, especially for GLONASS kinematic PPP when stations are located in the low latitude and BDS kinematic PPP. When multi-GNSS data are available, especially four navigation systems, the accuracy improvements of using the modeled attitudes or deleting eclipsing satellites are non-significant.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cao2018impact,
  author = {Xinyun Cao and Shoujian Zhang and Kaifa Kuang and Tianjun Liu and Kang Gao},
  title = {{The Impact of Eclipsing GNSS Satellites on the Precise Point Positioning}},
  booktitle = {Remote},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/rs10010094},
}
Figure