The Impact of Diversified Income and Agricultural Tax Reform on the Consumption of Chinese Rural Residents

Fangyuan Zhou, Xiao Luo, Kandorera Angela NujomaJournal of Economics and Public Finance 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Income from different sources has become an important guarantee to sustain family life and normal expenses in China. This study utilizes panel data from 2016 to 2020 to examine rural residents’ consumption expenditures and their sources of disposable income. By analyzing the impact of different income sources and the correlation between income before and after agricultural tax reform, the research identifies varying elasticities across income types. Wage income is found to be the most elastic driver of consumption, while household business income shows a smaller effect. Furthermore, the study highlights a significant lag in the promotion effect of agricultural tax reform on consumption, suggesting a long transmission chain from tax reduction to realized spending.

Introduction

For decades, the economic landscape of rural China was characterized by subsistence farming and a heavy agricultural tax burden. The abolition of the agricultural tax in 2006 marked a pivotal shift, saving farmers approximately 125 billion yuan annually. Concurrently, rural income streams have diversified beyond traditional farming into wages, business ventures, and government transfers. This paper explores how these diverse income sources influence consumption patterns and investigates the enduring "lagged" impact of the historic tax reform on rural prosperity.

Methodology

The study employs a multi-faceted econometric approach using the R programming language to analyze panel and time-series data. The researchers utilized Multiple Linear Regression (OLS) to calculate the elasticity of consumption relative to different income types, alongside ARIMA and GARCH models to handle linear trends and volatility in historical data, particularly for agricultural business income.

Model Validation

To ensure the reliability of the regression results, the study performed extensive diagnostic testing. Figure 2 presents the residual distribution, which closely approximates normality, a key assumption for OLS regression.

Residual Diagnostics: Histogram and Normal Q-Q Plot

Furthermore, influence diagnostics were conducted to identify potential outliers. As shown in Figure 5, the Cook’s Distance and Hatvalues indicate that the model is robust and not unduly influenced by specific data points.

Influence Diagnostics: Cook’s Distance and Hatvalues

Data Sources

The analysis draws from the China Statistical Yearbook (1990–2021), focusing on two levels:

  • National Panel Data (2016–2020): Aggregated data across all provinces to capture broad regional trends.
  • Regional Time Series Data (1990–2020): A focused study of Heilongjiang Province, serving as a representative case for large-scale agricultural regions to track long-term policy effects.

Key Insights: The Hierarchy of Income and Mental Accounting

The research identifies a clear hierarchy in how rural residents perceive and spend different types of income, a phenomenon explained by "mental accounting" theory.

  • Wage Dominance: Wage income exhibits the highest elasticity. Because it is perceived as stable and predictable, it directly fuels higher consumption levels.
  • Business Caution: Income from agricultural business (farming and husbandry) has the lowest elasticity. Farmers treat this income with caution due to its susceptibility to weather and market volatility, leading to higher savings rates for this specific stream.
  • Transfer Income: Government subsidies and transfers act as a critical safety net, providing the financial security necessary for residents to maintain steady consumption levels.

Results and the Lagged Effect of Tax Reform

The regression analysis established the following relationship for rural consumption ($Con$): $$\ln(Con_i) = 2.6060 + 0.1661 \ln(Agrincome_i) + 0.3529 \ln(Salary_i) + 0.2923 \ln(Trans_i)$$

The results indicate that a 1% increase in wage income leads to a 0.35% increase in consumption, whereas a 1% increase in business income yields only a 0.16% increase.

Crucially, the study finds that the benefits of agricultural tax reform are not instantaneous. There is a "transmission chain": tax reduction leads to expanded reproduction (investment in seeds/machinery), which eventually leads to higher harvests, sales, and finally, consumption. The data suggests that income from three years prior still significantly impacts current consumption, highlighting a multi-year lag in policy effectiveness.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the abolition of agricultural taxes and the diversification of income have significantly boosted rural consumption, the study notes several areas for future research. The use of annual data limits the ability to observe seasonal fluctuations; future work should incorporate monthly or quarterly datasets. Additionally, expanding the time-series analysis to other provinces beyond Heilongjiang would provide a more comprehensive national picture of the evolving rural economy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Income from different sources has become an important guarantee to sustain family life and normal expenses in China. How different sources of income affect farmers’ expenditure levels and how they have influenced farmers’ consumption since the agricultural tax reform in China since the 20th century has become a question worth exploring. Panel data from 2016 to 2020 are utilized to examine rural residents’ consumption expenditures and their sources of disposable income by region to analyze the impact of different income sources on farmers’ consumption and the correlation between income before and after agricultural tax reform, and finally conducts an analysis of future scenarios based on a time series model. The research results show that the elasticity of income from different sources on rural households’ per capita consumption expenditure is different, among which wage income is the most elastic, while household business income has a relatively small effect on consumption expenditure, but through data analysis we can find that agricultural tax reform has a significant and continuous promotion effect on rural households’ per capita consumption expenditure. The continuous cycle of agricultural tax reform is long, and the transmission chain through less tax payment, expanded reproduction, harvest, realization, and then consumption is long, thus there is a certain lag in tax reduction effect. Income from such sources in the first three years has a large impact on the current period data, while the first four and five years have a relatively small impact on current business income.
BibTeX
@article{zhou2022impact,
  author = {Fangyuan Zhou and Xiao Luo and Kandorera Angela Nujoma},
  title = {{The Impact of Diversified Income and Agricultural Tax Reform on the Consumption of Chinese Rural Residents}},
  journal = {Journal of Economics and Public Finance},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.22158/jepf.v8n4p75},
}
Figure