The impact of 3 different dietary interventions on overweight or obese adults: A network meta-analysis

T. Vivian Liao, Jiayu Su, Tingwei Quan, Yu Luo, Yiqian Zeng, Dandan Chen, Hongzhen TangMedicine 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This network meta-analysis systematically compares the effectiveness of ketogenic, low-fat, low-calorie, and Mediterranean diets for weight management in overweight and obese adults. The ketogenic diet emerged as the most effective intervention for reducing body weight, BMI, and waist circumference, though further high-quality trials are needed to confirm these findings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Obesity is a growing global health crisis, linked to numerous chronic diseases and impacting quality of life. While dietary interventions are a cornerstone of obesity management, the comparative effectiveness of different popular dietary patterns remains unclear. This study aims to provide a quantitative comparison of three prominent diets – ketogenic, low-fat, and Mediterranean – against a traditional low-calorie diet, to help guide clinical recommendations and individual choices.

Methods

The researchers conducted a systematic review and network meta-analysis. They searched multiple Chinese and English databases for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) up to January 31, 2024. Two independent reviewers screened studies, extracted data, and assessed the risk of bias using the Cochrane Collaboration's tool. A random-effects network meta-analysis was performed using Review Manager 5.4.1 and Stata 16.0 software. This approach allows for indirect comparisons between interventions that may not have been directly compared in individual studies, providing a more comprehensive overview. The Surface Under the Cumulative Ranking Curve (SUCRA) was used to rank the effectiveness of each diet.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on analyzing existing published randomized controlled trials.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ketogenic Diet Dominance: The ketogenic diet consistently ranked highest across all measured outcomes (body weight, BMI, and waist circumference), suggesting it's a powerful tool for weight loss in this population.
  • Network Meta-Analysis Power: By employing a network meta-analysis, the study could compare diets even if they weren't directly pitted against each other in every trial, offering a broader perspective than traditional pairwise meta-analyses.
  • Hierarchy of Effectiveness: The study identified a clear hierarchy of effectiveness, with the ketogenic diet leading, followed by low-fat and low-calorie diets, and the Mediterranean diet appearing least effective among the evaluated options.
  • Need for Nuance: While the ketogenic diet shows superior results, the authors acknowledge the need for careful consideration of its long-term sustainability and safety, hinting that adherence is a critical factor.

Key Results

The network meta-analysis included 17 RCTs involving 5802 subjects. The findings indicated a descending order of effectiveness for reducing body weight, BMI, and waist circumference:

  • Ketogenic diet > Low-fat diet > Low-calorie diet > Mediterranean diet

Specifically, the ketogenic diet demonstrated the highest probability of being the most effective intervention for all three outcomes. For example, in terms of body weight, the ketogenic diet ranked highest at 99.8% probability.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Modest Volume and Dated Literature: The available literature was not extensive, and some studies were older, potentially impacting the statistical robustness and generalizability of the findings.
  • Inconsistent Control Measures: The control groups in the included studies were not always consistently stringent.
  • Short-term vs. Long-term: The analysis did not differentiate between short-term and long-term studies, which could introduce variability.
  • Methodological Quality: The overall methodological quality of the studies was moderate, posing a potential risk of bias.
  • Database Limitations: The search was limited to 4 Chinese and 4 English databases, which might have led to incomplete data collection.
  • Local Inconsistency: Local inconsistency was detected in some comparisons, and the absence of subgroup analysis may limit interpretability.
  • Geographic Diversity: Variations in environmental and dietary factors across different study locations (Greece, USA, Australia, etc.) could influence outcomes.

The authors strongly recommend additional high-quality randomized controlled trials to validate these findings and provide more robust evidence, particularly concerning the long-term sustainability and safety of the ketogenic diet.

Summary updated

Abstract

The ketogenic diet was identified as the most effective intervention for reducing BW, BMI, and WC in the studied dietary comparisons. It consistently showed superior outcomes, ranking highest in effectiveness among the 4 evaluated dietary approaches. Nevertheless, additional high-quality randomized controlled trials are necessary to validate these findings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liao2024impact,
  author = {T. Vivian Liao and Jiayu Su and Tingwei Quan and Yu Luo and Yiqian Zeng and Dandan Chen and Hongzhen Tang},
  title = {{The impact of 3 different dietary interventions on overweight or obese adults: A network meta-analysis}},
  booktitle = {Medicine},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1097/md.0000000000039749},
}
Figure