The Illuminati Problem, Rules of Recognition, and What Distinguishes Law from Non-Law?
Lists
Only you see this
Abstract
How to distinguish law from non-legal but systematic and rule-guided practices of legal officials? This issue features prominently in the debate on ‘positive originalism’ in US constitutional law, and in similar fundamental controversies in other legal orders. I take it as a question about content and constitution of ultimate rules of recognition. Legal philosophers have been too quick in dealing with this problem. I argue that there is more space to claim that non officials have a constitutive relationship with the content of the law, thus potentially providing a standard to distinguish legal and non-legal practices of officials. However, to the extent officials play a constitutive role in the law, what matters is their genuine acceptance of ultimate rules of recognition. To show this, I develop the concept of acceptance of a social rule by specifying the requirement of genuineness of acceptance and the role of mental dispositions associated with acceptance.
BibTeX
@misc{barczentewicz2018illuminati,
author = {Mikołaj Barczentewicz},
title = {{The Illuminati Problem, Rules of Recognition, and What Distinguishes Law from Non-Law?}},
year = {2018},
howpublished = {Ssrn},
}Loading related content...