The IceCube Pie Chart: Relative Source Contributions to the Cosmic Neutrino Flux

I. Bartos, Doğa Veske, Marek Daniel Kowalski, Z. Márka, Szabolcs MárkaarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Neutrino events from IceCube have recently been associated with multiple astrophysical sources. Interestingly, these likely detections represent three distinct astrophysical source types: active galactic nuclei (AGN), blazars, and tidal disruption events (TDE). Here we compute the expected contributions of AGNs, blazars and TDEs to the overall cosmic neutrino flux detected by IceCube based on the associated events, IceCube's sensitivity, and the source types' astrophysical properties. We find that, despite being the most commonly identified sources, blazars cannot contribute more than 11% of the total flux (90% credible level), consistent with existing limits from stacked searches. On the other hand, we find that either AGNs or TDEs could contribute more than 50% of the total flux (90% credible level), although stacked searches further limit the TDE contribution to $\lesssim 30\%$. We also find that so-far unknown source types contribute at least 10% of the total cosmic flux with a probability of 80%. We assemble a pie chart that shows the most likely fractional contribution of each source type to IceCube's total neutrino flux.

Introduction

Since the 2013 discovery of a diffuse flux of high-energy cosmic neutrinos by the IceCube Neutrino Observatory, identifying the specific astrophysical objects responsible for these particles has been a primary goal of high-energy astrophysics. While several "smoking gun" associations have been made—including the blazar TXS 0506+056, the Seyfert galaxy NGC 1068 (an AGN), and the tidal disruption event (TDE) AT2019dsg—these individual detections do not immediately reveal the global composition of the neutrino sky. The central challenge is the "completeness" of astronomical catalogs: rare, bright sources are easily spotted but may not dominate the total flux, while common, dim populations could be the primary drivers despite fewer individual detections.

Methodology and Data

To address this, we developed a statistical framework to translate heterogeneous detections into a comprehensive neutrino budget. Our approach utilizes a full Bayesian model that incorporates source evolution (redshift), detector sensitivity, and association uncertainty. The study draws on several key observational datasets, including IceCube high-energy neutrino alerts, the 10-year point-source catalog, and electromagnetic surveys such as the Spitzer mid-infrared AGN survey and various radio/gamma-ray catalogs for TDE rates. The model assumes a neutrino power-law spectrum of $E^{-2.5}$ and ensures that the sum of all estimated contributions remains consistent with the total measured IceCube flux.

The Cosmic Neutrino Budget

Our analysis reveals a diverse landscape of neutrino origins. The resulting "pie chart" of the universe (Figure 1) quantifies the most likely fractional contributions from known and unknown source classes.

The IceCube Pie Chart showing the relative contributions of different astrophysical source classes to the total cosmic neutrino flux.

The model identifies AGNs as the leading contributor at approximately 36%, followed closely by TDEs at 29%. Notably, a significant portion of the flux (28%) is attributed to "Other" or unknown source types—populations that have yet to be associated with a single detected neutrino. These results are further refined by independent "stacking" searches, which constrain the TDE contribution to $\lesssim 30\%$.

Insights into Source Populations

One of the most striking results is the relatively small contribution of blazars. Despite being the most frequently identified point sources in neutrino astronomy, they contribute only about 6% (and no more than 11% at a 90% credible level) of the total flux. This "Blazar Paradox" arises because, while individual blazars can be extremely luminous, the population as a whole is less numerous than non-jetted AGNs or TDEs.

Probability density functions (PDFs) for the flux contributions of different source types, illustrating the distribution of total flux across populations.

As shown in Figure 2, the flux probability distributions for AGNs and TDEs peak at higher values than for blazars. This suggests that the neutrino sky is dominated by more numerous, moderately luminous objects rather than a few exceptionally bright jetted sources.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This work provides the first data-driven estimate of the relative contributions to the cosmic neutrino flux. The findings emphasize that the "loudest" sources are not necessarily the most important contributors to the total energy budget. The significant "Other" category highlights the vast discovery space remaining for future observatories. Next-generation facilities like IceCube-Gen2 and KM3NeT will be essential for refining these slices and identifying the unknown populations currently hiding in the diffuse flux.

Summary updated

Abstract

Neutrino events from IceCube have recently been associated with multiple astrophysical sources. Interestingly, these likely detections represent three distinct astrophysical source types: active galactic nuclei (AGN), blazars, and tidal disruption events (TDE). Here we compute the expected contributions of AGNs, blazars and TDEs to the overall cosmic neutrino flux detected by IceCube based on the associated events, IceCube's sensitivity, and the source types' astrophysical properties. We find that, despite being the most commonly identified sources, blazars cannot contribute more than 11% of the total flux (90% credible level), consistent with existing limits from stacked searches. On the other hand, we find that either AGNs or TDEs could contribute more than 50% of the total flux (90% credible level), although stacked searches further limit the TDE contribution to $\lesssim 30%$. We also find that so-far unknown source types contribute at least 10% of the total cosmic flux with a probability of 80%. We assemble a pie chart that shows the most likely fractional contribution of each source type to IceCube's total neutrino flux.
BibTeX
@misc{bartos2021icecube,
  author = {I. Bartos and Doğa Veske and Marek Daniel Kowalski and Z. Márka and Szabolcs Márka},
  title = {{The IceCube Pie Chart: Relative Source Contributions to the Cosmic Neutrino Flux}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2105.03792},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2105.03792},
}
Figure