TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel hybrid approach, combining Interpretive Structural Modeling (ISM) and Fuzzy Decision-Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory (FDEMATEL), to analyze the complex interdependencies of 18 key indicators for selecting optimal locations for hydrogen refueling stations (HRSs). The study reveals that policy-related factors are the most influential drivers, while economic indicators, though highly influenced by others, are critical for practical implementation.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The global transition to a hydrogen economy hinges on the development of robust hydrogen energy infrastructure, particularly hydrogen refueling stations (HRSs). However, selecting optimal locations for these stations is a complex challenge. Existing research often overlooks the intricate relationships and varying degrees of influence among the numerous factors involved, leading to a "difficult location" phenomenon. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a comprehensive framework to understand and visualize these interdependencies, enabling more informed and effective HRS location decisions.
Methods
The authors employ a four-stage mixed research approach:
- Indicator Identification: A thorough literature review identified 18 key indicators across four dimensions: policy, economy, society, and environment.
- Semi-structured Interviews: Experts in the field were interviewed to gain initial insights into the relationships between these indicators.
- Interpretive Structural Modeling (ISM): This technique was used to analyze the hierarchical relationships between indicators, creating a structured model of their interdependencies.
- Fuzzy Decision-Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory (FDEMATEL): This method, adapted with fuzzy logic to handle ambiguity, was used to quantify the direct and indirect influences between indicators, ultimately constructing a cause-effect relationship digraph.
The combination of ISM and FDEMATEL is the core methodological innovation, allowing for both structural understanding and quantitative analysis of complex indicator relationships.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on expert opinions gathered through semi-structured interviews for data collection.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Policy Reigns Supreme: Government policy requirements, industry regulations, and regional development plans (policy dimension indicators) are identified as the most significant drivers influencing HRS location selection. This highlights the critical role of governmental support and strategic planning.
- Economic Indicators: A Double-Edged Sword: While economic factors like construction scale, cost, and operation/maintenance costs are crucial for practical implementation, they are also highly susceptible to influence from other dimensions. This suggests a need for careful cost-benefit analysis that accounts for policy and social factors.
- Interconnectedness is Key: The study emphasizes that HRS location selection is not a simple aggregation of independent factors. Instead, it's a complex system where indicators influence each other in intricate ways, forming a multi-level hierarchy.
- Visualizing Complexity: The ISM-FDEMATEL approach effectively visualizes these complex relationships, moving beyond simple lists of criteria to a dynamic understanding of how different factors interact.
Key Results
The study established a 7-level hierarchical structure for the 18 identified indicators. The analysis revealed:
- Top Influencers: Indicators S1 (Government policy requirement), S2 (Industry regulatory system), S3 (Regional development plan), and S14 (Climatic conditions) were identified as critical "cause indicators" with strong influence power.
- Key Economic Factors: S4 (Construction scale), S5 (Construction cost), and S6 (Operation and maintenance cost) are foundational economic indicators, appearing at lower levels of the hierarchy but significantly impacting siting effectiveness.
- Cause-Effect Dynamics: The FDEMATEL analysis showed that policy indicators (S1, S3) have strong causality and centrality, indicating their dominant role. Economic indicators (S4, S5) have low influence but high influenced degrees, meaning they are heavily impacted by other factors.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Subjectivity of Expert Opinions: The reliance on expert judgment introduces a degree of subjectivity into the analysis. Future research could employ structural equation modeling to validate these findings.
- Static Analysis: The current model provides a static snapshot of indicator relationships. A dynamic approach is needed to study how these influences evolve over time, especially as the hydrogen infrastructure matures.
- Early-Stage Focus: The analysis is based on the current, relatively low coverage of hydrogen infrastructure. Further dynamic analysis considering the time factor is recommended.
Future work could focus on developing dynamic models, incorporating more diverse data sources, and exploring the long-term impacts of different indicators on HRS location decisions.
Summary updated