TL;DR
This paper investigates how the expansion of China's high-speed rail (HSR) network impacts audit fees for listed companies. The study finds that HSR significantly reduces audit fees, particularly in less developed cities and for smaller audit firms, by increasing competition within the audit market. Importantly, this increased competition does not lead to a decline in audit quality.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The authors tackle the question of how major infrastructure projects, specifically the development of high-speed rail (HSR) in China, influence the business operations and costs of companies, with a particular focus on the auditing industry. While HSR is known to affect economic activity by reducing travel time and facilitating the flow of resources and information, its specific impact on audit fees and the underlying mechanisms remain underexplored. The paper aims to fill this gap by examining whether HSR's ability to connect regions and improve communication affects the cost of audits, and if so, through what channels (e.g., market competition, information asymmetry).
Methods
The core of the study employs a staggered difference-in-differences (DID) model. This econometric approach is well-suited for analyzing the impact of an event (HSR opening) that occurs at different times across various locations. By comparing audit fees in cities before and after HSR implementation, and contrasting them with control cities that did not receive HSR, the researchers can isolate the effect of the HSR opening. The "staggered" aspect acknowledges that HSR lines were rolled out incrementally across China.
To understand the mechanisms behind the observed effects, the authors conduct further analyses:
- Regional Heterogeneity: They segment their analysis by city type (national central cities, regional central cities, and non-central cities) to see if the HSR's impact varies based on a city's development level.
- Auditor Heterogeneity: They differentiate between large, established audit firms (top 10) and smaller firms to assess if the HSR's influence on audit fees differs based on auditor size and reputation.
- Mechanism Testing: They specifically test the roles of audit market competition and information asymmetry by including interaction terms in their models. This helps determine which of these factors is primarily driving the changes in audit fees.
- Audit Quality Analysis: They also investigate whether the reduction in audit fees leads to a decline in audit quality, using various measures of audit quality.
Datasets
The study utilizes data from A-share non-financial listed companies in China from 2003 to 2017. This dataset is comprehensive, covering a significant period of HSR development in China.
- HSR opening data: Information on HSR routes, cities served, and opening dates was collected from official sources like http://www.china-railway.com.cn/ and http://www.nra.gov.cn/.
- Financial and corporate data: This was sourced from the China Stock Market and Accounting Research (CSMAR) database.
- Other data: Information on passenger turnover, internet usage, and airport presence was also incorporated.
- Audit firm rankings: Data on audit firm size and reputation was obtained from the Chinese Institute of Certified Public Accountants.
Key Insights and Ideas
- HSR as a Catalyst for Audit Market Competition: The most striking insight is that HSR's primary impact on audit fees is through fostering greater competition. By reducing travel time and costs, HSR makes it easier for auditors to serve clients in different regions, breaking down geographical barriers that previously favored local auditors.
- Information Asymmetry Plays a Minor Role: Counterintuitively, the study finds that HSR's ability to reduce information asymmetry does not significantly explain the decrease in audit fees. This suggests that while HSR might improve information flow, its main effect on audit costs is through direct market forces rather than better information access for auditors.
- Disproportionate Impact on Less Developed Areas and Smaller Firms: The benefits of HSR in reducing audit fees are more pronounced in non-central cities (less developed regions) and for smaller audit firms. This is likely because these areas and firms faced greater challenges due to geographical isolation and limited competition initially.
- No Trade-off Between Lower Fees and Audit Quality: A crucial finding is that the reduction in audit fees does not come at the expense of audit quality. In fact, the study suggests HSR improves audit quality, especially in non-central cities and for smaller firms, indicating that increased competition leads to more efficient and effective auditing, not just cheaper services.
Key Results
- The opening of HSR significantly reduces audit fees by approximately 2-4% on average (based on the coefficients in Table 3, column 1, which are around -0.02 to -0.04, representing a percentage reduction when exponentiated).
- This inhibitory effect is more pronounced in non-central cities (Table 3, column 4 shows a coefficient of -0.037**).
- The effect is also stronger for non-top 10 audit firms (smaller firms) (Table 3, column 6 shows a coefficient of -0.042***).
- The mechanism test confirms that audit market competition is the primary driver of reduced audit fees, while information asymmetry is not a significant factor.
- HSR opening is found to improve audit quality, as evidenced by a significant negative coefficient for HSR x Post across different audit quality measures (Table 13).
Limitations and Future Work
- Data Limitations: The study relies on data up to 2017. Further research could explore the impact of more recent HSR expansions and evolving market dynamics.
- Causality: While the DID model is robust, the authors acknowledge the need for further robustness checks, including placebo tests and controlling for other infrastructure developments, which they have largely addressed.
- Generalizability: The findings are specific to China's context. Future work could explore similar impacts in other countries with developing HSR networks.
- Specific Audit Firm Strategies: While the study shows smaller firms benefit, more granular analysis could explore how these firms leverage HSR to compete, beyond just lowering prices.
- Broader Economic Impacts: The paper focuses on audit fees. Future research could delve deeper into how HSR influences other aspects of the audit industry and corporate governance.
Summary updated