The High PMNs Phagocytosis Resistance of Enterococcal Isolates from RTx Patients

Tomasz Jarzembowski, Agnieszka Daca, Jacek M. Witkowski, Ewa Bryl, Leszek RutkowskiBioMed Research International 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates why enterococci, common gut bacteria, are a significant threat to immunocompromised patients, particularly kidney transplant recipients. Researchers found that enterococcal strains isolated from these patients are significantly more resistant to phagocytosis by neutrophils (a key immune cell) compared to strains from healthy individuals, suggesting these "high-risk" strains may contribute to infection development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Opportunistic pathogens like Enterococcus species pose a serious challenge, especially for immunocompromised individuals such as organ transplant recipients. These infections can be difficult to diagnose and manage due to often subtle symptoms. While Enterococcus is a normal gut commensal, it can cause severe nosocomial infections, particularly in patients undergoing immunosuppressive therapy. The exact mechanisms behind this increased susceptibility and virulence in these specific patient populations are not fully understood. This paper aims to shed light on one crucial aspect: the ability of Enterococcus to evade the host's immune defenses, specifically by resisting phagocytosis by polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNs), a primary component of the innate immune system.

Methods

The researchers compared the phagocytosis resistance of enterococcal isolates from kidney transplant (RTx) patients with those from healthy volunteers. They cultured these bacterial strains in both planktonic (free-floating) and biofilm forms under different conditions: standard temperature (37°C), elevated temperature (42°C), and with the addition of tacrolimus (an immunosuppressant drug) to mimic the patient environment.

To assess phagocytosis resistance, they used a flow cytometry-based assay. Bacterial cells were stained with fluorescent dyes (CFDA and PI). These stained bacteria were then incubated with isolated human PMNs. After incubation, the degree of phagocytosis was quantified by measuring the mean fluorescence intensity (MFI) of the PMNs, which indicates how many bacteria were engulfed. A higher MFI suggests greater bacterial resistance to phagocytosis.

Datasets

The study utilized two sets of enterococcal isolates:

  • RTx Patient Isolates: 36 urine and fecal isolates from kidney transplant recipients.
  • Healthy Volunteer Isolates: 17 fecal isolates from healthy individuals in the Gdańsk region.

These isolates were identified to the species level (Enterococcus faecalis) and further characterized by biochemical and resistance profiles.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • RTx Isolates are "Tougher": The most striking finding is that enterococcal strains from RTx patients exhibit significantly higher resistance to phagocytosis by PMNs compared to strains from healthy individuals, even under conditions mimicking immunosuppression.
  • Temperature Matters: Both commensal and RTx isolates showed increased resistance to phagocytosis at a higher temperature (42°C) compared to 37°C. This suggests that elevated temperatures, which can occur during infection or as part of the host response, might paradoxically enhance bacterial survival against immune cells.
  • Biofilm Formation Offers Protection: While not the primary focus, the study noted that biofilm-forming cells of commensal strains were more resistant to phagocytosis than their planktonic counterparts. This aligns with the known protective role of biofilms.
  • Immunosuppression Mimicry: The addition of tacrolimus to the culture media of commensal strains did not significantly alter their phagocytosis resistance, suggesting that direct immunosuppressive drug effects on bacterial resistance might be less critical than inherent strain properties in this context.
  • Strain-Specific Virulence: The authors propose that the observed differences in phagocytosis resistance are likely due to specific phenotypic properties of the bacterial strains themselves, rather than solely the immunosuppressed state of the host.

Key Results

  • Commensal enterococcal strains showed a higher phagocytosis index (indicating less resistance) than RTx isolates at 37°C (p=0.04).
  • At 42°C, commensal strains were more sensitive to phagocytosis than at 37°C, and also more sensitive than medical strains under the same conditions (p=0.0047).
  • Biofilm-forming cells of commensal strains were significantly more resistant to phagocytosis than planktonic cells.
  • While RTx fecal samples showed some similarities to commensal samples, urine isolates from RTx patients displayed a less pronounced difference in phagocytosis index between 37°C and 42°C.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Diagnostic Marker Limitation: The authors acknowledge that the high diversity in phagocytosis resistance among strains limits the immediate application of this finding as a direct diagnostic marker for identifying high-risk strains.
  • In Vitro vs. In Vivo: The study was conducted in vitro. The authors suggest that further evaluation using an animal model is necessary to validate these findings and better understand the in vivo implications of phagocytosis resistance.
  • Mechanism of Resistance: While the study demonstrates that RTx isolates are more resistant, the precise molecular mechanisms why they are more resistant are not fully elucidated. Future work could explore specific virulence factors or surface properties contributing to this enhanced evasion.
  • Endogenous Infection Hypothesis: The findings support the hypothesis that endogenous enterococcal strains in immunocompromised patients may possess inherent properties that make them more capable of causing infection, rather than solely being a consequence of the host's weakened immune system.

Summary updated

Abstract

Infections caused by opportunistic pathogens such as enterococci remain difficult to manage, especially in immunocompromised patients. Because of infections' limited symptoms in such patients the additional problems are to find proper diagnostic criteria and the management of infection. Here we aimed to compare the resistance of commensal enterococcal strains and RTx patients' isolates, to PMNs phagocytosis. Thirty-six enterococcal urine and faecal isolates from RTx patients and 17 faecal isolates from healthy volunteers were cultured in planktonic and biofilm forms in 37°C or 42°C. Another tested variable was the addition of immunosuppressant to the culture media. Bacterial cells were stained with fluorescent reporter (CFDA, PI) and incubated with PMNs. Results of phagocytosis were estimated as a mean fluorescence intensity (MFI) of PMNs using flow cytometry. Commensal enterococci cultured in all abovementioned (37°C and 42°C/the addition of immunosuppressant) conditions were less resistant to phagocytosis compared to RTx isolates. Observed significant difference in phagocytosis resistance suggests that patients in immunosuppression are colonized with high risk strains which may lead to the development of infection.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jarzembowski2015high,
  author = {Tomasz Jarzembowski and Agnieszka Daca and Jacek M. Witkowski and Ewa Bryl and Leszek Rutkowski},
  title = {{The High PMNs Phagocytosis Resistance of Enterococcal Isolates from RTx Patients}},
  booktitle = {BioMed Research International},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1155/2015/432579},
}
Figure