The High Latitude Spectroscopic Survey on the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope

Yun Wang, Zhongxu Zhai, Anahita Alavi, Elena Massara, Alice Pisani, Andrew Benson, Christopher M. Hirata, Lado Samushia, David H. Weinberg, James Colbert, Olivier Doré, T. F. Eifler, Chen Heinrich, Shirley Ho, E. Krause, Nikhil Padmanabhan, David N. Spergel, Harry I. TeplitzThe Astrophysical Journal 2021

TL;DR

The Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope’s High Latitude Spectroscopic Survey (HLSS) is set to map millions of galaxies to unravel the mystery of dark energy. This paper defines a "reference" survey design and uses high-fidelity simulations to show that Roman will provide unprecedentedly dense maps of the universe's large-scale structure, offering a powerful new probe of cosmic expansion and gravity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

We live in an accelerating universe, a phenomenon attributed to "dark energy," yet its nature remains one of the biggest mysteries in physics. Is it a "cosmological constant," or does it evolve over time? Does General Relativity hold on cosmic scales, or do we need a new theory of gravity?

To answer these questions, astronomers need to map the distribution of galaxies across vast volumes of space and time. While current projects like DESI (ground-based) and Euclid (space-based) are making great strides, they have limitations in depth or sampling density at high redshifts ($z > 1$). The Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope (formerly WFIRST) was designed to fill this gap. This paper establishes the technical "flowdown" from high-level science goals to a concrete survey strategy, ensuring the telescope's hardware and observing plan are optimized to deliver definitive answers about the dark universe.

Methods

The authors present a "reference" design for the HLSS and evaluate its potential through a multi-layered simulation pipeline:

  1. Survey Design: They propose a 2000 deg² survey using Roman's near-IR grism (a combination of a grating and prism) covering wavelengths from 1.0 to 1.93 µm.
  2. Galaxy Mock Catalog: To predict what Roman will see, they started with the UNIT N-body simulation (tracking dark matter) and applied the Galacticus semi-analytic model. This model simulates complex galaxy formation physics to populate the dark matter "halos" with realistic galaxies.
  3. Pixel-Level Simulations: Using the aXeSIM software, they created realistic, simulated "images" of the spectroscopic data, including effects like detector noise and overlapping spectra (confusion), to test how well redshifts can actually be measured.
  4. Cosmological Forecasting: Finally, they used Fisher matrix analysis to translate the predicted galaxy distributions into statistical uncertainties for key cosmological parameters, such as the Hubble expansion rate $H(z)$ and the growth rate of structure.

Datasets

  • UNIT Simulation: A massive cosmological N-body simulation used as the backbone for the mock universe.
  • WISP and HiZELS: Existing galaxy surveys used to calibrate the Galacticus model, ensuring the predicted counts of H$\alpha$ and [OIII] emitting galaxies match current observations.
  • Reference HLSS Mock: A newly created 2000 deg² mock redshift survey catalog, which the authors are making public to help the community prepare for Roman's launch.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Density is Key: Unlike Euclid, which covers a wider area more shallowly, Roman’s HLSS will be significantly denser (more galaxies per volume). This high density allows for much better measurements of "higher-order clustering"—looking not just at pairs of galaxies, but at more complex patterns that are sensitive to the physics of gravity.
  • The [OIII] Window: While H$\alpha$ emission is the primary target for $z=1-2$, Roman’s sensitivity allows it to use [OIII] emission to map structures at $z=2-3$. This provides a unique look at the universe when it was only about 2 billion years old.
  • Synergy with Imaging: The HLSS is designed to overlap with the High Latitude Imaging Survey (HLIS). Having high-resolution images of every galaxy that is spectroscopically measured is crucial for identifying targets and correcting for "slitless" spectroscopic effects.

Key Results

  • Galaxy Counts: The reference survey is expected to yield roughly 10 million H$\alpha$ galaxy redshifts ($z=1-2$) and 2 million [OIII] galaxy redshifts ($z=2-3$).
  • Precision Science: The survey can measure the cosmic expansion history and the growth of structure with high precision (often better than 1-2% per redshift bin).
  • Optimization Potential: The study found that a "Deep" version of the survey—covering 4000 deg² with a lower flux limit over 1.5 years—would provide the most compelling stand-alone constraints on dark energy, potentially outperforming the reference design if mission time allows.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Line Confusion: In "slitless" spectroscopy, spectra from different galaxies can overlap. A specific challenge is misidentifying H$\beta$ lines as [OIII], which can lead to distance errors. The authors are developing theoretical models to mitigate this.
  • Dust Uncertainty: The number of detectable galaxies depends heavily on how much dust is inside them, which obscures light. The paper uses two different dust models to show the range of possible outcomes.
  • Moving Target: The "reference" survey is a baseline, not the final plan. The actual HLSS strategy will be refined closer to launch (mid-2020s) to complement the results from other missions like Euclid and the Vera Rubin Observatory.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope will conduct a High Latitude Spectroscopic Survey (HLSS) over a large volume at high redshift, using the near-IR grism (1.0–1.93 μ m, R = 435–865) and the 0.28 deg 2 wide-field camera. We present a reference HLSS that maps 2000 deg 2 and achieves an emission-line flux limit of 10 −16 erg s −1 cm −2 at 6.5 σ , requiring ∼0.6 yr of observing time. We summarize the flowdown of the Roman science objectives to the science and technical requirements of the HLSS. We construct a mock redshift survey over the full HLSS volume by applying a semianalytic galaxy formation model to a cosmological N -body simulation and use this mock survey to create pixel-level simulations of 4 deg 2 of HLSS grism spectroscopy. We find that the reference HLSS would measure ∼10 million H α galaxy redshifts that densely map large-scale structure at z = 1–2 and 2 million [O iii ] galaxy redshifts that sparsely map structures at z = 2–3. We forecast the performance of this survey for measurements of the cosmic expansion history with baryon acoustic oscillations and the growth of large-scale structure with redshift-space distortions. We also study possible deviations from the reference design and find that a deep HLSS at f line > 7 × 10 −17 erg s −1 cm −2 over 4000 deg 2 (requiring ∼1.5 yr of observing time) provides the most compelling stand-alone constraints on dark energy from Roman alone. This provides a useful reference for future optimizations. The reference survey, simulated data sets, and forecasts presented here will inform community decisions on the final scope and design of the Roman HLSS.
BibTeX
@article{wang2021high,
  author = {Yun Wang and Zhongxu Zhai and Anahita Alavi and Elena Massara and Alice Pisani and Andrew Benson and Christopher M. Hirata and Lado Samushia and David H. Weinberg and James Colbert and Olivier Doré and T. F. Eifler and Chen Heinrich and Shirley Ho and E. Krause and Nikhil Padmanabhan and David N. Spergel and Harry I. Teplitz},
  title = {{The High Latitude Spectroscopic Survey on the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2021},
}
Figure