The HERA Dish II: Electromagnetic Simulations and Science Implications

Aaron Ewall‐Wice, Richard F. Bradley, David R. DeBoer, Jacqueline N. Hewitt, Aaron R. Parsons, James Aguirre, Zaki S. Ali, Judd D. Bowman, Carina Cheng, Abraham R. Neben, Nipanjana Patra, Nithyanandan Thyagarajan, Mariet Venter, Eloy de Lera Acedo, Joshua S. Dillon, Roger Doolittle, Dennis Egan, Mike Hendrick, Patricia J. Klima, Saul A. Kohn, Patrick Schaffner, J. C. Shelton, B. R. Saliwanchik, Max Tegmark, H. A. Taylor, Rusty Taylor, Butch WirtarXiv 2016 · arXiv

Abstract

We use time-domain electromagnetic simulations to assess the spectral characteristics of the dish antenna for the Hydrogen Epoch of Reionization Array (HERA). These simulations are part of a multi-faceted campaign to determine the effectiveness of the dish's design for obtaining a detection of redshifted 21 cm emission from the epoch of reionization. Our simulations show the existence of reflections between HERA's suspended feed and its parabolic dish reflector, at certain frequencies, with an amplitude of roughly $-35$dB at 100 ns which can lead to some loss of measurable modes and a modest reduction in sensitivity. Even in the presence of this structure, we find that the spectral response of the dish is sufficiently smooth for delay filtering, a proven foreground isolation technique, to contain foreground emission at line-of-sight wave numbers below $k_\parallel \lesssim 0.2h$Mpc$^{-1}$, in the region where the current PAPER experiment operates. Incorporating these results into a Fisher Matrix analysis, we find that the spectral structure observed in our simulations has only a small effect on the tight constraints HERA can achieve on the astrophysics of reionization.

Introduction: The Challenge of the 21 cm Signal

The "Holy Grail" of modern observational cosmology is detecting the 21 cm line from neutral hydrogen during the Epoch of Reionization (EoR)—the period when the first stars turned on and ionized the universe. The challenge is that this signal is buried under "foregrounds" (like synchrotron radiation from our own galaxy) that are roughly $10^5$ times brighter.

To separate the signal from the noise, astronomers rely on the fact that foregrounds are spectrally smooth, while the 21 cm signal fluctuates rapidly with frequency (and thus distance/redshift). However, if the antenna itself has "spectral structure"—ripples caused by internal reflections or resonances—it can "smear" those bright foregrounds into the frequency modes where the 21 cm signal lives, effectively blinding the telescope. This paper investigates whether HERA’s cost-effective parabolic dish design introduces too much of this spectral "dirt."

Methodology: Simulating the Time-Domain Response

The authors employed a multi-pronged approach combining simulation, theory, and hardware validation. Using CST Microwave Studio, they modeled a 14-meter parabolic dish with a suspended "sleeved dipole" feed. They simulated a plane wave pulse hitting the dish and recorded the voltage response over 500 ns. By using a "delay transform" (a Fourier dual of frequency), they mapped antenna reflections to specific physical delays, allowing them to visualize exactly where and when "echoes" occur within the antenna structure.

Schematic of signal paths and the resulting voltage response.

Key Insights: The "Knee" and Feed Resonance

The simulations revealed a "knee" in the response—a sudden increase in signal delay—at around 120 ns. Crucially, researchers discovered this wasn't caused by the dish, but by a resonance within the cylindrical skirt of the feed itself. This skirt was intended to improve beam symmetry, but it acts like a resonant cavity.

A key theoretical insight is that the impact of reflections on the power spectrum is linear with the voltage delay response, rather than quadratic. This means even small reflections (at the -40 dB level) must be carefully managed to avoid contaminating the EoR window.

Simulated delay response comparing different antenna designs.

Key Results and Science Impact

  • Reflection Levels: Reflections between the feed and dish fall below -40 dB at 150 ns.
  • Foreground Containment: Even with the resonance, the antenna response is smooth enough to contain foregrounds at line-of-sight wave numbers below $k_\parallel \lesssim 0.2 h \text{Mpc}^{-1}$. This matches the performance of HERA's predecessor, PAPER, despite HERA's much larger collecting area.
  • Sensitivity: HERA-350 is expected to achieve a $>10\sigma$ detection of the power spectrum even if the feed resonance persists. The spectral structure observed has only a small effect on the tight constraints HERA can achieve on the astrophysics of reionization, such as ionization efficiency and the minimum virial temperature of star-forming halos.

Conclusion and Future Work

This study confirms that HERA's parabolic dish design is viable for EoR science. While the antenna introduces minor spectral reflections, they are sufficiently suppressed to allow for effective foreground isolation. Future iterations of the HERA feed aim to eliminate the 150 MHz resonance while maintaining beam symmetry. Additionally, while the signal is detectable, the next major challenge lies in the extremely precise calibration required to remove foregrounds in the presence of these instrumental features.

Summary updated

Abstract

We use time-domain electromagnetic simulations to assess the spectral characteristics of the dish antenna for the Hydrogen Epoch of Reionization Array (HERA). These simulations are part of a multi-faceted campaign to determine the effectiveness of the dish's design for obtaining a detection of redshifted 21 cm emission from the epoch of reionization. Our simulations show the existence of reflections between HERA's suspended feed and its parabolic dish reflector, at certain frequencies, with an amplitude of roughly $ -35$dB at 100 ns which can lead to some loss of measurable modes and a modest reduction in sensitivity. Even in the presence of this structure, we find that the spectral response of the dish is sufficiently smooth for delay filtering, a proven foreground isolation technique, to contain foreground emission at line-of-sight wave numbers below $k_\parallel \lesssim 0.2h$Mpc$^{-1}$, in the region where the current PAPER experiment operates. Incorporating these results into a Fisher Matrix analysis, we find that the spectral structure observed in our simulations has only a small effect on the tight constraints HERA can achieve on the astrophysics of reionization.
BibTeX
@misc{ewallwice2016hera,
  author = {Aaron Ewall‐Wice and Richard F. Bradley and David R. DeBoer and Jacqueline N. Hewitt and Aaron R. Parsons and James Aguirre and Zaki S. Ali and Judd D. Bowman and Carina Cheng and Abraham R. Neben and Nipanjana Patra and Nithyanandan Thyagarajan and Mariet Venter and Eloy de Lera Acedo and Joshua S. Dillon and Roger Doolittle and Dennis Egan and Mike Hendrick and Patricia J. Klima and Saul A. Kohn and Patrick Schaffner and J. C. Shelton and B. R. Saliwanchik and Max Tegmark and H. A. Taylor and Rusty Taylor and Butch Wirt},
  title = {{The HERA Dish II: Electromagnetic Simulations and Science Implications}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1602.06277},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1602.06277},
}
Figure