The HERA-19 Commissioning Array: Direction-dependent Effects

Saul A. Kohn, P. M. Chichura, A. S. Igarashi, Austin Fox Fortino, James Aguirre, Roshan K Benefo, Tashalee S. Billings, Samavarti Gallardo, Paul La Plante, Zachary E. Martinot, Chuneeta D. Nunhokee, Paul Alexander, Zaki S. Ali, Adam P. Beardsley, G. Bernardi, Judd D. Bowman, Richard F. Bradley, C. L. Carilli, Carina Cheng, David R. DeBoer, Eloy de Lera Acedo, Joshua S. Dillon, Aaron Ewall‐Wice, Gcobisa Fadana, Nicolas Fagnoni, Randall Fritz, Steve R. Furlanetto, Brian Glendenning, Bradley Greig, Jasper Grobbelaar, B. J. Hazelton, Jacqueline N. Hewitt, J. Hickish, Daniel Jacobs, Austin Julius, MacCalvin Kariseb, Nicholas S. Kern, Matthew Kolopanis, Telalo Lekalake, Adrian Liu, Anita Loots, David H. E. MacMahon, Lourence Malan, Cresshim Malgas, Matthys Maree, Nathan Mathison, Eunice Matsetela, Andrei Mesinger, M. F. Morales, Abraham R. Neben, Bojan Nikolic, Aaron R. Parsons, Nipanjana Patra, Samantha Pieterse, Jonathan C. Pober, N. Razavi‐Ghods, Jon Ringuette, James Robnett, Kathryn Rosie, Raddwine Sell, Craig Smith, Angelo Syce, Max Tegmark, Nithyanandan Thyagarajan, Peter Kg Williams, Haoxuan Zheng, Zheng, Haoxuan2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper characterizes the polarization response of the HERA-19 commissioning array, a crucial step for future Epoch of Reionization (EoR) observations. By comparing observational data to simulations, they demonstrate that their calibration method effectively isolates foregrounds in Stokes I, but reveals significant discrepancies in polarized Stokes parameters (Q, U, and especially V), highlighting the need for improved polarized calibration.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Detecting the faint, redshifted 21cm hydrogen signal from the Epoch of Reionization (EoR) is a major goal in cosmology. However, this signal is buried under much brighter foreground emissions, primarily synchrotron radiation from our own galaxy and extragalactic sources. These foregrounds are spectrally smooth, while the EoR signal is expected to be spectrally structured. Interferometers like the Hydrogen Epoch of Reionization Array (HERA) exploit this difference by looking at specific regions in the "delay spectrum" (a Fourier transform of the frequency spectrum) to separate foregrounds from the EoR signal.

A significant challenge is polarized foreground emission, which can leak into the unpolarized EoR signal through instrumental effects and miscalibration. Faraday rotation can further complicate polarized foregrounds. For instruments like HERA, which aim to "avoid" foregrounds rather than model and subtract them, understanding and characterizing the instrument's intrinsic polarization response is paramount to avoid contaminating the EoR signal. This paper specifically addresses this by investigating how polarized signals are handled by the HERA-19 commissioning array.

Methods

The authors employ an image-based calibration technique using the unpolarized diffuse emission of the Global Sky Model (GSM) as a reference. This calibration is applied to the HERA-19 commissioning array data. They then construct power spectra for all pseudo-Stokes parameters (I, Q, U, V) to analyze the polarization response.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Image-based calibration: Instead of relying on complex redundant calibration techniques (which will be used in future HERA builds), they use a simpler approach based on the known properties of the sky.
  • Global Sky Model (GSM): This is used as a model for the unpolarized diffuse emission to calibrate the instrument.
  • Pseudo-Stokes parameters: These are used to represent the observed visibilities, distinguishing them from true Stokes parameters.
  • Power spectrum analysis: This technique is used to analyze the spectral structure of the data and compare it to simulations.
  • Electromagnetic simulations: Detailed simulations of the HERA dish and feed were used to generate instrumental Mueller matrices.

Datasets

  • HERA-19 commissioning array data: Eight nights of observational data were used.
  • Global Sky Model (GSM): Used as an unpolarized sky model for calibration.
  • Simulated data: Generated using the GSM and detailed electromagnetic simulations of the HERA instrument.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Calibration effectiveness for Stokes I: The simple image-based calibration, when applied to Stokes I (total intensity), successfully achieves qualitative redundancy between baselines and provides reasonable amplitude accuracy. This suggests the calibration is effective at removing instrumental effects that would otherwise distort the primary foreground signal.
  • Polarized leakage is a significant issue: The power spectra for the polarized Stokes parameters (Q, U, and especially V) show substantial discrepancies compared to simulations that only account for beam leakage. This indicates that instrumental effects beyond simple beam leakage are significantly impacting the polarized measurements.
  • Stokes V is highly problematic: The Stokes V power spectra are found to be highly discrepant from the expected zero power, strongly suggesting a need for more accurate polarized calibration techniques. This is a critical finding for future EoR experiments that rely on the unpolarized nature of the cosmological signal.
  • D-terms are likely culprits: The authors point to direction-independent leakage through "D-terms" of the Jones matrix as a likely cause for the excess power in Stokes V. They also suggest that relative amplitude errors in antenna-based gains could explain discrepancies in Q and U.
  • Calibration stability: The calibration procedure was found to be stable over the 8 days of observations.

Key Results

  • The image-based calibration for Stokes I shows good agreement with simulations, indicating that the calibration does not add significant spectral structure beyond what's expected from the array configuration and primary beam.
  • Excess power is observed in the linear polarization (Q and U) power spectra, which is not fully explained by primary beam leakage. This is attributed to a combination of residual calibration errors and actual polarized emission, with an estimated fractional polarization of ~10%.
  • Stokes V power spectra show a significant excess compared to simulations, indicating a substantial miscalibration. The authors estimate that D-terms are likely responsible for this, with amplitudes relative to diagonal terms around ~3-5%.
  • The calibration achieved an accuracy of about 10% for the Galactic Center observations, with about 20% variation from day-to-day.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Incomplete calibration: The calibration used is described as "incomplete," particularly regarding the D-terms, which are crucial for accurate polarized measurements.
  • Limited dynamic range: The current noise levels limit the dynamic range of the power spectra, hindering deeper probes of foregrounds and instrument response.
  • Future calibration: The authors emphasize the need for more accurate polarized calibration techniques, including the analysis of D-terms. They suggest that future HERA builds with more antennas and improved electronics will allow for deeper integrations and a wider range of k-modes, enabling more thorough characterization of foregrounds and instrument effects.
  • Understanding excess power: The origin of the excess power at a delay of ~1000 ns, seen across all polarizations, is not fully understood and requires further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Foreground power dominates the measurements of interferometers that seek a statistical detection of highly-redshifted H i emission from the Epoch of Reionization (EoR). The chromaticity of the instrument creates a boundary in the Fourier transform of frequency (proportional to k∥) between spectrally smooth emission, characteristic of the strong synchrotron foreground (the “wedge”), and the spectrally structured emission from H i in the EoR (the “EoR window”). Faraday rotation can inject spectral structure into otherwise smooth polarized foreground emission, which through instrument effects or miscalibration could possibly pollute the EoR window. For instruments pursuing a “foreground avoidance” strategy of simply measuring in the EoR window, and not attempting to model and remove foregrounds, as is the plan for the first stage of the Hydrogen Epoch of Reionization Array (HERA), characterizing the intrinsic instrument polarization response is particularly important. Using data from the HERA 19-element commissioning array, we investigate the polarization response of this new instrument in the power-spectrum domain. We perform a simple image-based calibration based on the unpolarized diffuse emission of the Global Sky Model, and show that it achieves qualitative redundancy between the nominally redundant baselines of the array and reasonable amplitude accuracy. We construct power spectra of all fully polarized coherencies in all pseudo-Stokes parameters, and discuss the achieved isolation of foreground power due to the intrinsic spectral smoothness of the foregrounds, the instrument chromaticity, and the calibration. We compare to simulations based on an unpolarized diffuse sky model and detailed electromagnetic simulations of the dish and feed, confirming that in Stokes I, the calibration does not add significant spectral structure beyond that expected from the interferometer array configuration and the modeled primary beam response. Furthermore, this calibration is stable over the 8 days of observations considered. Excess power is seen in the power spectra of the linear polarization Stokes parameters, which is not easily attributable to leakage via the primary beam, and results from some combination of residual calibration errors and actual polarized emission. Stokes V is found to be highly discrepant from the expectation of zero power, strongly pointing to the need for more accurate polarized calibration.
BibTeX
@misc{kohn2018hera,
  author = {Saul A. Kohn and P. M. Chichura and A. S. Igarashi and Austin Fox Fortino and James Aguirre and Roshan K Benefo and Tashalee S. Billings and Samavarti Gallardo and Paul La Plante and Zachary E. Martinot and Chuneeta D. Nunhokee and Paul Alexander and Zaki S. Ali and Adam P. Beardsley and G. Bernardi and Judd D. Bowman and Richard F. Bradley and C. L. Carilli and Carina Cheng and David R. DeBoer and Eloy de Lera Acedo and Joshua S. Dillon and Aaron Ewall‐Wice and Gcobisa Fadana and Nicolas Fagnoni and Randall Fritz and Steve R. Furlanetto and Brian Glendenning and Bradley Greig and Jasper Grobbelaar and B. J. Hazelton and Jacqueline N. Hewitt and J. Hickish and Daniel Jacobs and Austin Julius and MacCalvin Kariseb and Nicholas S. Kern and Matthew Kolopanis and Telalo Lekalake and Adrian Liu and Anita Loots and David H. E. MacMahon and Lourence Malan and Cresshim Malgas and Matthys Maree and Nathan Mathison and Eunice Matsetela and Andrei Mesinger and M. F. Morales and Abraham R. Neben and Bojan Nikolic and Aaron R. Parsons and Nipanjana Patra and Samantha Pieterse and Jonathan C. Pober and N. Razavi‐Ghods and Jon Ringuette and James Robnett and Kathryn Rosie and Raddwine Sell and Craig Smith and Angelo Syce and Max Tegmark and Nithyanandan Thyagarajan and Peter Kg Williams and Haoxuan Zheng and Zheng, Haoxuan},
  title = {{The HERA-19 Commissioning Array: Direction-dependent Effects}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.17863/cam.26908},
}
Figure