TL;DR
This study uses computational fluid dynamics (CFD) to investigate the hemodynamic impact of patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) management in infants undergoing central shunt (CS) surgery for congenital heart disease. The findings suggest that leaving the PDA open can offer hemodynamic advantages, such as improved blood flow distribution and reduced power loss, but a larger PDA may lead to excessive pulmonary perfusion, potentially worsening cyanosis.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Infants with congenital heart disease and insufficient pulmonary blood flow often require systemic-to-pulmonary shunts (SPS) to increase blood flow to the lungs. A central shunt (CS) is one such surgical method. However, the management of the patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) – a fetal blood vessel that normally closes after birth but may remain open in these infants – during CS surgery is not clearly defined. While closing the PDA is standard practice, some studies suggest that leaving it open might offer benefits. This paper aims to explore how the presence and gradual closure of a PDA influence the hemodynamics in patients with CS, considering different types of pulmonary artery (PA) dysplasia.
Methods
The researchers employed a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) approach to simulate blood flow. They created patient-specific 3D models of the cardiovascular system, including the aorta and pulmonary arteries, based on CT scans. These models were adapted to represent three common types of PA dysplasia (symmetrical, left PA, and right PA dysplasia). The PDA's closure was simulated by creating models with six different relative sizes, ranging from fully open (150% of the CS diameter) to completely closed (0%).
A three-element Windkessel (3WK) model was used to define the boundary conditions at the outlets of the vascular network, coupled with patient-specific aortic inflow data. The simulation used the Shear Stress Transport (SST) k-omega turbulence model and a second-order accurate numerical scheme. Key hemodynamic parameters analyzed included:
- Systemic-to-pulmonary shunt ratio (QS/A): Measures the amount of blood shunted from the systemic to the pulmonary circulation.
- Left pulmonary artery (LPA) to right pulmonary artery (RPA) flow ratio (QL/R): Assesses the balance of blood flow to each lung.
- Power loss (PL) and indexed power loss (iPL): Indicate the energy dissipated in the system, reflecting cardiac workload.
- Systemic oxygen delivery (Do₂) and aortic oxygen saturation (Sao₂): Crucial indicators of oxygen transport to the body.
- Wall Shear Stress (WSS) distribution: Examines the forces exerted by blood flow on vessel walls, relevant for thrombosis risk.
Datasets
The study utilized CT data from a 12-day-old infant with pulmonary atresia and symmetrical PA dysplasia for initial 3D model reconstruction. Additionally, statistical data on branch PA diameters from 40 infants with non-closed PDA before SPS surgery (2011-2017) from Guangdong Provincial People's Hospital were used to define the PA dysplasia models.
Key Insights and Ideas
- PDA as a "natural" shunt: Leaving the PDA open acts as an additional shunt, increasing the overall systemic-to-pulmonary blood flow (QS/A).
- Improved flow distribution: Non-closed PDA tends to equalize blood flow to the left and right pulmonary arteries (QL/R closer to 1), promoting balanced lung development.
- Reduced cardiac workload: Non-closed PDA leads to lower power loss and indexed power loss, potentially reducing the burden on the heart.
- Lower thrombosis risk: Non-closed PDA is associated with a reduced proportion of high Wall Shear Stress (WSS) areas, which are linked to platelet activation and thrombosis.
- Trade-off with oxygenation: While non-closed PDA offers hemodynamic benefits, it can lead to a lower systemic oxygen delivery (Do₂) and higher aortic oxygen saturation (Sao₂) due to increased pulmonary perfusion, which might not be ideal for reducing cyanosis.
- PA dysplasia matters: The specific type of PA dysplasia significantly influences hemodynamic parameters like QS/A and QL/R.
- Gradual closure impact: The benefits of non-closed PDA diminish as the PDA gradually closes.
Key Results
- QS/A: Decreased from approximately 0.73-0.78 (PDA open) to 0.56-0.59 (PDA closed) across different PA dysplasia models.
- QL/R: Generally greater than 1 (more flow to LPA) when PDA is closed, but non-closure was associated with lower QL/R values, closer to 1.
- Power Loss: Non-closure of PDA resulted in lower power loss (e.g., 182 mW for symmetrical PA dysplasia with PDA open vs. 288 mW when closed).
- WSS: Non-closure of PDA reduced high WSS areas by over 60%.
- Oxygen Delivery: Non-closure of PDA led to lower Do₂ (e.g., 2.19 mLo₂/s for symmetrical PA dysplasia with PDA open vs. 3.45 mLo₂/s when closed).
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- PA Dysplasia Statistics: The PA dysplasia statistics were based on a single hospital's database, which might limit generalizability.
- Geometric Diversity: The study simplified geometric variations in PA, aorta, and PDA, which can affect hemodynamics. More extensive statistical analysis is needed.
- CS Anastomosis Simplification: The CS anastomosis geometry was simplified, potentially impacting simulation accuracy.
- Fixed CFD Model: The current simulation assumes a fixed geometry. As patients grow, cardiovascular structures change, requiring updated models for long-term accuracy.
- Postoperative Follow-up: The accuracy of CFD simulations needs verification through postoperative follow-up.
Future work should involve more extensive statistical analysis of PA dysplasia, incorporating more complex geometric variations, and validating CFD results with clinical follow-up data. The authors also suggest that surgeons should consider the specific cardiovascular geometry and patient condition to tailor PDA management during CS surgery.
Summary updated