The HCP 7T Retinotopy Dataset: Description and pRF Analysis

Noah C. Benson, Keith Jamison, Michael J. Arcaro, An T. Vu, Matthew F. Glasser, Timothy S. Coalson, David C. Van Essen, Essa Yacoub, Kâmil Uǧurbil, Jonathan Winawer, Kendrick KaybioRxiv 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces the largest publicly available dataset of high-resolution 7T fMRI retinotopy data from 181 individuals, enabling detailed analysis of visual cortex organization. The authors present the experimental paradigm and model-based analysis, demonstrating high data quality and reliability, and making the data and code freely available for future research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The visual cortex, a significant portion of the human brain, is organized retinotopically, meaning it maps visual space. Understanding this organization is crucial for comprehending visual processing and for creating detailed brain atlases. While retinotopic mapping using fMRI is a standard technique, previous datasets have been relatively small, limiting the ability to study individual differences and fine-scale variations. This paper addresses this gap by providing a large-scale, high-resolution dataset that allows for more robust analyses of retinotopic organization across a diverse population.

Methods

The core of the analysis relies on fitting a Population Receptive Field (pRF) model to fMRI time-series data. Specifically, they use the Compressive Spatial Summation model, which predicts the fMRI signal based on the stimulus aperture and a 2D Gaussian representing the pRF. This model estimates parameters like the pRF's position (angle and eccentricity) and size. To ensure robustness and assess reliability, they performed analyses on both individual subjects and group averages, as well as using split-half datasets (e.g., first half vs. second half of runs). The data underwent extensive pre-processing, including motion correction, distortion correction, and alignment to a standard surface space (MSMAll).

Datasets

The primary dataset introduced in this paper is the HCP 7T Retinotopy Dataset, comprising fMRI data from 181 healthy young adults. This dataset was acquired using a 7 Tesla scanner with a 1.6-mm isotropic resolution, resulting in a substantial amount of high-quality retinotopic data. The authors also reference existing atlases, such as the Wang et al. (2015) maximum probability atlas and the Glasser et al. (2016a) multimodal parcellation, for comparison and validation of their findings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unprecedented Data Scale: The sheer size of the dataset (181 subjects) is a major breakthrough, allowing for the study of individual variability in visual cortex organization, which was previously difficult with smaller cohorts.
  • High-Quality Data Beyond Striate Cortex: The 7T acquisition and advanced pre-processing reveal reliable retinotopic signals not only in primary visual areas (V1-V3) but also in higher-level visual areas, temporal, parietal, and even frontal cortex, areas often plagued by low signal-to-noise in conventional fMRI studies.
  • Reliable pRF Estimates: Split-half analyses demonstrate strong within-subject reliability for pRF parameters, confirming the high quality and consistency of the data.
  • Open Science Approach: Making the data, stimuli, and analysis code publicly available significantly lowers the barrier for researchers to conduct novel analyses and build upon this resource.

Key Results

  • Robust Signals Across the Brain: Both group-average and individual-subject analyses revealed robust retinotopic signals in a wide range of cortical and subcortical areas.
  • Agreement with Existing Atlases: The group-average retinotopic maps show good agreement with previously published visual area parcellations, validating the dataset's accuracy.
  • High Within-Subject Reliability: Angle and eccentricity estimates showed particularly high reliability across data splits, indicating consistent spatial selectivity.
  • Identification of Visual Areas: The retinotopic maps clearly delineate known visual areas (V1-V3) and reveal organization in higher-level areas, providing a detailed map of visual processing.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Stimulus Extent: The stimulus extended to an eccentricity of 8 degrees, meaning representations of the far periphery are not well captured.
  • Edge Effects: Grayordinates near the stimulus limit may have underestimated pRF sizes and displaced centers due to edge effects.
  • Model Discretization: Model solutions are somewhat discretized, reflecting the influence of the fitting grid.
  • Non-Negative Gain Constraint: The constraint for non-negative gain might not be suitable for studying brain regions that exhibit BOLD signal decreases.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring other pRF models (e.g., difference-of-Gaussians, anisotropic Gaussians, flexible shapes) and further evaluating model accuracy. They also highlight the dataset's potential for comparing with other HCP measures, developing normative models, mapping new brain areas, and adjudicating ongoing controversies in retinotopic map organization.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract About a quarter of human cerebral cortex is dedicated mainly to visual processing. The large-scale organization of visual cortex can be measured with functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) while subjects view spatially modulated visual stimuli, also known as ‘retinotopic mapping’. One of the datasets collected by the Human Connectome Project (HCP) involved ultra-high-field (7 Tesla) fMRI retinotopic mapping in 181 healthy young adults (1.6-mm resolution), yielding the largest freely available collection of retinotopy data. Here, we describe the experimental paradigm and the results of model-based analysis of the fMRI data. These results provide estimates of population receptive field position and size. Our analyses include both results from individual subjects as well as results obtained by averaging fMRI time-series across subjects at each cortical and subcortical location and then fitting models. Both the group-average and individual-subject results reveal robust signals across much of the brain, including occipital, temporal, parietal, and frontal cortex as well as subcortical areas. The group-average results agree well with previously published parcellations of visual areas. In addition, split-half analyses show strong within-subject reliability, further demonstrating the high quality of the data. We make publicly available the analysis results for individual subjects and the group average, as well as associated stimuli and analysis code. These resources provide an opportunity for studying fine-scale individual variability in cortical and subcortical organization and the properties of high-resolution fMRI. In addition, they provide a set of observations that can be compared with other HCP measures acquired in these same participants.
BibTeX
@misc{benson2018hcp,
  author = {Noah C. Benson and Keith Jamison and Michael J. Arcaro and An T. Vu and Matthew F. Glasser and Timothy S. Coalson and David C. Van Essen and Essa Yacoub and Kâmil Uǧurbil and Jonathan Winawer and Kendrick Kay},
  title = {{The HCP 7T Retinotopy Dataset: Description and pRF Analysis}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/308247},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure