The habitability of stagnant-lid Earths around dwarf stars

M. Godolt, Nicola Tosi, Barbara Stracke, John Lee Grenfell, Thomas Ruedas, Tilman Spohn, H. RauerSpringer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology) 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The habitability of a planet is determined by a complex interplay between its formation history, interior evolution, and the changing luminosity of its host star. While plate tectonics is often considered a prerequisite for long-term climate stability, many rocky exoplanets likely operate in a "stagnant-lid" regime, where the lithosphere remains a single, unbroken shell. This study explores whether such planets can maintain habitable conditions, particularly around M-dwarf stars, whose intense early luminosity threatens to desiccate nearby worlds. By coupling 1D interior evolution models with radiative-convective climate models, we demonstrate that secondary outgassing of $H_2O$ and $CO_2$ can rebuild habitable atmospheres and oceans, even after severe initial water loss.

The Challenge of M-Dwarf Habitability

M-dwarf stars are the most common stellar hosts in our galaxy, making them primary targets in the search for life. However, they present a significant hurdle: a prolonged, high-luminosity pre-main sequence phase. During this period, which can last hundreds of millions of years, the habitable zone (HZ) is located much further from the star than its eventual main-sequence position. Planets that later find themselves in the HZ may have spent their youth under extreme irradiation, potentially boiling away their entire initial water inventory.

Stellar luminosity evolution for different stellar masses. M-dwarfs (lower curves) exhibit a long, high-luminosity pre-main sequence phase before reaching stability.

As shown in the stellar evolution tracks, low-mass stars like M-dwarfs (e.g., $0.08 M_{Sun}$) maintain high luminosity for nearly a billion years. This creates a "desiccation trap" for early-forming planets. To become habitable later, these planets must have a way to "re-water" their surfaces once the star settles down.

The Interior as a Volatile Bank

In a stagnant-lid regime, the planetary interior can act as a protected reservoir for volatiles. Because outgassing is driven by partial melting and volcanic activity—processes that occur over geological timescales—a significant portion of a planet's water and carbon can remain trapped in the mantle during the star's most violent early stages.

Evolution of mantle temperature (a) and melt fraction/depth (b) over 4.5 billion years for various initial mantle water concentrations.

The coupled interior model illustrates that mantle convection and subsequent melting persist for billions of years. As the mantle temperature evolves, partial melting (indicated by the colored regions in the depth-time plot) continues to produce crust and release trapped gases. This "delayed release" mechanism allows for the secondary outgassing of water vapor and $CO_2$, potentially forming new oceans and a greenhouse-warmed atmosphere long after the initial primordial atmosphere was lost.

Key Insights and Results

Our simulations reveal several critical factors for stagnant-lid habitability:

  • Redox Control: The width of the Habitable Zone is heavily influenced by the mantle's oxygen fugacity. A more oxidized mantle releases more $CO_2$, providing the necessary greenhouse warming to extend the HZ's outer edge.
  • The Re-watering Threshold: For planets orbiting M-dwarfs, a mantle water reservoir between 62 and 125 ppm is often sufficient to rebuild an ocean (0.05 to several tens of bars) after the pre-main sequence phase ends.
  • Continuous Habitability: Despite lacking the carbonate-silicate cycle associated with plate tectonics, stagnant-lid planets can maintain a Continuous Habitable Zone (CHZ) for billions of years through the natural balance of planetary cooling and volcanic outgassing.

Conclusion

Stagnant-lid planets are not necessarily the barren wastelands they were once thought to be. The internal "volatile bank" provides a robust mechanism for planetary recovery, especially around the galaxy's most common stars. Even if a planet is completely desiccated in its youth, the slow, steady breath of its interior can restore the conditions necessary for life, expanding our definition of what makes a world "Earth-like."

Summary updated

Abstract

The habitability of a planet depends on various factors, such as delivery of water during the formation, the co-evolution of the interior and the atmosphere, as well as the stellar irradiation which changes in time. Since an unknown number of rocky exoplanets may operate in a one-plate convective regime, i.e., without plate tectonics, we aim at understanding under which conditions planets in such a stagnant-lid regime may support habitable surface conditions. Understanding the interaction of the planetary interior and outgassing of volatiles with the atmosphere in combination with the evolution of the host star is crucial to determine the potential habitability. M-dwarf stars in particular possess a high-luminosity pre-main sequence phase which endangers the habitability of planets around them via water loss. We therefore explore the potential of secondary outgassing from the planetary interior to rebuild a water reservoir allowing for habitability at a later stage. We compute the boundaries of the habitable zone around M, K, G, and F-dwarf stars using a 1D cloud-free radiative-convective climate model accounting for the outgassing history of CO2 and H2O from an interior evolution and outgassing model for different interior compositions and stellar luminosity evolutions. The outer edge of the habitable zone strongly depends on the amount of CO2 outgassed from the interior, while the inner edge is mainly determined via the stellar irradiation, as soon as a sufficiently large water reservoir has been outgassed. A build-up of a secondary water reservoir for planets around M-dwarf stars is possible even after severe water loss during the high luminosity pre-main sequence phase as long as some water has been retained within the mantle. Earth-like stagnant-lid planets allow for habitable surface conditions within a continuous habitable zone that is dependent on interior composition.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{godolt2019habitability,
  author = {M. Godolt and Nicola Tosi and Barbara Stracke and John Lee Grenfell and Thomas Ruedas and Tilman Spohn and H. Rauer},
  title = {{The habitability of stagnant-lid Earths around dwarf stars}},
  booktitle = {Springer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology)},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.48550/arxiv.1903.07298},
}
Figure