The habitability of a stagnant-lid Earth

Nicola Tosi, Barbara Stracke, M. Godolt, Thomas Ruedas, John Lee Grenfell, Dennis Höning, Athanasia Nikolaou, Ana‐Catalina Plesa, D. Breuer, Tilman SpohnSpringer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology) 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates whether Earth-like planets without plate tectonics, known as "stagnant-lid" planets, can be habitable by modeling their long-term thermal evolution, volcanic outgassing, and resulting climate. The study finds that such planets can indeed maintain liquid water on their surface for billions of years, suggesting that plate tectonics might not be a strict requirement for habitability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The prevailing view is that plate tectonics is crucial for Earth's long-term habitability, primarily through its role in regulating climate via the carbon-silicate cycle. However, plate tectonics is a complex phenomenon, and it's unclear if it's common on exoplanets, especially the super-Earths being discovered. The "stagnant-lid" regime, where the lithosphere is a single, immobile shell, is considered a more likely tectonic mode for many terrestrial planets. This paper addresses the fundamental question: can a planet stuck in a stagnant-lid state, lacking the climate-regulating mechanisms of plate tectonics, still be habitable, meaning capable of hosting liquid water on its surface over geological timescales?

Methods

The authors employ a coupled modeling approach:

  1. 1D Thermal Evolution Model: They simulate the thermal evolution of a stagnant-lid planet's interior (core, mantle, and crust) over 4.5 billion years using parameterized convection. This model accounts for mantle melting, crust formation, and the partitioning of incompatible elements like water.
  2. Volcanic Outgassing Model: Based on the interior evolution, they calculate the release of water (H₂O) and carbon dioxide (CO₂) into the atmosphere. This involves considering the solubility of these gases in magmas and the planet's oxygen fugacity.
  3. 1D Radiative-Convective Atmosphere Model: This model takes the outgassed volatiles and the evolving solar luminosity to calculate the global mean atmospheric temperature and pressure. This allows them to determine the boundaries of the habitable zone (HZ).

The key novelty lies in the joint modeling of these interconnected processes, moving beyond isolated studies of interior dynamics or atmospheric climate.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on established physical laws and parameterizations derived from previous research and observational data (e.g., solar spectra, properties of minerals, atmospheric absorption databases).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stagnant-lid planets can be habitable: The most significant finding is that planets without plate tectonics can maintain surface liquid water for billions of years, challenging the notion that plate tectonics is a prerequisite for habitability.
  • Volcanic outgassing is key: The long-term climate and habitability are strongly controlled by the continuous outgassing of H₂O and CO₂ from the planet's interior.
  • Water solubility is a limiting factor: The high solubility of water in basaltic melts significantly limits the amount of H₂O that can be outgassed into the atmosphere, preventing the formation of a massive ocean like Earth's.
  • Oxygen fugacity controls CO₂: The planet's oxygen fugacity plays a crucial role in determining the amount of CO₂ outgassed. More oxidizing conditions lead to significantly higher CO₂ pressures.
  • Habitable Zone is dynamic: The boundaries of the habitable zone are not static but evolve over time due to changes in solar luminosity and the planet's own outgassing history.

Key Results

  • Habitable conditions at 1 AU: For an Earth-like planet at 1 AU from a Sun-like star, the models generally show surface temperatures allowing for liquid water over most of its 4.5 Gyr history, even without plate tectonics.
  • Limited water reservoir: The maximum outgassed H₂O pressure after 4.5 Gyr is typically in the range of a few to a few tens of bars, corresponding to an "ocean" much smaller than Earth's.
  • Variable CO₂ pressures: Outgassed CO₂ pressures can range from ~1 bar under reducing conditions to 100-200 bar under oxidizing conditions, significantly influencing the climate.
  • HZ width varies: The width of the habitable zone at the end of the evolution can vary non-monotonically, influenced by both CO₂ and the limited H₂O reservoir.

Limitations and Future Work

  • 1D simplification: The models are 1D, which simplifies complex 3D processes like mantle convection and atmospheric circulation.
  • No primordial atmosphere: The study assumes the atmosphere is built solely from secondary outgassing, neglecting potential primordial atmospheres.
  • Limited surface processes: The influence of surface processes like weathering and ocean dissolution on carbon and water budgets is only briefly discussed and not fully modeled.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that a more detailed modeling of surface processes, the inclusion of primordial atmospheres, and the investigation of different stellar types are necessary for a more robust characterization of planetary habitability. They also highlight the need for more dynamic climate models to better understand the HZ boundaries.

Summary updated

Abstract

Plate tectonics is a fundamental component for the habitability of the Earth. Yet whether it is a recurrent feature of terrestrial bodies orbiting other stars or unique to the Earth is unknown. The stagnant lid may rather be the most common tectonic expression on such bodies. To understand whether a stagnant-lid planet can be habitable, i.e. host liquid water at its surface, we model the thermal evolution of the mantle, volcanic outgassing of H$_2$O and CO$_2$, and resulting climate of an Earth-like planet lacking plate tectonics. We used a 1D model of parameterized convection to simulate the evolution of melt generation and the build-up of an atmosphere of H$_2$O and CO$_2$ over 4.5 Gyr. We then employed a 1D radiative-convective atmosphere model to calculate the global mean atmospheric temperature and the boundaries of the habitable zone (HZ). The evolution of the interior is characterized by the initial production of a large amount of partial melt accompanied by a rapid outgassing of H$_2$O and CO$_2$. At 1 au, the obtained temperatures generally allow for liquid water on the surface nearly over the entire evolution. While the outer edge of the HZ is mostly influenced by the amount of outgassed CO$_2$, the inner edge presents a more complex behaviour that is dependent on the partial pressures of both gases. At 1 au, the stagnant-lid planet considered would be regarded as habitable. The width of the HZ at the end of the evolution, albeit influenced by the amount of outgassed CO$_2$, can vary in a non-monotonic way depending on the extent of the outgassed H$_2$O reservoir. Our results suggest that stagnant-lid planets can be habitable over geological timescales and that joint modelling of interior evolution, volcanic outgassing, and accompanying climate is necessary to robustly characterize planetary habitability.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tosi2017habitability,
  author = {Nicola Tosi and Barbara Stracke and M. Godolt and Thomas Ruedas and John Lee Grenfell and Dennis Höning and Athanasia Nikolaou and Ana‐Catalina Plesa and D. Breuer and Tilman Spohn},
  title = {{The habitability of a stagnant-lid Earth}},
  booktitle = {Springer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology)},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.48550/arxiv.1707.06051},
}
Figure