The HAB1 PP2C is inhibited by ABA-dependent PYL10 interaction

Juan Li, Chaowei Shi, Demeng Sun, Yao He, Chaohua Lai, Pei Lv, Ying Xiong, Longhua Zhang, Fangming Wu, Changlin TianScientific 2015 · DOI

Abstract PYL10 is a monomeric abscisic acid (ABA) receptor in Arabidopsis thaliana that regulates protein phosphatase 2C (PP2C) activity. While previous literature classified PYL10 as an ABA-independent inhibitor of PP2Cs, this study demonstrates that PYL10 activity is, in fact, ABA-dependent. The discrepancy was traced to experimental interference from Bovine Serum Albumin (BSA) in commercial assay kits. Solution NMR relaxation analysis further reveals that ABA binding increases the conformational entropy and flexibility of PYL10, suggesting an entropy-driven mechanism for phosphatase inhibition.

Introduction

Abscisic acid (ABA) is a critical stress hormone in plants, mediating responses to drought and salinity. The signaling pathway involves PYL receptors binding to ABA, which then inhibit Group A protein phosphatases 2C (PP2Cs), such as HAB1. The PYL family consists of both dimeric and monomeric receptors. PYL10, a monomer, was long thought to be "constitutively active," inhibiting HAB1 even in the absence of ABA. This study re-evaluates this classification and explores the biophysical changes PYL10 undergoes upon hormone binding.

The BSA Artifact and Reclassification of PYL10

The researchers identified that the perceived ABA-independence of PYL10 was an artifact caused by Bovine Serum Albumin (BSA)—a common protein used in laboratory buffers to prevent non-specific binding. In assays conducted without BSA, PYL10 showed clear ABA-dependent inhibition of HAB1. Specifically, phosphatase activity decreased significantly as the ABA concentration increased. However, when BSA was added at concentrations typical of commercial kits (100 µg/ml), PYL10 appeared to inhibit HAB1 even without ABA, mimicking the previously reported ABA-independent behavior.

Comparison of PYL10 phosphatase inhibition with and without BSA. Panel A shows clear ABA-dependent inhibition by PYL10 in the absence of BSA, while Panel B shows how the addition of BSA masks this dependency.

Isothermal Titration Calorimetry (ITC) confirmed that PYL10 has a relatively low affinity for ABA ($K_d \approx 66 \mu M$), making the receptor particularly susceptible to interference from other proteins like BSA.

NMR Insights: Flexibility and Entropy-Driven Binding

To understand the mechanism of ABA-induced activity, the team employed high-resolution solution NMR spectroscopy (850 MHz). Contrary to the common paradigm where ligand binding rigidifies a protein, NMR relaxation measurements and reduced spectral density mapping revealed that PYL10 becomes more flexible upon binding to ABA.

The apo-form of PYL10 exhibited fewer NMR resonances (105) compared to the ABA-bound form (150), suggesting that the unbound protein is highly unstable or undergoing rapid conformational exchange. Upon ABA binding, the increased mobility of residues around the binding pocket contributes to a rise in conformational entropy ($\Delta S$). This increased "breathing" of the receptor appears to facilitate its interaction with and subsequent inhibition of the HAB1 phosphatase.

Conclusion and Future Work

By correcting the long-standing misclassification of PYL10, this research highlights the importance of buffer composition in biochemical assays. The discovery that ABA binding triggers an increase in receptor flexibility provides a new perspective on the biophysical mechanisms of plant hormone signaling, suggesting that entropy-driven conformational changes can be vital in protein-protein interactions.

While the study provides robust in vitro evidence, the role of other cellular proteins in mimicking the "BSA effect" in vivo remains to be explored. Additionally, further high-field NMR studies are needed to fully resolve the complex multi-timescale dynamics of the PYL10-ABA interaction.

Summary updated

Abstract

PYL10 is a monomeric abscisic acid (ABA) receptor that inhibits protein phosphatase 2C (PP2C) activity in Arabidopsis thaliana. Previous studies reported that the PP2C phosphatase inhibition by PYL10 was ABA-independent. Here, systematic PYL10 biochemical studies demonstrated that PYL10 activity was ABA-dependent, and the previously reported studies was interfered by the presence of BSA in the commercial kit. To investigate dynamic mechanism of how ABA binding to PYL10 induces PP2C phosphatase inhibiting activity, solution NMR relaxation analysis of apo-PYL10 and PYL10/ABA were conducted following backbone resonance assignments. Reduced spectrum density mapping of the backbone relaxation data revealed that PYL10 was more flexible in ABA bound form than apo-PYL10, indicating an increased conformational entropy upon ligand binding. Moreover, to illustrate conformation exchanges of PYL10 upon ABA binding, NMR line shape analysis was performed with increasing concentrations of ABA, and the results indicated that PYL10 backbone conformational changes occur at different time scales.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2015hab,
  author = {Juan Li and Chaowei Shi and Demeng Sun and Yao He and Chaohua Lai and Pei Lv and Ying Xiong and Longhua Zhang and Fangming Wu and Changlin Tian},
  title = {{The HAB1 PP2C is inhibited by ABA-dependent PYL10 interaction}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1038/srep10890},
}
Figure