The growth performance and meat quality of goatsfed diets based on maize or wheat grain

You Yang, Xiao Gang Li, Zhiling Sun, Tang Yang, Zhiliang Tan, Bing Wang, Xianpei Han, Zhixiong HeJournal of Animal and Feed Sciences 2012 · DOI

Abstract

A study was conducted on 24 four-month-old Liuyang Black wether goats to investigate the effects of different starch sources—maize versus wheat—on growth performance and meat quality. Over a 100-day experimental period, goats were fed diets where 25% of the total intake came from either maize or wheat grain. Results showed that while maize-based diets led to significantly higher final body weights and daily weight gains, wheat-based diets produced meat with superior marbling scores. Additionally, the fatty acid profile of the Longissimus dorsi muscle was significantly altered by the starch source, suggesting that grain choice is a viable lever for producers to manipulate meat characteristics.

Introduction

In ruminant nutrition, the source of dietary energy significantly influences metabolic processes. Maize and wheat, while both rich in starch, differ in their physical structures and ruminal fermentation characteristics. Wheat starch is highly soluble and ferments rapidly in the rumen, whereas maize starch is more resistant to ruminal degradation. This resistance allows a greater portion of maize starch to reach the small intestine, where it can be enzymatically digested into glucose—a process theoretically up to 42% more energy-efficient than ruminal fermentation into volatile fatty acids (VFAs). This study aimed to determine how these digestive differences impact the growth and meat quality of Liuyang Black goats.

Methods

The researchers utilized 24 four-month-old Liuyang Black wether goats. The goats were divided into two groups and fed diets formulated to be nearly iso-energetic and iso-nitrogenous, with either maize or wheat as the primary starch source (comprising 25% of the total diet). Diets were provided at 1.3 times the maintenance energy requirement. The trial lasted 100 days, including a 10-day adaptation period.

Key metrics recorded included:

  • Growth Performance: Initial and final body weights were measured to calculate average daily gain (ADG).
  • Carcass and Meat Quality: Five representative goats from each group were slaughtered to assess carcass weight, meat color (CIE Lab system), pH, and chemical composition of the Longissimus dorsi* (LD) muscle.
  • Fatty Acid Analysis: Lipids from the LD muscle were analyzed via gas chromatography to determine the proportions of various fatty acids.

Results and Discussion

Growth Performance and Carcass Weight

The choice of starch source had a significant impact on animal growth. Goats in the maize group achieved a significantly higher final body weight (18.2 kg) compared to those in the wheat group (17.4 kg). This translated to a higher average daily gain for the maize-fed goats (80.0 g/d vs. 72.2 g/d).

Growth performance indices of goats fed wheat or maize-based diets.

The improved growth in the maize group likely stems from the higher proportion of starch escaping ruminal fermentation. Post-ruminal digestion of starch into glucose is more efficient for weight gain. This efficiency was also reflected in carcass weights, with maize-fed goats producing heavier carcasses (9.97 kg) than wheat-fed goats (9.42 kg).

Meat Quality and Marbling

Despite the slower growth rates, the wheat-fed group showed a distinct advantage in meat quality, specifically regarding intramuscular fat deposition. The marbling score for the Longissimus dorsi muscle was significantly higher in the wheat group (3.10) compared to the maize group (2.70).

Meat quality and chemical composition of the Longissimus dorsi muscle.

This "marbling paradox" suggests that the rapid fermentation of wheat starch in the rumen may create a VFA profile that favors the deposition of intramuscular fat, even if overall energy retention for body weight gain is lower. Other meat quality parameters, such as pH, moisture, protein, and total fat content, did not differ significantly between the two groups.

Fatty Acid Composition

The starch source also modulated the fatty acid profile of the meat. Wheat-fed goats had a higher proportion of Myristic acid (C14:0; 5.32 vs 4.30 g/100g) but a lower proportion of Linolenic acid (C18:3; 1.53 vs 2.14 g/100g) compared to the maize group. These findings indicate that dietary grain selection can be used as a tool to tailor the nutritional and sensory characteristics of goat meat.

Conclusion

The study demonstrates a clear trade-off between growth efficiency and meat quality when choosing between maize and wheat as starch sources for goats. Maize promotes superior weight gain and heavier carcasses, making it an efficient choice for volume-driven production. Conversely, wheat enhances marbling, which may be preferable for premium meat markets. Producers should weigh these performance differences against the relative market costs of these grains to optimize their feeding strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

A total of 24 four-month-old Liuyang Black wether goats (100.2 kg) were allotted to two diets based on wheat and maize to investigate effects of starch sources on the growth performance and meat quality. The experimental period lasted for 100 days, including 10 days for adaptation. Five representative goats from each group were selected for slaughter on the last experimental day. The final body weight and body weight gain of goats in wheat group were lower than those of goats in maize group (P<0.05), however, the marbling score of the Longissimus dorsi of goats in wheat group was greater than that of goats in maize group (P<0.05). Fatty acid composition of Longissimus dorsi muscle was also different between wheat group and maize group, for example, the proportion of C14:0 in Longissimus dorsi muscle of goats in wheat group was greater than that of goats in maize group (P<0.05), and the proportion of C18:3 in Longissimus dorsi muscle of goats in wheat group was smaller than that of goats in maize group. Results indicate that growth performance of the goats
BibTeX
@article{yang2012growth,
  author = {You Yang and Xiao Gang Li and Zhiling Sun and Tang Yang and Zhiliang Tan and Bing Wang and Xianpei Han and Zhixiong He},
  title = {{The growth performance and meat quality of goatsfed diets based on maize or wheat grain}},
  journal = {Journal of Animal and Feed Sciences},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.22358/jafs/66133/2012},
}
Figure